What are you talking about? - course the market's OK! St Kilda East 239 Alma Road: Phillip Kingston: Bought for $1,500,000: 3 bidders (Photo Kate Agnoleto)

At 6pm on Saturday, the James Clearance Rate on the 31 auctions we covered was 58%.

Bidderman, our demand indicator of average bidders per auction, had a small rise to 1.6 bidders per auction, in part due to four volcanoes (strong auctions) including one 7 bidder auction in 28 Barrington St Kew.

These figures indicate that the market has now cooled – not frozen or falling apart, just cooled. That means we have moved into a buyers’ market, perhaps until Easter and possibly until Spring.

Well-priced homes are still selling. And there have been some surprising above-expectation results, such as 28 Barrington Kew (Glen Coutinho) which sold for $2,230,000 and, last week,Victor Road Kew (James Tostevin) at $4.1 million. But if the market doesn’t agree with initial pricing then it’s a slow, torturous journey to get a result. See our special Pass-Ins and Stales Report below.

This week we also look at the returns of serve on The Economist’s article as the ‘Experts’ hit back against the “Overpriced” headlines of last week.

This Weekend’s Market Summary:

This weekend in most places, except Boroondara, there was limited $M+ stock on offer at auction. The individual council clearance rates we report on in our market wraps could be distorted due to a) lack of auctions and b) lack of overall quality in those auctions. But this is not to imply a lack of stock in general – there are high levels of $M+ stock available across the board and Boroondara in particular is almost awash with homes on the market.

Looking specifically for a moment at Boroondara (Kew, Hawthorn, Canterbury and Camberwell), while this market may be a little out of kilter with the rest of Melbourne in terms of auction numbers, in the past few years it is a market that has shown the strongest resilience against negativity. It was affected by the GST for the shortest time, and has had the biggest price increases since. This weekend too it seemed to have a little oomph and we expect the clearance rate for Boorondara $M+ homes to be in the high 50s to low 60s.

But it does have a fight on its hands right now, with the main demand drivers (overseas buyers) reducing greatly in activity and supply to the market continuing to arrive week after week. Which means that buyers who can look beyond the headlines will find opportunities, and with the right strategies you should be in a position to push back a little against the seemingly never ending sellers’ market.

The next few weeks will be better in terms of auction quality in the top of the Top End in Boroondara. As long as those properties sell and the clearance rates stay stable, and if new stock reduces post Easter, we could move back to a balanced market. But if stock continues to come on in big numbers then the market will almost certainly remain cool with a significant change in demand sentiment.

Most of the $M+ homes on offer that sold this weekend were in the early $1 million range.

Bayside, Port Phillip, Stonnington have been quiet, with only a handful of sales in the post auction wash up from March 19th  and likewise at auction this weekend. In Port Phillip this is understandable as the Grand Prix completely extinguishes the market for almost a month. Why auction numbers are down in Brighton, Toorak and Malvern is not completely obvious – well not to us anyway. April 9th is shaping up as a Super Saturday of some sorts with almost 120 auctions in Boroondara and Stonnington combined. $M+ auctions in Bayside are still light on at the top of the Top End with mainly $1 million to $2 million homes on offer for the next few weeks leading into Easter. Most of the top of the Top End in Bayside is not going to auction.

Agent thoughts: Has the market changed since before the Labour Day weekend?
Chris Barrett, Marshall White, Hawthorn:“There have been a lot of people in the media talking about a negative change in the market since Labour day weekend, I however have found this to be unsubstantiated. As long as vendors prices are realistic and the property is presented well vendors can expect solid interest in their home.”
John Clarkson, Hocking Stuart, Brighton:“Good properties near local attractions and amenities, schools, shopping and the beach are still attracting a high level of enquiry.  Since Labour Day weekend the message is clear: If you are realistically priced you have a very good chance of selling . If you are above market perception, enquiry is reduced to a trickle.”  * For John’s full comments please see the Bayside weekly wrap.

James Special Report: Pass-Ins and Stales – The Autumn overhang build up.

We went back and re-examined all the auctions we reported on this year in 2011 and we revisited all the pass-ins, using still advertised on the net to determine their still for sale status. Please note that the table below is only connected with PASS-INS, not the homes we reported as bought before, at or just after auction on the day.

The table does make for interesting reading on the fate of a home that the market does not consider to be priced correctly at auction.

The table below shows Adjusted Clearance Rates comparing”On the Day” Clearance Rates with “On the Day plus Bought since”. Back in February 19 and 26 Pass-ins were taken up fairly quickly. However the most interesting stat is the lack of take up on Passed-in homes over the last two weeks of auctions: only 3 in 26.

• 1 of the 13 unsolds from the March 5th pass-ins and
• 2 of the 13 from the March 19th pass-ins.

This we feel confirms the view that the $M+ market started the year as balanced, but around Labour Day took a cooling direction.

What's happening Nick? Bentleigh 7 Eddys: Bought $1,312,500: 3 bidders. (Photo: David James)

James Big Issue: Agents claiming there are 100% Clearance rates in this market are just as misleading as saying the market is in freefall – both are far from the truth. Klarity Kris and Architect Adam cover it in the James Big Issue Video. Here is a summary of what they say.

• Still some surprising results. Two in particular, both in Boroondara, that stand out are Victor Avenue in Kew with James Tostevin – which sold for a hard to believe $4,100,000. Nic Franzman, Mark Dayman and Nic Ptak also from Marshall White’s result at 22 Stawell St Kew for $3,300,000. That was also a most surprising result
• We are hearing from agents 100% clearance rates – mainly due to agents feeling they need to respond to the Negativity of The Economist’s article and the Earthquakes, which for the moment have contributed to dampening demand.
• An interesting stat is that only 3 of the 26 homes we reported as passed in after auction in the last two weeks of auctions have since sold.
• We could say that 3 from 26 is reflective of the market strength – a far cry from the 100% Clearance Rate stats, BUT 3 from 26 while true, is also misrepresenting the market just as is reporting 100% clearance rates
• The market was in a balanced state pre Labour Day and as expected it is now going into a cooling phase until Easter due to increased stock levels and drop in demand intensity.

The message for buyers

• You have choice in the $3m+ range but there are still a few surprisingly strong results
• You will still have to compete relatively strongly if the home is good and well priced in that $1m to $1.5m range
• And the middle range say circle $2m to $2.5m is a bit of moving beast – the trend is not crystal clear to us at this stage.

Click on the JAMES BIG ISSUE video with Architect Adam and Klarity Kris in the middle of the home page

Media Monitor: Are Melbourne homes overpriced?

The case for being overpriced arose from The Economist’s article – which we reported on last week.  And now this week the case against those seemingly extreme overpriced by 56% headlines.

Rob Brooker head of economics from the NAB

1. Current events such as floods and Japan are affecting Melbourne short term, but long term our fundamentals are very strong.
2. Not suggesting prices are going to increase rapidly as affordability is hard pressed right now but we do have a shortage of housing stock.

His comments can be found in the excellent Kay and Burton report – sure it’s a selling tool but we listen to the expert commentary each time it’s on It’s well produced, they have credible experts and it’s relevant to our high end Melbourne market. Check it out, at least the expert comment stuff. The home fluff afterwards is up to you: http://www.kayburton.com.au/kayburtonreport

Paul Bloxham – HSBC’s chief economist for Australia and New Zealand, and a former RBA economist savages The Economist’s article stating “it’s too naive to be useful”. His main points in the Business Spectator are

1. We have an undersupply in inner city areas (totally agree with this comment)
2. Our stock is very high quality and has improved considerably over the last 20 years contributing to the increases in price paid (totally agree with this comment)
3. Very strong and improving economy (beyond our level of expertise but sounds good)

For the full article http://www.businessspectator.com.au/bs.nsf/Article/Australian-property-prices-housing-bubble-pd20110317-F24WP?OpenDocument&src=sph This was supplied by Al Craig of Jellis Craig – thank you.

‘Round the Grounds Headlines:
Boroondara- Some solid results but the trend is down under weight of stock numbers.
Bayside- Little movement on a lot of the recent Auction pass-ins
Stonnington- Small numbers of $M+ auctions today – although plenty of Top End non auction stock available
Port Phillip-With the Grand Prix – only 4 key $M+ auctions – 3 sold
More detailed analysis on our Weekly Local Council Market Wraps

Biggest Sales we can report:

• Templestowe, 9 Edwin: On the market since October of last year with Jeremy Tyrell of Fletchers. Has been bought for in excess of $4,700,000
• Richmond 37 Docker: Ken Griffith of Jellis Craig. Bought at auction, $3,300,000 – $3,500,000
• Hawthorn 23 Lisson Grove: Michael Lui of Marshall White. Bought after auction $3,600,000 – $3,800,000
• Toorak 17 Lansell, Lisa Jarrett of Abercrombys. On the market since December of last year

Biggest Sale we covered after auction: 44 Mary St Hawthorn, Antony Woodley of Marshall White. Above $2,700,000 (Undisclosed): Bought after auction, 1 bidder

Biggest Sale we covered under the hammer: 28 Barrington Ave, Kew, Glen Coutinho (Hocking Stuart), Under the hammer $2,230,000, 7 bidders (WOW)
“This Kew property did attract a crowd of 80 people, with quite a few potential buyers in the mix. The auctioneer, Glen Countinho, had to field bids from a whopping seven different bidders! Despite the light rain, the flow of the auction was quite amazing and reached the final amount of $2,230,000 before the hammer came down.” (Sonia Matmati)

Biggest Pass In: 68 Studley Park Rd, Kew, Passed in, $3,700,000
“A very pretty setting for an auction. Standing on an elevated embankment, auctioneer Richard Earle literally oversaw proceedings. He began by highlighting the virtues of this property with energy and detail. No bids came forth, however, so it was passed in for $3,700,000.”

Auction Video: This week i’ts down to Brighton with Klarity Kris at 22 Oakwood Ave, a Hocking Stuart auction with Peter Kennett. Click on the live action.

Please Note: we always ask permission to film and we always show respect at each auction. We also never video at an auction we are bidding at. If you are at an auction and don’t wish to be videoed, there are designated no-video zones. See our co-workers or ask the auctioneer.

Buyer Master Class: Klarity Kris discusses what’s necessary when buying a home when there are kids in the picture. Is it double storey single fronted or single storey double fronted!

Copyright: Mouldy Bread Picture from ChemistryWorldBlog.

We Only Buy Homes

CAMBERWELL, 8 Kingsley St: Scott Patterson (Jellis Craig) was all smiles. Bought under the hammer, $2,375,000, 3 bidders

Key Points:

• Clearance Rates are definitely not as good as we are used to in Boroondara but they are still healthy in the mid 60′s and nearly 40 homes over a million were bought this week
• Stock Surge – Large amounts of $M+ stock are hitting the market for pre Easter campaigns
• 61 Bellett Camberwell has been on the market since July of last year and was sold by Sam Wilkinson of Kay and Burton mid week for $3,100,000.
• The Balwyn formula of big block, new home, big price tag seems to have come to a grinding halt – very few high end new sales. Opportunity?
• Off markets are on the increase.

Agent Q & A

How are stock levels and what will they be like leading up to Easter?

Glen Coutinho, Hocking Stuart, Kew: “There will be a surge in stock levels with a lot of homes being booked for auction just prior to Easter which is traditionally the end of a selling season and a new group starting after the break for winter.”

Duane Wolowiec, Marshall White, Hawthorn: “With limited weekends in April due to school holidays and Easter, there are a number of vendors working overtime to have their properties ready for sale with the view to auction either on the 2^nd or 9^th of April. Some vendors may feel a little rushed to meet the deadline and may opt for a longer lead up time and expose their property as a forthcoming auction.”

BRIGHTON, 7 Yuille St: Jonathan Dixon looks for bidders and finds one. Not enough to sell under the hammer though. Passed in $2,500,000, 1 bidder

Key Points:

• Two Land Sale Volcanoes 4+ bidder auctions below:
• 11 William St Brighton with Rod Richardson of Hocking Stuart – $3,100,000 for 1383 sqm of land = $2,241 per sqm for land in central Brighton. Solid and expected result. 5 bidders.
• 5 Horton Close Brighton with Campbell Cooney of Hodges – just off the north end of the Golden Mile. – $2,055,000 for 652 sqm of land = $3,151 per sqm land for smaller parcels closer to the beach. Solid. 5 bidders.
• People do want new homes in Bayside and this is backed up by the post auction sale with Peter Kennett at 1 Hunter St Black Rock – it is what we call the almost Balwyn formula (small land and big new home) – only its not quiet as big and lavish and has a more palatable $2m price tag instead of the $3m and $4m Boroondara price tags. Black Rock $2m versus North Balwyn $3.5m -  mmmmmm
• Further supporting evidence for new homes at the right price – 91 South Road Brighton with new home package specialist Justin Follett of Kay and Burton was bought on Tuesday through an Expressions of Interest campaign for in excess of $2,600,000.

Agent Q & A

How are stock levels and what will they be like leading up to Easter?

Robin Parker, RT Edgar, Brighton: “Stock levels for good quality family homes continue to be in short supply in the sub $2 million price bracket.”

Rod Richardson, Hocking Stuart, Brighton: “We definitely have a lot ahead of us.  I wouldn’t say stock levels have dropped at all and there is a lot more for sale in the coming weeks as we approach Easter.  The past few weeks we’ve had some good results and it looks like that’s set to continue.”

Hawthorn 35 Mason: Scott Patterson and Michael Armstrong: Bought for over $3,100,000: 4 bidders

Some interesting results to finish off the month:

• 6 Teringa Place Toorak with Andrew Macmillan and Andrew McCann of Benmac was bought Sunday for an undisclosed amount over $3,500,000. House was quite serviceable but it would have also been considered as a bulldozer job placing land just under $5000 per sq metre
• 

  49 Howe Crescent South Melbourne - bought in excess of $6,000,000. Expressions of Interest - Michael Coen Hocking Stuart

  And a very quick and smart result at 49 Howe Crescent South Melbourne with Michael Coen of Hocking Stuart – due to be sold through an Expressions of Interest Campaign completing 21st March it was snapped up within a few days of advertising on the 25th of February. The result was a strong one and is undisclosed but the  quoting was over $5,000,000 and we believe in sold for in excess of $6,000,000 to give you some perspective. We do a fair bit of work in the is Expression of Interest area and this again proves that those who wait until the stated deadline do not put themselves in the best position to buy.

• 

  290 Beach Beaumaris - Len Sharp Chisholm and Gamon - Full asking price of $2,950,000 after a previously failed selling campaign.

  Private Sale at 290 Beach Road Black Rock with Len Sharp of Chisholm and Gamon for full asking price of $2,950,000. This again supports our comments that 1) Bayside and 2) New and 3) $3m (almost) price tag are a combination that is getting some runs on the board in the late Summer of 2011.

• Caulfield 20 Langdon Road – Rochelle Butt and Rodney Morley of TBM got away 1500 sqm of land plus home in Caulfield North for an amount believed to be in excess of $4,000,000. Showing that Caulfield’s prices can be Canterbury prices when the right package is sought after.

Week Ending February 26th: If last week was the season opener for the $1m+ auction market, then  this  week  was the beginning of the $3m+ auction market and the main  focus for this weekend’s report. We don’t have all this weekend’s numbers in yet, so it’s hard to call, but it seems that this upper  market cleared at 44% of the properties under the hammer. We at  James accept a slightly lower auction clearance rate on the day in this segment as indicating balanced, warm or even hot  markets, because the air is generally thinner at this level due to the lower number of bidders available at this price point, and because the pre and post auction argy-bargy is  generally greater. Today there were quite a few $3m+ homes on offer. We  think this market segment is underwhelming at present – however if it is the right price, the right property and the right position it is still being well  received and taken up.

A few of the biggies that were bought

• Armadale 23 Wattletree Road – Justin Long – 3 bidders – $3,300,000
• Hawthorn 46 Illawarra – Mark Dayman – Bought Before – $4,250,000
• Brighton 33 Middle Crescent – Jason Swift – 3 bidders – $4,300,000
• Malvern East 8 Westgarth – Andrew Macmillan – 2 bidders – Post Auction Buy a smidge under $3,000,000
• Hawthorn 45 Mason – Scott Patterson – 4 bidders – Under  the Hammer over $3,100,000
• Malvern East 118 Finch – Bought for $3,150,000
• Kew 4 Madden – Peter Batrouney – Bought After – 1 bidder – $3,050,000
• East Melbourne – John Bongiorno – 3 bidders – $3,000,000

Some of the biggies that missed the mark

• Balwyn North 15 Stephens  – 2 bidders – Passed In for $3,650,000
• Balwyn North 59 Hosken – Passed In for $4,050,000
• Toorak 44 Verdant – Passed In for $3,750,000
• Hawthorn 23 Lisson – Passed In for $3,600,000
• Toorak 231 Kooyong – Passed In for $3,500,000
• Malvern East 50 Finch  - 1 Bidder – Passed In $4,100,000

St Kilda West 49 Mary: Passed In $4,000,000 - 0 Bidders: Andrew Stuart was not in the mood for mucking around – he had an uphill battle and he knew it. An opening vendor bid of $4,000,000 immediately hushed the vibrant crowd of 120 and that was it. Game over – a half time break for show but the gate was shut. A duck for this auction. Photos by Phoebe James

Week Ending February 19th: This market is either poor or, what is more reasonable to assume, still on holidays. Mike Gibson of Kay and Burton says that most high end sellers, as advised, are waiting. Hence the quality currently on the market is average. He expects good stock at this level to come on post Labour Day and before Easter.

To support our claims that the $3m+ market hasn’t really got going yet, look at this weekend’s Pass–Ins of $3m+ properties  –

St Kilda West – Mary St – $4,000,000 –  0 Bidders
James Auction Report: See Report Above

Camberwell – Canterbury Road – $3,801,000 – 1 Bidder
James Auction Report: An air of expectation at another James Tostevin Boroondara tennis court auction. He has almost singlehandedly made them his own over the last 2 years or thereabouts. His focus has been 20000 sq ft tennis court at $6m plus. A huge crowd, around 200 with kids trampolining, people milling and cars driving by. Everybody seems to know at least one person to give a wink or a nod to. Carnival atmosphere. Then the business started – well this time it didn’t. One auctioneer bid at $3,800,000 and then surprisingly one crowd bid for $1,000 more. Small Argument – settled with pass-in to the bidder on his $1,000 bid. Inside to do battle and last check they were still banging heads. We await the result.

"You are all very naughty schoolkids and I'm going to keep you back here somebody bids." Well no, James Tostevin didn't say that but he may have been thinking this on Saturday. Camberwell 31 Canterbury: Passed In $3,801,000: 1 bidder:

Balwyn – 12 Creswick – $3,425,000 – 3 Bidders
James Auction Report: A genuine bid of $2,000,000 opened proceedings. Auctioneer Maurice Di Marzio politely accepted the bid, suggesting it was closer to land value than a sale price, before offering a vendor bid of $3,200,000. More than 150 people watched Mr Di Marzio field bids from another two bidders before passing the property in at $3,425,000. Both interested parties headed inside after the auction for further discussions.

Albert Park – 139 Beaconsfield – $3,250,000 — 0 Bidders
James Auction Report: Auctioneer David Wood from Hocking Stuart was seriously up against the elements today as he tried to make himself heard against the traffic noise and the wind coming off Port Phillip Bay. The preamble was short and to the point, before he asked for bids. No one was prepared to open the bidding and he immediately entered a vendor bid of $3,250,000. Still no response, so half time was called. After the think music was up, the question was asked again and still no bids. The property was passed in on the vendor bid.

Gowan Stubbings of Kay and Burton successful at 29 Scott Grove Glen Iris

Kooyong – 711 Toorak – $3,190,000

In fact the only auction sale over $3,000,000 we covered was 29 Scott Grove Glen Iris (Gowan Stubbings of Kay and Burton) for $3,032,000 – 3 Bidders.
James Auction Report: A triangular battle developed right from the word go, and auctioneer Gowan Stubbings orchestrated the bidding superbly to maintain momentum throughout. Only when the $3,000,000 mark was eclipsed, did one of the bidders drop out. $32,000 later and the property was secured. Good naturedly, the two bidders shook hands to acknowledge the end of the contest. A riveting event.

However a few strong private and off-market sales show this market is not completely morbid. There is still some pulse. There were three very solid such sales in Bayside this week:

Brighton Golden Mile: Scene of 2 big sales over $10,000 per sq metre in February 2011

Shandford Avenue – Nick Johnstone of JP Dixon – $7.3m for 600sqm approx – which translates to $10,000 sqm for Golden Mile beachfront

Chatsworth Avenue – Stewart Lopez of Kay and Burton – $11m+ for 1100 sqm approx – again, $10,000 sqm for Golden Mile beachfront

Kerferd Road – Andrew Stuart of Hocking Stuart – $4.9m off market – 440 sqm approx

Continuing with February Sales:

While we have seen no sales over $3m reported in Boroondara and only the long suffering and difficult to see what you can do with it 13 Como Sth Yarra finally sold (Jeremy Fox of RT Edgar) we have seen a reasonable amount of mopping up action in Brighton – a sort of summer clean out.

New and old Brightonians like to buy New in Brighton

1 Inner Crescent Brighton with Justin Follett of Kay and Burton for an undisclosed amount – proved difficult to move and while it was an impressive residence it must have been price that proved the sticking point. Having said that line it up against a number of apartments and I thought the final result was fair value.

This type of offering sold well over Summer

2 William St Brighton – cnr St Andrews –scene of the all the helicopter noise in recent weeks saw a similar offering to 1 Inner Crescent also sell –reportedly through Kay and Burton.

2a Mulgoa also with Kay and Burton and a similar offering got a lot of it’s 50% better price basically because of its golden mile location.

Another good result  in the Golden Mile this time for the dynamic duo Regina Schmidt and Brian Devlin saw another of the Glyndon apartments (no 4) bought for $3,200,000 which continues to emphasize the demand for “retiree” offerings and it shows the selling appeal for Friedrich designs.

The Buxton duo again  – 1/188 The Esplanade with waterfront views but unlike the Golden Mile also some traffic noise – bought for $3,500,000.

And finally also Buxton in Brighton – David Hart got away a very popular 62 Dendy when we  went through it (but for us main road, south facing , tight block) for a smidge under $2,950,000. And increase of just over 28% from the depths of the GFC,  2 years ago.

BALWYN NORTH, 15 Stephens St: Big, big crowd of around 300 people enjoyed the sunshine and watched Doug McLauchlan (Marshall White) in action. Passed in $3,650,000, 2 bidders

At 6.00pm Saturday, the James Clearance Rate for the 31 Million Dollar Plus Auctions we covered was 74%.  The signs are there that the market has started with a hint of warmth about it. Bidderman was at 2, the $M+ Clearance Rate was 74% and this weekend’s Hammer rate was almost one in two. That’s a market moving past warm and into “hotting up” from a stats point of view. But the stock quality overall was high and you would expect to see an elevated clearance rate this weekend. However a lot of new stock has come on this week and the market may be in for a sustained period of potential Super Saturdays in March and April. This will really test whether the warmth we saw this weekend was an underlying hotting up or some temporary New Year afterglow. Overall our read on the current early opening $M+ market: Nicely Balanced.

New Stock:
With 202 new million dollar plus homes listed this week, March and April (the pre-Easter market) is looking like it will have a few potential Super Saturdays. And as we know, large numbers cool anything but the hottest of hot markets. So overall we are still calling the early 2011 market as we did last week: healthy, nicely balanced and starting as well as you could reasonably expect.

Bidderman:
Indicating the average bidders per auction, was at 2. Although that is up on last week statistically, to us it basically says steady as she goes. Last week had lower quality homes on offer (than average across the board), while this week was above average. Bidderman at 2 says “healthy market”. Please note though that if this were to be maintained in the pre-Easter market there would be upwards pressure on price. But with increasing stock levels coming on, significant upwards price pressure in this pre-Easter time seems less than likely. Did we say this early market seems balanced?

Crowds:
All agents have reported significant increases in human traffic through their OFIs (Open for Inspections) and on Saturday we reported six auctions with over 100 people in attendance. All auctions had good numbers watching.

Hammer Rate:
Almost one in two sold under the hammer – that is strong. Well done to vendors and buyers alike – this is what auctions are all about: selling and buying.

Ducks on the Pond:
Very few no-bidder auctions this weekend and they were mainly in that $3m+ segment.

Round the Grounds – $Million+ Snapshot from our Market Reports

Bayside – Overall Clearance Rate solid for Brighton – 77%

Stonnington – Nearly everything sold in Malvern and Malvern East, but what happened in South Yarra?

Boroondara – Big crowds but there is an underlying agent nervousness in Boroondara

Port Phillip – Lacklustre on what we saw – but still at 60% Clearance Rate

Rest of Melbourne – The fringe $1 million plus market is small but active

$3m+ properties:
If last week was the season opener for the $1m+ auction market, then this week was the beginning of the $3m+ auction market and the main focus for this weekend’s report. We don’t have all this weekend’s numbers in yet, so it’s hard to call, but it seems that this upper market cleared at 44% of the properties under the hammer. We at James accept a slightly lower auction clearance rate on the day in this segment as indicating balanced, warm or even hot markets, because the air is generally thinner at this level due to the lower number of bidders available at this price point, and the pre and post auction argy-bargy is generally greater. Today there were quite a few $3m+ homes on offer. We think this market segment is underwhelming at present – however with the right price, the right property, and the right position, it is still being well received and taken up.

A few of the biggies that were bought

• Armadale 23 Wattletree Road – Justin Long – 3 bidders – $3,300,000
• Hawthorn 46 Illawarra – Mark Dayman – Bought Before – $4,250,000
• Brighton 33 Middle Crescent – Jason Swift – 3 bidders – $4,300,000
• Malvern East 8 Westgarth – Andrew Macmillan – 2 bidders – Post Auction Buy a smidge under $3,000,000
• Hawthorn 45 Mason – Scott Patterson – 4 bidders – Under  the Hammer over $3,100,000
• Malvern East 118 Finch – Bought for $3,150,000
• Kew 4 Madden – Peter Batrouney – Bought After – 1 bidder
• East Melbourne – John Bongiorno – 3 bidders – $3,000,000

Some of the biggies that missed the mark

• Balwyn North 15 Stephens  – 2 bidders – Passed In for $3,650,000
• Balwyn North 59 Hosken – Passed In for $4,050,000
• Toorak 44 Verdant – Passed In for $3,750,000
• Hawthorn 23 Lisson – Passed In for $3,600,000
• Toorak 231 Kooyong – Passed In for $3,500,000
• Malvern East 50 Finch  - 1 Bidder – Passed In $4,100,000

More analysis on Bayside’s summer market can be found in our February $3m+ market report. New and old Brightonians like to buy New in Brighton- see the trend!

Are sellers missing out on Bidders and ultimately better prices because of Sargeants Conveyancing?
A number of  potential bidder’s lawyers will not allow their clients to bid on homes with unmodified Sargeants contracts. Yes this company provides cheap contracts but with completely unacceptable additional Special Condition clauses which buyers cannot agree to. Sargeants is putting not only potential buyers but their vendors into difficult positions. Sargeants are stripping away buyers’ already very limited basic property rights – but that is not good for the sellers either when buyers don’t bid. We do not bid on homes that have unmodified Sargeants contracts – not because we are on some moral crusade (hey we are buyer agents) but because our clients’ solicitors won’t let us. Sellers, our clients money is good money, this weekend we bought 4 from 4 at auction over a million dollars – maybe we didn’t bid on yours because you had an unmodified Sargeants contract.

"Rebel With a Cause" Jason Swift in Action at 33 Middle Crescent Brighton - see below

Biggest Sale: 33 Middle Crescent, Brighton, Jason Swift (Hodges); Bought under the hammer, $4,300,000, 3 bidders
“Hey start me where you like – somebody bounce my ball” cried out the cockney accent of Jason Swift. I loved this auction; it was entertaining , bold and good ‘ol fashion fun. Jason Swift gave us piles of corn, humour, clichés and he gave the auction something else – character and the more important – momentum . At first you might think, hmmm bit strange – bloody Pom doing an auction – but mate he’s as Aussie as Jack Thompson and I loved the way he auctioned this home. The crowd was spread out – the vendor wanted a big but not ridiculous number and with good work pre-auction and a classy performance on the day, Hodges got what their client wanted. Well done Jason; I’m not sure how many people know just how good that was – bringing a crowd with you at this level is what only a few can do well. That was definitely a 2 hat performance. Opened at $3,000,000; on market at $4,200,000 concluding under the hammer at $4,300,000. Great theatre and a great way to finish the day.”

Biggest Pass In: 50 Finch St, Malvern East, John Bongiorno (Marshall White); Passed in $4,100,000, 1 bidder
“What a turnout for this auction! It looked like the whole neighbourhood had turned up, with a crowd of 200 watching auctioneer John Bongiorno in action. However, despite the buzz and the anticipation from the crowd, you could really tell that most of them were there just to sightsee as when the time came for an opening bid all was quiet. An opening vendor bid of $4,000,000 never really got things going, while a late bid from one member of the crowd was all the action that was seen and with that the property was passed in. A lot of people stayed though, either to catch up with each other or to see whether the lone bidder was successful in post-auction negotiations.”

Bidderbuzz Auction: 35 Mason St, Hawthorn, Scott Patterson (Jellis Craig); under the hammer, in excess of $3,100,000. 4 bidders
“A big crowd of around 125 gathered for this Jellis Craig/Kay and Burton auction with Scott Patterson and Michael Armstrong managing proceedings. You could feel there were a lot of bidders ready to go and after a perfectly timed intro form Scott Patterson we were away with a $2,750,000 opening bid. On the market at $3,100,000 and bought under the hammer for an undisclosed price in excess of that. A strong auction and numerous other disappointed bidders didn’t get a look in. This is a good home and so the market is saying good properties will be well supported.”

What the key agents said about the current market:
Geoff Hall, Noel Jones, Camberwell: “Motivated vendors are good right now – we are listing well but buyers seem a little thin on the ground. We think right now there is one buyer for every home and on some homes when we find that buyer we are trying our hardest to put it away. I think last week the market started in balance.”

Tim Heavyside of Fletchers: “Most homes are selling on the day or shortly afterwards – a number are not flying – but they are selling. A lot of stock is about to hit the market in April, after sellers became a bit nervous about entering the market late last year and held their sale up. Now a number of them have decided to sell and consequently we are seeing a stock build up.”

Campbell Cooney of Hodges: “Things firmed up in the market just before Xmas with some difficult homes having price adjustments and selling.  Since January we have had double our normal numbers through OFIs, for instance a normal home where we were having 7 or 8 groups through in November is now having 15 groups through at each inspection.

Both Scott Patterson of Jellis Craig and John Bongiorno of Marshall White reported 70% approx. clearance rates on largish auction stock numbers. Both agree the market is certainly not hot – but it’s not weak either, except possibly at the higher end.

Auction Video: This week we head to sunny Brighton, where we watch Nick Johnstone in action at 2 Maher St. Click on the live action. Apologies – we are in the middle of creating a three video connection each week: Big Issue – Auction Video – Sunday Reflections. There may be some technical difficulties while we put this new automated system in over the next week.

Please Note: we always ask permission to film and we always show respect at each auction. We also never video at an auction we are bidding at. If you are at an auction and don’t wish to be videoed, there are designated no-video zones. See our co-workers or ask the auctioneer.

Buyer Masterclass: We thought a bit of poetry was in order and while we couldn’t contact Banjo we got his relative Cal Bung to pen us some words.

We Only Buy Homes

Hawthorn 35 Mason: Scott Patterson and Michael Armstrong: Bought for over $3,100,000: 4 bidders

Week Ending February 26th: If last week was the season opener for the $1m+ auction market, then this week was the beginning of the $3m+ auction market and the main focus for this weekend’s report. We don’t have all this weekend’s numbers in yet, so it’s hard to call, but it seems that this upper market cleared at 44% of the properties under the hammer. We at James accept a slightly lower auction clearance rate on the day in this segment as indicating balanced, warm or even hot markets, because the air is generally thinner at this level due to the lower number of bidders available at this price point, and because the pre and post auction argy-bargy is generally greater. Today there were quite a few $3m+ homes on offer. We think this market segment is underwhelming at present – however if it is the right price, the right property and the right position it is still being well received and taken up.

A few of the biggies that were bought

• Armadale 23 Wattletree Road – Justin Long – 3 bidders – $3,300,000
• Hawthorn 46 Illawarra – Mark Dayman – Bought Before – $4,250,000
• Brighton 33 Middle Crescent – Jason Swift – 3 bidders – $4,300,000
• Malvern East 8 Westgarth – Andrew Macmillan – 2 bidders – Post Auction Buy a smidge under $3,000,000
• Hawthorn 45 Mason – Scott Patterson – 4 bidders – Under  the Hammer over $3,100,000
• Malvern East 118 Finch – Bought for $3,150,000
• Kew 4 Madden – Peter Batrouney – Bought After – 1 bidder – $3,050,000
• East Melbourne – John Bongiorno – 3 bidders – $3,000,000

Some of the biggies that missed the mark

• Balwyn North 15 Stephens  – 2 bidders – Passed In for $3,650,000
• Balwyn North 59 Hosken – Passed In for $4,050,000
• Toorak 44 Verdant – Passed In for $3,750,000
• Hawthorn 23 Lisson – Passed In for $3,600,000
• Toorak 231 Kooyong – Passed In for $3,500,000
• Malvern East 50 Finch  - 1 Bidder – Passed In $4,100,000

St Kilda West 49 Mary: Passed In $4,000,000 - 0 Bidders: Andrew Stuart was not in the mood for mucking around – he had an uphill battle and he knew it. An opening vendor bid of $4,000,000 immediately hushed the vibrant crowd of 120 and that was it. Game over – a half time break for show but the gate was shut. A duck for this auction. Photos by Phoebe James

Week Ending February 19th: This market is either poor or, what is more reasonable to assume, still on holidays. Mike Gibson of Kay and Burton says that most high end sellers, as advised, are waiting. Hence the quality currently on the market is average. He expects good stock at this level to come on post Labour Day and before Easter.

To support our claims that the $3m+ market hasn’t really got going yet, look at this weekend’s Pass–Ins of $3m+ properties  –

St Kilda West – Mary St – $4,000,000 –  0 Bidders
James Auction Report: See Report Above

Camberwell – Canterbury Road – $3,801,000 – 1 Bidder
James Auction Report: An air of expectation at another James Tostevin Boroondara tennis court auction. He has almost singlehandedly made them his own over the last 2 years or thereabouts. His focus has been 20000 sq ft tennis court at $6m plus. A huge crowd, around 200 with kids trampolining, people milling and cars driving by. Everybody seems to know at least one person to give a wink or a nod to. Carnival atmosphere. Then the business started – well this time it didn’t. One auctioneer bid at $3,800,000 and then surprisingly one crowd bid for $1,000 more. Small Argument – settled with pass-in to the bidder on his $1,000 bid. Inside to do battle and last check they were still banging heads. We await the result.

"You are all very naughty schoolkids and I'm going to keep you back here somebody bids." Well no, James Tostevin didn't say that but he may have been thinking this on Saturday. Camberwell 31 Canterbury: Passed In $3,801,000: 1 bidder:

Balwyn – 12 Creswick – $3,425,000 – 3 Bidders
James Auction Report: A genuine bid of $2,000,000 opened proceedings. Auctioneer Maurice Di Marzio politely accepted the bid, suggesting it was closer to land value than a sale price, before offering a vendor bid of $3,200,000. More than 150 people watched Mr Di Marzio field bids from another two bidders before passing the property in at $3,425,000. Both interested parties headed inside after the auction for further discussions.

Albert Park – 139 Beaconsfield – $3,250,000 — 0 Bidders
James Auction Report: Auctioneer David Wood from Hocking Stuart was seriously up against the elements today as he tried to make himself heard against the traffic noise and the wind coming off Port Phillip Bay. The preamble was short and to the point, before he asked for bids. No one was prepared to open the bidding and he immediately entered a vendor bid of $3,250,000. Still no response, so half time was called. After the think music was up, the question was asked again and still no bids. The property was passed in on the vendor bid.

Gowan Stubbings of Kay and Burton successful at 29 Scott Grove Glen Iris

Kooyong – 711 Toorak – $3,190,000

In fact the only auction sale over $3,000,000 we covered was 29 Scott Grove Glen Iris (Gowan Stubbings of Kay and Burton) for $3,032,000 – 3 Bidders.
James Auction Report: A triangular battle developed right from the word go, and auctioneer Gowan Stubbings orchestrated the bidding superbly to maintain momentum throughout. Only when the $3,000,000 mark was eclipsed, did one of the bidders drop out. $32,000 later and the property was secured. Good naturedly, the two bidders shook hands to acknowledge the end of the contest. A riveting event.

However a few strong private and off-market sales show this market is not completely morbid. There is still some pulse. There were three very solid such sales in Bayside this week:

Brighton Golden Mile: Scene of 2 big sales over $10,000 per sq metre in February 2011

Shandford Avenue – Nick Johnstone of JP Dixon – $7.3m for 600sqm approx – which translates to $10,000 sqm for Golden Mile beachfront

Chatsworth Avenue – Stewart Lopez of Kay and Burton – $11m+ for 1100 sqm approx – again, $10,000 sqm for Golden Mile beachfront

Kerferd Road – Andrew Stuart of Hocking Stuart – $4.9m off market – 440 sqm approx

Continuing with February Sales:

While we have seen no sales over $3m reported in Boroondara and only the long suffering and difficult to see what you can do with it 13 Como Sth Yarra finally sold (Jeremy Fox of RT Edgar) we have seen a reasonable amount of mopping up action in Brighton – a sort of summer clean out.

New and old Brightonians like to buy New in Brighton

1 Inner Crescent Brighton with Justin Follett of Kay and Burton for an undisclosed amount – proved difficult to move and while it was an impressive residence it must have been price that proved the sticking point. Having said that line it up against a number of apartments and I thought the final result was fair value.

This type of offering sold well over Summer

2 William St Brighton – cnr St Andrews –scene of the all the helicopter noise in recent weeks saw a similar offering to 1 Inner Crescent also sell –reportedly through Kay and Burton.

2a Mulgoa also with Kay and Burton and a similar offering got a lot of it’s 50% better price basically because of its golden mile location.

Another good result  in the Golden Mile this time for the dynamic duo Regina Schmidt and Brian Devlin saw another of the Glyndon apartments (no 4) bought for $3,200,000 which continues to emphasize the demand for “retiree” offerings and it shows the selling appeal for Friedrich designs.

The Buxton duo again  – 1/188 The Esplanade with waterfront views but unlike the Golden Mile also some traffic noise – bought for $3,500,000.

And finally also Buxton in Brighton – David Hart got away a very popular 62 Dendy when we  went through it (but for us main road, south facing , tight block) for a smidge under $2,950,000. And increase of just over 28% from the depths of the GFC,  2 years ago.

Will we see last year's crowd numbers return for the opening of the 2011 auction season this weekend? Find out at marketnews.com.au on February 19th at 6pm.

Welcome to Million Dollar Melbourne in 2011

With the Auction Season Opener hitting us between the eyes on February 19, we know that the big question for buyers, sellers and agents is: What is going to happen in 2011?

The feeling in late 2010 was that the market was cooling and we shared that view on price – but we did not share that view on activity. The December market finished quite strongly activity wise.

What’s been happening so far in 2011?

During the last week in Jan, I personally went to 10 homes over $1million in Boroondara (Kew, Hawthorn, Balwyn, Canterbury etc). I was a little surprised at the solid numbers of people inspecting at all opens.

This past weekend (the first full one in February) I focused on Bayside, mainly Brighton, and it was very quiet, very different – with very few people.  The exceptions were 62 Dendy St (David Hart) – a new home on a busy street; a big home at 33 Middle Crescent (Campbell Cooney) and a great little home at 26 Moffat  (David Wilson). Why this last one hasn’t flown out the door yet I don’t know – we gave it a rating over 800. The other seven opens were poorly attended.

Flooding may have been one reason for the reduced activity in Bayside – this was only a few hours after that incredible rain. There were a number of cancelled opens due to inundation (a word we are hearing all too often at the moment) of garages.

Even so there is still plenty happening at Bayside’s Top End. 33 Chatsworth Brighton with 1300 sqm of absolute beachfront has just sold (with Stewart Lopez and Ian Jackson of Kay and Burton) for an undisclosed sum (we reckon around $12 million). And another property on the Golden Mile beachfront at Shandford Ave, with about 600 sqm, reportedly sold for north of $7 million with Nick Johnstone of JP Dixon. So  Bayside Top End is not exactly dead yet.

Next week we have a full book of inspections at quality homes on and off market in Stonnington. Look out for our reports.

So back to the season opener on February 19. This will be the first real public test of the auction market. What sort of stock numbers are out there at the moment?

Last year we used 100 auctions as the definition of a big Saturday. We had four of them in a row at the end of the year, after a very slow start to Spring caused by the election and then the election result uncertainty.

This February 19 sees 74 auctions scheduled – a solid start without setting the world on fire. It is February 26 that provides us with our first real 2011 benchmark with over 120 homes under the hammer. We think that weekend will be the first of about a dozen benchmark auction days we will have through 2011..

So what are the results we are looking at and what will they mean?

Bidderman, our bidders per auction indicator, is an important guide of demand. With Bidderman dropping to around 1 late last year we saw prices drop. A similar number on the first Super Saturday will not be a good sign for sellers especially because there is good stock quality on both auction days (hence no excuses), so a low Bidderman will indicate a genuine lack of interest. If that were to continue we would definitely see a drop in prices. Of course it will be a different result if Bidderman averages more than 2 bidders per auction.

The other important measure is clearance rates. These strengthened towards the end of last year –  not because buyers went berserk but because sellers were forced to meet the diminished market conditions. We had a “strongish” late market because of seller flexibility.

What will the clearance rate numbers mean? If the clearance rates at for these two auction Saturdays are in the 50% range we would consider the market to be soft, marking the beginning of a buyers’ market. If clearance rates are between 60 and 70% for both weekends then it’s fairly balanced. If the clearance rate is around or more than70% then the market noise would be strong and, depending on stock levels going forward, prices may move upwards.

CAV slackens off on Conflict Of Interest issue

One item of news that has snuck under the radar is Consumer Affairs slackening off of the old Section 55 of the Estate Agents Act. This set out a rigorous process in cases where agents want to buy vendors’ homes that are being handled by their own agency, for instance where a Hocking Stuart agent is buying a Hocking Stuart advertised property. Consumer Affairs has severely diluted the strength of the legislation by saying it no longer requires an independent valuation and that an unqualified representative can sign off like a lawyer or an accountant.

This dilution is dangerous and is being driven by either ignorance or laziness on the part of CAV. Selling agents are not asking for it; in fact many ethical agents abhor CAV actions in this matter. We all need checks and balances.

The Consumer watchdog has abrogated its responsibilities, leaving vulnerable old ladies and others to be taken for a ride.

We don’t think agents should be allowed to buy a property handled by the agency they work for at all – there is just too much conflict of interest. But if the law and CAV allows this to continue there MUST be rigorous checks and balances in place to protect the vulnerable.

Imagine if the police weakened their stance on fraud because they wanted to streamline their paperwork. This is not good enough CAV.

On a lighter note, over this year 2011 we will be bringing you even more information, more sold results, more stats, and more detailed analysis.

We will also be back to the job we love most – buying great properties for our clients. After one week back, we’ve already made our first client home purchase for a property in Thomas St Hampton. After six weeks away with the kids  - we need to get our sanity back. So bring on those auctions.

Buy Well.

Tim Wilson and Jeremy Fox get ready to do battle at 2 Bromley Toorak, but in the end there were not in the trenches and they stood there as generals and watched 3 bidders slug it out to $5,600,000 - $800,000 over reserve.

Week Ending November 27th:

The high end ($3m+) which like the proverbial brides nightie (not sure if I can say that) is up and down at the drop of a hat. A fortnight ago it was up and last week it was down – this week it was up and in a big way – below are some of the results.

Highlights:

• Toorak 2 Bromley with Jeremy Fox of RT Edgar for 5,600,000 – 3 bidders (see report)
• Hampton 3 Lorraine for over $3,000,000 with Nick Johnstone of JP Dixon (Expression of Interest)
• Armadale Adelaide (Off Market)
• Hawthorn 41 Wattle Road – good home on the market for some time bought for well over $5,000,000 through Paul Keane Jellis Craig
• South Yarra 2/155 Domain Road Marcus Chiminello of Marshall White bought for in excess of $7,500,000 or $20,000 per square metre  (Off Market)
• Toorak 88 Mathoura Road for $6,500,000 bought before – also Marcus Chiminello
• Armadale 12 Munro with Tim Derham, passed in at auction last weekend at $3,000,000 and has been bought afterwards.

$3m+ not so highlights:

• Brighton 12a Manor: Passed In $3,800,000: Zero Bidders
• Hawthorn 5 Yarra: Passed In $4,500,000: Zero Bidders
• South Yarra 16 William: Passed In $4,200,000: Zero Bidders
• Canterbury 35 Logan: Passed In for $2,860,000: Zero bidders

South Melbourne 9 Anderson: An exciting auction which had a buzz from the crowd, trams, birds and sounds of people playing sport down the street at the Melbourne Sports And Aquatic Centre. Geoff Cayzer was auctioneer and, although soft spoken, he was very entertaining with his humour and pre-auction speech. This lightened the atmosphere and allowed two bidders to fight it out after Mr Cayzer's opening bid of $2,850,000. The battle wasn't long though as after some 5 bids the hammer was brought down and the property sold for $3,250,000, which brought cheers and jubilation from the winning bidder's party. A great, fun and entertaining auction to watch.

Week Ending November 20th:

This market seems clear as mud in terms of short term directional pointers. Some good ones sold, some good ones didn’t and all on a turnover down on this time last year and down on September of this year. But the market hasn’t stopped completely in its tracks eg 50 Charles Kew with Paul Keane of Jellis Craig – going nowhere for some time then some interest, then bang a boardroom auction and well north of $4,200,000 was achieved on the night. On the quiet side, a second off market north of $13,000,000 in recent times – actually it was over $15million and in establishment Toorak – Mike Gibson from Kay and Burton the selling agent.

$3M+ Highlights

• Malvern 116 Stanhope: Paul Keane of Jellis Craig. Bought for just under $3,500,000
• South Melbourne 9 Anderson: Geoff Cayzer. Bought under the hammer for $3,250,000: 2 bidders
• Ivanhoe 9 Nyorie: David Oster of Jellis Craig. Bought after auction for $3,100,000: 2 bidders

$3M+ not so Highlights:

• East Melbourne 105 George: Passed In on a vendor bid for $4,500,000
• Malvern 1 Wilks: Passed In on a vendor bid for $3,000,000
• Armadale 12 Munro: Passed In on a vendor bid for $3,000,000

Great Expectations but in the end it was more like Bleak House as 50 Hotham Melbourne East failed to sell under the hammer. Passed In for $7,000,000. Glen Coutinho of Hocking Stuart

Week Ending November 13th:

………But this new state of affairs does not apply so much to the $3m+ market which was a little less shiny today after shining like a beacon 7 days ago. In fact there were a number of significant pass-ins at this level this weekend.

So in a nutshell: last week’s doom and gloom on low quality stock and a negative feel mid-week at open-for-inspections was followed by a bit of a bounce-back this weekend – with more homes selling than expected. But that’s not to say it’s a strong sellers market by any stretch of the imagination. At present the market is, in our opinion, between cool and warm, depending on the quality of the stock. We await with interest next week’s instalment as to where our late Spring market is heading.

Highlights

• 32 Linlithgow, Toorak (Jeremy Fox of RT Edgar) was the biggest sale of the day (see report below)
• 4 Snowden, Canterbury (James Tostevin and Duane Wolowiec of Marshall White), Bought after at an undisclosed price of more than $3,000,000.
• 35 Cole St Brighton (Ian Jackson of Kay and Burton), Bought at auction for a shade over $3,500,000 – after not selling at an Expressions of Interest campaign earlier in the year

Lowlights

• The weather
• Biggest Pass-In was at 50 Hotham East Melbourne, a great home with an 800+ James Rating. It failed to attract any bidding near the reserve and was passed in at $7,000,000
• $3M+ pass-ins at 188 The Esplanade Brighton, 3 Buley Hawthorn East, 18 Heyington and 12 Merriwee Toorak

Camberwell 18 Currajong: 3 bidders, 3 advocates and one great auction: Maurice Di Marzio: Bought under the hammer for $3,375,000

Week Ending November 6th:

What a difference a month and some increased stock levels make. If you have a look at our $3m section in October and compare it to our September report you will see a big difference in activity, especially when you consider the market had a clean run in October with no election and limited footy interruptions, and had five

Click on video to see $3m auctions live

auction Saturdays. This market is as fickle as the horse race we love to watch. In Winter this market was down, in September it definitely perked up and now the $3m+ and off-markets would appear to be edging downwards again. But again the statistics are hiding the full story: there were in fact a few sales over this level we have been asked not to report on, and we ourselves have purchased four off-markets over $1million in the last month, in Brighton, Clifton Hill, Hawthorn and Caulfield. Plus look at this weekend’s $3m+ results! The fact is, there is still plenty of activity – just not as public as in September. There are good homes available for sale off market if you know where to look.

• Elwood 45 Dickens: Jason Scillio: Under Hammer: $3,535,000:  3 bidders
  A large crowd gathered in the front garden of this magnificent property to hear Jason Scillio provide a well prepared preamble prior to inviting bids from a large crowd on this beautiful afternoon. After the usual hesitation, strong bidding emerged from three buyers and it was on the market at $3,450,000. The house was soon bought with a strong bid $3,535,000. (David James)

• Carlton North 810 Drummond:  Tom Roberts:  Under Hammer  $3,450,000:  3 bidders
  What a home. This is the best example of the saying ‘don’t judge a book by its cover’.  It is an ugly duckling from the street, but when you walk through the door you’re hit with one of the most stunning living area renovations I have seen in Inner Melbourne. The auction itself started with a pretend bid at $2,000,000 that was immediately countered by auctioneer Tom Roberts with a vendor bid at $3,000,000 and she took off from there. Three bidders and on the market at $3,300,000 before settling at $3,450,000 in front of a crowd of 125.

• Toorak 6 Benson: Gowan Stubbings: Bought around $3,000,000: 3 bidders
  A great auction to watch. Auctioneer Gowan Stubbings led the way, offering a vendor bid of $2,400,000 after a member of the crowd offered an initial bid of $2,350,000. With three bidders overall, it became a battle between two very confident, strong parties, both determined to fight it out to the very end. One bidder offered increments of $10,000 and even $100,000, while the other settled on $1000 increments each time. Ultimately, the $1000 bidder won, walking away with the property for an undisclosed amount close to $3,000,000. A very entertaining auction with a crowd of around 60. (Jen Milligan)

• Some solid results outside Saturday’s auction:
  Toorak 63 St Georges: Andrew Baines of Kay and Burton: Expression of Interest for just under $8 million. Went through this home and tennis court.It had a good feel and, just as the ad says, an exclusive street address. At around $4,000 per sqm it was a win for the buyer and seller.
  Two blocks of flats sold at mid week auctions: South Yarra 28 Tivoli ($4,825,000)  Philippe Batters: 46 Ulupna; Ormond ($3,700,000) Andrew Chisholm.
  Brighton 11 Kent Campbell Cooney was bought post auction for $4,100,000, which put south-facing, non beachfront land on the Golden Mile at $3,800 per sqm

• It was gratifying to see the number of professional advocates acting for buying clients this weekend. The Bidderbuzz auction at Currajong auction had three advocates, and there was one each on Benson, Drummond, Elwood. While the advocate didn’t win the chocolates for their clients every time, at least it shows more $1m, $2m, and $3m+ buyers are making informed decisions.

Some of our buyer prayers have been answered

Market: Even with significantly reduced auction numbers this weekend (owing to a more important event which finally delivered a result that proved there was justice in the world), we still saw a pretty healthy market result for sellers – with a 74% Clearance Rate on the 55 $Million+ auctions we monitored. Of those 55 auctions, 9 results were not reported. But even that is not unreasonable under the circumstances of the GF Replay.

There seems little doubt that the market is on the rise. The big interest now is how the market will absorb the stock surge that will culminate in Spring/Summer’s first Super Saturday on October 23rd.

And it really is Super Saturday - with a massive 81 $M+ auctions booked for Boroondara alone, and around 200 $M+ auctions booked in our key focus $M+ areas – Bayside and Inner East. Check out the size of the Weekly Review this week (it’s as big as a phone book). By comparison this weekend saw only one quarter of that number of auctions. So if you were at an auction this weekend, those four bidders you competed against may well be spread across four homes in a couple of weeks. Well that’s the “buyer-hope” theory anyway.

This Week’s Highlights:

• Two land sales showing vastly differing land values
  a) Land at 101 River Avenue Plenty (39,500 sqm), which can be subdivided, was auctioned  by Rob Stefanovski of LJ Hooker Greensborough and  bought for $3,830,000 or $96 per sq metre
  b) A large land parcel (1,813 sqm) at 3-5 Heath St Sandringham sold after a failed auction by Bill Jowett of Buxton for $2,800,000 or $1,544 per sq metre
• The major stock inflows that took place on Monday, Tuesday and Wednesday when agents began their marketing campaigns for the next Super Saturday – October 23rd.
• The continued improvement of the $3M+ market – two examples below
  a) Off market in Black St Brighton (Peter Bourbaud and Barb Gregory) – bought for around $4 million
  b) 27 Moorhouse Armadale with Gowan Stubbings of Kay and Burton – bought after an Expression of Interest campaign for more than $5 million
• The Pies Forward Line pressure (whoops, sorry – I got distracted)

Auction Snapshot from this weekend: 133 Rathmines Fairfield: Michael Fry and Grant Leonard of Nelson Alexander. Bought under the hammer for $1,116,000. 5 bidders.
There was a buzz about this well located timber period home, which had had its quote lifted to $930,000 during the campaign. It was a surprising development given Grant’s comment that the property failed to attract any interest in the high $800s a few months ago with a quiet sale campaign. It was on the market with the first bid at $900,000. Second bid $950,000. Third bid $970,000. Fourth bid-  bang $1,000,000. Three more bidders joined in before the action stopped at $1,116,000. It was a well run auction campaign. I always enjoy a Michael Fry auction. He has a sophisticated grace about him incongruent with the fact that he is yanking the dollars from buyers’ pockets. Enjoyable to watch unless you’re an underbidder – which unfortunately this time we were.

Bumper Market Insight: We have an information packed Market Insight this week; even though there are no Market Wraps, Bidderman, reports or videos.  The footy replay threw this auction weekend into a bit of chaos, with a few auctions even changing days. But it was a very low stock weekend anyway, so no major damage. All $M results are at the end of this Market Insight. But the big news now is the next three weekends that will lead full bore into the Melbourne Cup Long Weekend.

Stock Levels and Price Assessment:
The big question the market will be asking now is: What will happen to prices on October 23rd? With this big stock influx, how is the price game of snakes and ladders going to pan out? Are we going to see the slippery snake and big price slide of May 2010 or will the market just take this in its stride, as it did this time last year, with prices climbing further up the ladder? Time will tell. Importantly as buyers you need to get yourself organised – and don’t count your chickens before they’ve hatched.

With this apparent largess of choice, perhaps you don’t need brilliant home-seeking skills right at this moment. But you will need first class assessment procedures (e.g. sorting the goodies from the baddies in terms of capital growth prospects, and working out which one is best from a “happy wife = happy life” point of view). You will also need good negotiation strategies – because while you may have more choice, you will also have competition. Remember, our bidders per auction indicator Bidderman was strong on lower numbers in September, especially on good homes. On the flipside, some sellers expectations may be disappointed, so planning good negotiation strategies will improve your chances of grabbing a bargain when it presents.

Have a look at our Forward Auction Booking graphs below to get an idea of what is ahead of you: (click on a graph to enlarge)

There are also some exciting trophy homes on offer through private sale and off market – especially in the $3m+ segment.

Have a look at the New Stock Graph at the top of Market Insight – which compares the last week in September to the last week in June, (private sale and auction weekly new stock numbers are combined).

Special Report on the $3m Market

The $3m+ is back, after the self induced May hiccup that led to a very quiet winter.

There have been over 50 buys in the month of September at this level, with buyers coming from all quarters. Let’s pick one of the segments – around $4million. We have bought 3 homes at this specific level in the last few weeks. All were classic period homes with land of over 1000 square metres. Two were bought post auction (eg after a pass-in) and one was off market (Black St Brighton). However, the interesting thing were the buyer profiles. One buyer was a change of life family, one was a growing family that needed more space, and one was an expat family returning from overseas. This is a fairly accurate representation of the range of people we look for homes for. Of the last case – expats returning from overseas -Brighton high end agent Peter Bourbaud believes “this group will push the market along for the next few years, after a couple of very quiet years from the expat community”. We concur. Last year we conducted very little in business terms last year for expats. However in 2010 there has been a distinct pick up in action from expats returning home.

The James September $3m+ Report with all reported $3m+ boughts and solds can be viewed from the Home Page (next to Market Insight and below Buyer Masterclass) or click here

If you are new to the $3m market you may find the charts below (using 2007 to 2010 Valuer General, REIV and our own James Databases) of some value, as they help to show how the overall $3m+ market works. Note particularly that:

• The two powerhouse $3m+ suburbs are Brighton and Toorak (see 2009 results graphed below). However these two suburbs behave quiet differently from each other (see median graph). More on that another time.
• More $3m+ is bought later in the year than early. (2009 graphed below)
• There are some real name streets around and there are some falsies (where if you pay top dollar you will stand out like a beacon)
• Less than a quarter (25%) of $3m+ homes sell under the hammer at auction (click on September Graph below)
• A lot more activity is off market (not advertised) at this $3m+ level than any other price point, e.g. sub $3m.

Click on any of the graphs below to bring them up to full size

Agent Comments on the current $3m+ market

• “Prior to the school holiday period there was some renewed strength in $3m+ market due to things stabilising after the election and to the shortage of good quality homes. With the spring market in full swing it will be very interesting to see what happens with the increase of volume. But if the enquiry rates are anything to go by, October will be a strong month of sales.” Andrew Hayne of Marshall White Malvern
• “The $3 million plus market is strong, and we are expecting a big finish to spring in this market for good family homes.” Nick Johnstone of JP Dixon Brighton
  
• “There seems to have been a resurgence of buyer enquiry for the upper end properties recently.  It will be interesting to see if this follows through once we see increased stock levels after the school holidays and round 2 of the Grand Final.” Julian Augustini of Hodges Brighton
• Andrew Baynes from Kay and Burton South Yarra “Last Monday was the busiest auction sign up day for me in 10 years.”

Media Monitor: Domain – The Age 2/10/10. Headlined: “Hands up if you don’t have a clue” by Josh Jennings. Basically a solid article – but Josh, how many homes has Dr Damien Eldridge, Economics Lecturer from La Trobe University, bought using his quoted bidding advice this year? Would it have been 5 or 10 or 50? Going by his auction comments we were unclear as to whether you were holding him out as an expert – or simply providing supporting evidence to your headline.

We are not all brickbats here for the mainstream press. Congratulations to Chris Vedelago from The Age who this year has been consistently reporting the market as it really is and who actually seems to get out of the ivory tower (that so many property reporters are stuck in) and goes to auctions and talks to agents. We mightn’t always agree with you Chris, but we respect your work. Keep it up and keep getting out into the market.

Market News TV: On Tuesday of this week we ask the question: Is the ACCC or CAV the right watchdog for the real estate industry? Check out our Agent Opinion Videos.

Buyer Masterclass: We conclude our Negotiation Masterclass series with an article on Backward Bidding. From next week until Christmas we will be looking at “Pricing and Values” in Million Dollar Melbourne

Reported Results:

Backward bidding is about “throwing stones back”, it’s about fighting back, it’s about saying enough is enough.

We have the greatest respect for the professional abilities of agents at Marshall White, Kay and Burton, RT Edgar and many other agents. But we have to be upfront; as much as we support them and the roles they play – we do not support their quoting regimes especially if attached to a Clayton’s Reserve strategy.

So enter our Backward bidding strategy – our partial solution until the industry acts.

Backward bidding takes place on auction day, and it goes something like this.

• Prior to the auction we ask if there is a reserve – if there is no reserve why bid? First right of refusal – refusal of what – there is no reserve.
• If we know we have a potential Clayton’s Reserve and we know the agent’s plan is to pass the property in, we bid a sensible opening bid – we do this for a reason.
• Next we ask if it is on the market
• We expect a ‘No’ – because we know the agent has been giving a bulls..t quote
• If we get a  ‘No’ then
• We put in a lower bid. This creates angst amongst some auctioneers as they stand there reciting the auction rules, the ones by the way they are trying to abuse. They tell you that you can’t withdraw a bid. But we are not, we are placing a new one, it’s just that it’s lower. They then tell you they don’t have to accept a bid, which is true.

We don’t fight back verbally – we remain silent

This usually leads to some public uncomfortableness (please we are against any form of threatening or inappropriate behaviour and do not support it under any circumstances), and when things settle one of the following usually happens

• Acceptance of our lower bid by the auctioneer
• The auctioneer refusing to take the new bid and passing the property in – to nobody
• A vendor bid
• Somebody else bidding

Our next response if the auction continues and we are above the quote is to bid like this:

• “If I bid another $20,000 will it be on the market?”
• The usual response is either rude or friendly such as: I’ll ask if you bid that.
• After a brief visit inside the auctioneer comes back and tells us yes or “we are so close”.

Right or wrong is not our issue – a vendor can ask whatever they want – what we try and do is best manage situations where the vendor won’t tell you what they really want as they hide behind a “bulls..t auction quote and Clayton’s Reserve strategy”

There is nothing wrong with a selling agent trying to get more money. That’s their job. Why we backward bid is because some agents and vendors in trying to get more money go beyond what is acceptable – in our opinion they operate in a dubious manner.

But I digress, let’s presume it is passed–in to us. Then what?

We have different pass-in strategies depending on:

1)      The reserve the agent has told us during the campaign

2)      What the agent tells us it is now

3)      How many other bidders there are

All these are of course under the overriding umbrella of clients’ risk v reward instructions.

We will forward bid and then backward bid, or just forward bid or just backward bid, or in fact do nothing depending on our clients’ instructions and vendor responses. A number of times at pass-ins we have bid below the pass-in figure. Yes we have bought homes below higher offers and pass-in figures and yes we have bought them above pass-in figures.

As buyers you need to be prepared to fight, when circumstances force this. If your only negotiation technique is the kangaroo frozen in the headlights technique, or the Manuel from Fawlty Towers technique where you just keep going up and up in order to please then you will have issues. If you are up against the best exponents of Clayton’s Reserves, you will end up paying an incredibly high price – when it was not fair to do so – it is not fair if you had bid, won first right of refusal and then had not been told the real reserve or that reserve did not reasonably coincide with the quote.

Please if you don’t bid sensibly at auction, this is an EOI negotiation or private/off market sale without a price or bulls..t quote then we totally support vendor open slather – it’s caveat emptor all the way. The “floor, stairs, then new level again, floors, stairs, then new level again” price ramping technique is not only brilliant when done well, it’s fair and would be what I would want my agent to do if I was selling in these circumstances.

After the initially chest pumping on backward bidding you should expect a certain level of discomfort.

The fact is that some agents will want to break you, sell it to another buyer given half the chance just so as you learn a lesson. After all you have attacked not only the bulls..t quoting and Clayton’s reserve but you have also attacked their ego. Please backward bidding is heavy stuff, just as a seller may lose your best offer, you may very well lose what you wanted to buy – you are playing for keeps, so use it in the right circumstances.

Backward bidding, like some quoting regimes and Clayton’s reserves is heavy, heavy stuff.

This is our last article in the current series on Negotiation – we plan to do another series early in 2011. For more in this Negotiation series refer to the Articles section on the homepage of website. From the week after Grand Final and will be starting a series on Values and Prices.

We only buy homes

Big Crowds on Canterbury: 42 Wattle Valley. Bought After: Richard Winneke: Over $3,426,000: Photo courtesy Jellis Craig.

September Executive Summary:

Demand: Solid and increasing

• Reported Boughts: 46
• Bidderman: Substantial improvement in bidders per auction at the higher level. Random cross section of bidders. 1/3/2/1/3/1/3/2/2/3/3/3/2/1/0/0 for a month average of 1.875

Supply: New Stock Low

• Overhang from May however new stock is still light on at end of September and that which comes on at a reasaonble price is mostly being bought.

Price: Firming

• A number of stales (on market over 3 months) were purchased in Bayside reducing overhang – this will have an upwards effect on price if demand remains constant.
• Some new properties coming onto the market but new stock is still limited in Boroondara and Stonnington also encouraging price in an upwards direction.

Quote of the month: Stewart Lopez of Kay and Burton ” In this improving Upper End market, sellers are getting back the control that they lost with the stock splurge in May”

Highlights
Over $9 million
Hawthorn 24 Coppin: Jock Langley: Around $9,000,000 Private Sale. This basic house, on an acre on the river in Hawthorn’s river precinct, has been on the market for well over a year and had quotes at $15m then 12m and then…. A number of agents have worked on this. I went through this home last year and finally Jock Langley has got a sale through under $10m. It is a great block, its only fault until today was its price tag.
Brighton 292 New: Brian Devlin and Regina Schmidt: Around $9,000,000 Private Sale. Up for sale for less than a month, this grand looking home was purchased today for around $9,000,000. A very impressive block just down from Brighton Grammar.
Over $7 million
Toorak 11 Cole: Ross Savas: Private Sale: Quote $8,000,000 plus reported as bought for above that figure
Undisclosed Rating: http://www.james.net.au/rating/11-Cole-Court-TOORAK
Hawthorn East 49 Harcourt: James Tostevin: Bought After: Over $7,200,000: Bidderman 2
James Auction Report: http://www.marketnews.com.au/auction-reviews/8661/49-Harcourt-Street-HAWTHORN_EAST/
Brighton 6 Head: Jeremy Fox: Sold well after auction: Around $7,000,000
Full Rating: http://www.james.net.au/rating/6-Head-Street-BRIGHTON

Bidderbuzz Auction of the Month
24 Somers Malvern: Jeremy Fox: Under the hammer: $6,160,000: Bidderman 3
James Auction Report and Rating: http://www.marketnews.com.au/auction-reviews/8705/24-Somers-Avenue-MALVERN/
The sunfilled courtyard was a perfect setting for the Somers Avenue auction, with the lovely weather attracting a generous crowd of interested parties and onlookers alike. Auctioneer Jeremy Fox asked the crowd for an opening bid, but was disappointed with silence. It wasn’t long before a confident bid of $5,000,000 soon had the ball rolling though. Two parties continued with strong bidding, as the crowd watched on with baited breath. It was at $5,650,000 when another bidder keenly entered the fray, enquiring if the house was in fact yet ‘on the market’. There was clear buzz of anticipation amongst the crowd, as Mr. Fox conferred with the vendors, and finally confirming in the positive. Bidding continued fast and furiously between bidders, whilst the crowd remained captivated. The final knock-out bid brought on a genuine look of relief to the successful bidder. A truly entertaining auction, as you could hear echoed amongst the departing onlookers. (Nikki Hills)

Late Entries (Not Included in Stats)
Brighton Black St: Peter Bourbaud and Barb Gregory: Off Market: James Home Rating 852/1000. Price Undisclosed
Toorak 5 Myrnong: Darren Krongold and Sally Zelman: Private Sale: Price Undisclosed
James Rating: http://www.james.net.au/rating/5-Myrnong-Crescent-TOORAK
Armadale 23 Moorhouse: Gowan Stubbings: Expressions of Interest: Price over $5,000,000
James Rating: http://www.james.net.au/rating/23-Moorhouse-Street-ARMADALE

Apartments:
East Melbourne 144 Jolimont Road: Marcus Chiminello: Penthouse $3,250,000
Melbourne 301/401 St Kilda Road: Marcus Chiminello: Lucient $3,100,000

Albert Park
Albert Park 62 Beaconsfield: Kaine Lanyon: Quote $3,500,000 to $3,750,000: James Home Rating 655/1000: At Auction: Over $3,300,000
James Rating: http://www.james.net.au/rating/62-Beaconsfield-Parade-ALBERT_PARK

Armadale
81 Rose: Tim Derham: Bought Over $3,300,000. A  terrace home that needed a fair bit of work but did have rear access and was north facing to rear. Solid result.
James Undisclosed Rating: http://www.james.net.au/rating/81-Rose-Street-ARMADALE
21 Adelaide: John Bongiorno auctioned this “bulldozer or significant rebuild” home at 4.30pm today. Bought for $3,130,000 or just over $4,000 per sqm. Bidderman 3. Heather Elder and Rae Tomlinson
James Undisclosed Rating: http://www.james.net.au/rating/21-Adelaide-Street-ARMADALE
28 Seymour: Joanna Nairn: Quote $3,500,000 plus: James Rating 682/1000: Bought After Auction: Around $3,500,000: Bidderman 1
James Auction Report: http://www.marketnews.com.au/auction-reviews/9007/28-Seymour-Avenue-ARMADALE/
1 Myamyn: Andrew Macmillan: Under the hammer: $3,215,000: Bidderman 2
James Auction Report: http://www.marketnews.com.au/auction-reviews/8670/1-Myamyn-Street-ARMADALE/
3 Avalon: Ross Savas: Bought: Reportedly over $7,000,000, but not confirmed:
James Rating: http://www.james.net.au/rating/3-Avalon-Road-ARMADALE

Balwyn
Balwyn 23 Bevan: Richard James & William Chen: Quote $3,300,000 to $3,600,000: James Home Rating 742/1000: Bought After Auction: Around $3,500,000: Bidderman 1
James Auction Report: http://www.marketnews.com.au/auction-reviews/8932/23-Bevan-Street-BALWYN/

Brighton
10 Campbell: Peter Kennett. Private Sale after a Pass-In Auction. In excess of pass-in $3,850,000.
James Undisclosed Rating: http://www.james.net.au/rating/10-Campbell-Street-BRIGHTON
20 Bent: Justin Follett. Private Sale . Within asking price range $3,800,000 – $4,000,000.
James Undisclosed Rating: http://www.james.net.au/rating/20-Bent-Street-BRIGHTON
7 St Ninians: Nick Johnstone. Private Sale. In excess of  $3,500,000.
James Undisclosed Rating: http://www.james.net.au/rating/7-St_Ninians-Court-BRIGHTON
292 New: Brian Devlin and Regina Schmidt: Around $9,000,000 Private Sale. Up for sale for less than a month, this grand looking home was purchased today for around $9,000,000. A very impressive block just down from Brighton Grammar.
James Undisclosed Rating: http://www.james.net.au/rating/292-New-Street-BRIGHTON
22 Tennyson: Marcus Gollings. Private Sale. In excess of $5,000,000.
James Undisclosed Rating: http://www.james.net.au/rating/22-Tennyson-Street-BRIGHTON
3/9 Glyndon: Stewart Lopez: Private Sale: Mid $3,000,000’s
James Rating: Click here http://www.james.net.au/rating/3/9-Glyndon-Avenue-BRIGHTON
6 Head: Jeremy Fox: bought well after auction: Around $7,000,000
Full Rating click here: http://www.james.net.au/rating/6-Head-Street-BRIGHTON
19 Wellington: Stewart Lopez and Sturt Hinton. Private Sale after Auction. Over $4,000,000
James Rating: http://www.james.net.au/rating/19-Wellington-Street-BRIGHTON
3 Wellington: Stewart Lopez and Sturt Hinton. Private Sale after Auction. Around $3,900,000
James Rating: http://www.james.net.au/rating/3-Wellington-Street-BRIGHTON
5/23 St Ninians: Stewart Lopez and Sturt Hinton. Private Sale under $5,000,000
James Rating: http://www.james.net.au/rating/5/23-St_Ninians-Road-BRIGHTON
6 Seacombe: Ian Jackson: Private Sale over $4,500,000
James Rating: http://www.james.net.au/rating/6-Seacombe-Grove-BRIGHTON

Camberwell
8 Canterbury: Peter Mitchell: bought after auction: Around $3,000,000: Bidderman 3
James Auction Report: http://www.marketnews.com.au/auction-reviews/7926/8-Canterbury-Road-CAMBERWELL/

Canterbury
42 Wattle Valley: Richard Winneke: bought after, in excess of $3,426,000: Bidderman 1
James Auction Report: http://www.marketnews.com.au/auction-reviews/8807/42-Wattle_Valley-Road-CANTERBURY/
23 Chaucer: James Tostevin: bought after over $3,850,000: Bidderman 3
James Auction Report: http://www.marketnews.com.au/auction-reviews/8221/23-Chaucer-Crescent-CANTERBURY/

Elwood
31 Ormond: Marcus Gollings: Expressions of Interest: Bought over $4,000,000
James Undisclosed Rating: http://www.james.net.au/rating/31-Ormond-Esplanade-ELWOOD

Hawthorn
2 Berkeley: Rob Vickers-Willis: Bought at Auction: Bought over $3,000,000
James Undisclosed Rating: http://www.james.net.au/rating/2-Berkeley-Street-HAWTHORN
24 Coppin: Jock Langley: Around $9,000,000 Private Sale. This basic house, on an acre on the river in Hawthorn’s river precinct, has been on the market for well over a year and had quotes at $15m then 12m and then…. A number of agents have worked on this. I went through this home last year and finally Jock Langley has got a sale through under $10m. It is a great block, its only fault until today was its price tag.
James Undisclosed Rating: http://www.james.net.au/rating/24-Coppin-Grove-HAWTHORN
36 Chrystobel: Lisa Jarrett: Private Sale after auction: In excess of $3,500,000
James Auction Report: http://www.james.net.au/rating/36-Chrystobel-Crescent-HAWTHORN

Hawthorn East
49 Harcourt: James Tostevin: Bought After, over $7,200,000: Bidderman 2
James Auction Report: http://www.marketnews.com.au/auction-reviews/8661/49-Harcourt-Street-HAWTHORN_EAST/

Ivanhoe
59 Studley: David Oster: Under the hammer: $4,300,000: Bidderman 2
James Auction Report: http://www.marketnews.com.au/auction-reviews/8989/59-Studley-Road-IVANHOE/

Kew
63 Walpole: James Tostevin: Bought Before Auction: In excess of $3,000,000.

Malvern
24 Somers: Jeremy Fox: Under the hammer: $6,160,000: Bidderman 3
James Auction Report: http://www.marketnews.com.au/auction-reviews/8705/24-Somers-Avenue-MALVERN/
15 A Sorrett: Andrew Hayne: Week or so after Auction: Over $3,500,000
James Auction Report: http://www.james.net.au/rating/15a-Sorrett-Avenue-MALVERN
Elizabeth: Marcus Chiminello Off the plan $3,300,000
6 Bonview: John Bongiorno: Bought Afterwards in excess of $3,600,000: Bidderman 3
James Video Auction Report: http://www.marketnews.com.au/video/?vid=305
11 Moorakyne: Michael Gibson: Under the Hammer: $4,000,000: Bidderman: 3
James Rating and Auction Report: http://www.james.net.au/rating/11-Moorakyne-Avenue-MALVERN
17 Thanet: Mark Wridgway: Before Auction: Bought over $3,500,000.
James Home Rating: http://www.james.net.au/rating/17-Thanet-Street-MALVERN

Malvern East
31 Finch St: Andrew McCann: Under the Hammer: $3,360,000: Bidderman 2
James Auction Report: http://www.marketnews.com.au/auction-reviews/8376/31-Finch-Street-MALVERN_EAST/

South Yarra
38 Park: Warwick Anderson: Quote $3,500,000 plus: James Rating 725/1000: Bought After Auction: Above $3,000,000: Bidderman 1
James Auction Report: http://www.marketnews.com.au/auction-reviews/8476/38-Park-Place-SOUTH_YARRA/
19 Acland: Greg Herman: 4 bidders: Bought under the hammer: $3,600,000
James Auction Report: http://www.marketnews.com.au/auction-reviews/6886/19-Acland-Street-SOUTH_YARRA/

St Kilda
Two Block of Flats:
4 Church: Claudio Perruzza: Bought at Auction $3,400,000
16 Charnwood: Adam Joske: Bought at Auction $6,060,000

Toorak
11 Cole: Ross Savas: Private Sale: Quote $8,000,000 plus reported as bought for above that figure
Undisclosed Rating: http://www.james.net.au/rating/11-Cole-Court-TOORAK
2/23 Tintern: Ross Savas: Private Sale: Quote $5,000,000 plus reported as bought for above that figure
Undisclosed Rating: http://www.james.net.au/rating/2/23-Tintern-Avenue-TOORAK
8 Macquarie: Jeremy Fox: Private Sale after auction. $6,400,000.
James Rating: http://www.james.net.au/rating/8-Macquarie-Road-TOORAK
4 Forrest Court: Peter Kudelka and James Scarff: Bought after auction $4,050,000: Bidderman 0
James Auction Report: Click here http://www.marketnews.com.au/auction-reviews/8829/4-Forrest-Court-TOORAK
1 Hopetoun: Justin Long: Bought after auction: Over $5,500,000: Bidderman 0
James Auction Report: http://www.marketnews.com.au/auction-reviews/8671/1-Hopetoun-Road-TOORAK/
803 Orrong: Warwick Anderson: Private Sale $4,500,000
Undisclosed Rating: http://www.james.net.au/rating/803-Orrong-Road-TOORAK
1a Como: Greg Herman: Private Sale: Over $6,400,000

Please Note: The $3m+ market can be a very shadowy one at times with regards to what is bought, if indeed it was actually bought and what price (cash and/or otherwise) was paid. At all times the prices we outline are never truly confirmed until they can be viewed six to nine months later at the Government stamp duties office – however we don’t publish without feeling there is a high degree of truth. This is why as buyer agents when pricing homes we never make decisions on one buy alone and why true land and building values plus an overall knowledge of all buys is vital in calculating correct market value.  At this price level it is also a very private world and we respect that when trying to balance market transparency v individual privacy. We accept we don’t get it right every time but we do try. We never discuss buyer/seller personalities; we do not reveal intimate details to the wider press and we do not disclose full details publicly where the source has asked us not to. Our sources are not just the selling agent, but underbidders, our own advocates, REIV, our auction reporters and other agents not connected with the sale/buy. If you aware of an error or omission please email mal@james.net.au and we will adjust – you will be treated confidentially if you wish.

Malvern 24 Somers: Jeremy Fox of RT Edgar: Bought for $6,160,000 under the hammer: 3 bidders: Crowd of 90.

Special Report on the $3m market: The $3m+ is back, after its self induced May hiccup which lead to a very quiet winter.

There have been over 50 buys in the month of September at this level and the buyers are coming from all quarters. Lets pick one of the segments – around $4million. We have bought 3 homes at this specific level in the last few weeks: all were classic period homes on land sizes over 1000 square metres  – two were post auction (eg after a pass-in) and one was off market (Black St Brighton). However the interesting thing was the buyer profile. One was a change of life family; one had a growing family and needed space and one was an expat family returning from overseas. If you look at our client lists this is a fairly accurate representation of whom we are looking for. In the last case – expats returning from overseas – Brighton high end agent Peter Bourbaud thinks “this group will push the market along for the next few years, after a couple of very quiet years from the expat community”. We concur, we conducted very little in business terms last year for expats, however there has been a distinct pick up in action from expats returning home in 2010.

The James September $3m+ Report, with all reported $3M+ boughts and solds can be viewed from the home page (next to market insight and below Buyer Masterclass) or click here

If you are new to the $3m market you may find these charts below (using 2007 to 2010 VG, REIV and James Databases) of some value as they help to show how the overall $3m+ market works.

• The two powerhouse $3m+ suburbs are Brighton and Toorak (see 2009 results graphed below); however they behave quiet differently from each other (see median graph). But more on that another time.
• More $3M+ is bought later in the year than early. (2009 graphed below)
• There are some real name streets around and there are some falsies (where you pay top dollar and stand out like a beacon)
• Less than a quarter (25%) of $3m+ homes sell under the hammer at auction (click on September Graph below)
• A lot more activity is off market (not advertised) at this $3m+ level than any other price point eg sub $3m.

Please click on the any of the graphs below to bring them up to full size

Agent Comments on the $3m+ market

• “Prior to the school holiday period there was some renewed strength in $3m+ market due to stabilisation of things after the election and the shortage of good quality homes. With the spring market in full swing it will be very interesting to see what happens with the increase of volume, but if the enquiry rates are anything to go buy October will be a strong months of sales.” Andrew Hayne of Marshall White Malvern
• “The 3 mill plus market is strong, we are expecting a big finish to spring in the 3 plus market for good family homes.” Nick Johnstone of JP Dixon Brighton
  
• “There seems to have been a resurgence of buyer enquiry for the upper end properties recently.  It will be interesting to see if this follows through once we see increased stock levels after the school holidays and round 2 of the Grand Final.” Julian Augustini of Hodges Brighton
• Andrew Baynes from Kay and Burton South Yarra “Last Monday was my busiest auction sign up day for me in 10 years”

We only buy homes

Crowd moving into position at 49 Harcourt St Hawthorn East - Bought Afterwards in excess of $7.2million. James Tostevin of Marshall White.

Another strong (well stronger than Winter) fortnight for auctions and private sales over $3m. Rather than wax lyrical lets look at some facts. See below for results, reports, ratings and analysis.

42 Wattle Valley Road Canterbury: Richard Winneke of Jellis Craig

Full Auction Report: Click here
http://www.marketnews.com.au/auction-reviews/8807/42-Wattle_Valley-Road-CANTERBURY

Auctioneer Jeremy Fox presiding in front of a crowd of 90 people at 24 Somers Ave Malvern. On the market at $5,650,000 and selling strongly under the hammer with Bidderman at 3.

Full Auction Report click here:
http://www.marketnews.com.au/auction-reviews/8705/24-Somers-Avenue-MALVERN

4 Forrest Court Toorak: Peter Kudelka Kay and Burton

Full Auction Report: Click here
http://www.marketnews.com.au/auction-reviews/8829/4-Forrest-Court-TOORAK

49 Harcourt Hawthorn East: Sold After in excess of $7,200,000

Full Auction Report click here:
http://www.james.net.au/rating/49-Harcourt-Street-HAWTHORN_EAST

1 Myamyn St Armadale: Andrew Macmillan of Benmac: $3,215,000: 2 bidders

Full Auction Report click here:
http://www.marketnews.com.au/auction-reviews/8670/1-Myamyn-Street-ARMADALE/

6 Head St Brighton: Jeremy Fox of RT Edgar: Around $7,000,000

Full Rating click here:
http://www.james.net.au/rating/6-Head-Street-BRIGHTON

Sold Afterwards in excess of $3,600,000: John Bongiorno: Marshall White: 3 bidders

Full Video Auction Report: Click here
http://www.marketnews.com.au/video/?vid=305

19 Acland St South Yarra: Greg Herman RT Edgar: 4 bidders: Bought under the hammer: $3,600,000

Full Auction Report: Click here
http://www.marketnews.com.au/auction-reviews/6886/19-Acland-Street-SOUTH_YARRA/

44 Elizabeth St Malvern: Gerald Delany and Michael Armstrong of Kay and Burton: Passed In at $3,250,000: 0 bidders

Full Auction Report: Click here
http://www.james.net.au/rating/44-Elizabeth-Street-MALVERN

106 St Georges Rd Toorak: Mike Gibson: Kay and Burton: 0 bidders: Passed In $5,500,000

Full Auction Report: Click here
http://www.marketnews.com.au/auction-reviews/8555/106-St_Georges-Road-TOORAK/

61 North Road Brighton: Nick Johnstone of JP Dixon:

Full Auction Report: Click here
http://www.marketnews.com.au/auction-reviews/7552/61-North-Road-BRIGHTON

22 Tennyson Brighton: JP Dixon - Marcus Gollings. Believed to be in excess of $5,000,000. Private Sale

22 Tennyson St Brighton:

• 16,640sqft/1,546sqm
• floodlit tennis court and
• heated pool
• 5.5 bathroom floorplan
• hydronic heating
• space for six cars including triple garaging behind the two sets of auto-gates.

63 Walpole St Kew: James Tostevin: Marshall White: Believed to be in excess of $3,000,000. Sold Before Auction.

1a Como Toorak: Over $6,000,000 Greg Herman of RT Edgar: Private Sale

Buying a home is a business interaction – and business interactions involve dealing with different business cultures. So just as business people need to find the most appropriate way to interact with people of different cultures, so too do home buyers have to find the right way to deal with selling agents.

There is an overall culture among selling agents and there are many sub-cultures within different agencies, just as there are within cities, football clubs, even families. Understanding, and working with, these sub-cultures usually yields better results than fighting against them.

A first step to gaining an insight into agent culture is to consider the overall big picture: that agents represent sellers first and foremost (and, despite the bad press agents sometimes get, most of the good agents do really do this).

Taking this one step further, some selling agents have a culture of win-loss: the seller can only win if the buyer loses.

The next helpful hint is to understand that you are on their turf. In footy terms, when you begin negotiations you are playing an away game. Be mindful therefore that the wind may blow in a direction that the agent knew but wasn’t obvious to you.

In inner Melbourne, one of the first agent “cultures” that new buyers have to learn quickly is the concept of “quote  ’em low and watch  ’em go.” It’s endemic and not likely to change in a hurry because unfortunately it often works against the inexperienced. But this is not an article about that.

Once you have done twenty or so deals with a particular agency you will start to get a handle on the overall agent culture(s), and you will also start to develop insights into individual agency “clan” cultures.

To reiterate: better negotiations generally come from better understandings. And while you may not agree with the way the game is played, you can often achieve a better result if you understand the players and the game you are in.

For example, here are some of the sub-cultures we see in some of the Melbourne real estate agencies we deal with regularly:

Jellis Craig: Under the leadership of Scott Patterson, Richard Earle and Richard James, Jellis Craig’s sub-culture has changed in recent times to a more professional consultative culture.

RT Edgar: Led by Jeremy Fox in the toughest game in town – vs Kay and Burton. The sub-culture of this company is one of approaching every day with the view of ”what deal can be done?”

Kay and Burton: The five pillars, as we call them  – Ross Savas, Peter Kudelka, Jason Scillio, Mike Gibson and Gerald Delany  – have a sub-culture based around considered planning, preparation and professional presentation. A deal can’t be rushed.

Marshall White: Led by James Connell and John Bongiorno, this company is also highly structured. They have a competitive and very professional sub-culture.

Biggin and Scott : Local flavour is very much part of their sub-culture.

Noel Jones, Benmac, Buxton, Hodges, Barry Plant, Nelson Alexander and so on all have very different sub-cultures.

I’m sure you have run into agents who treat you like dirt (although this is a lot less widespread than ten years ago). And you may find that you visit home after home where these agents are from the same company. It’s all about culture and leadership from the top. If the company’s leadership has tight commissions, poor training and low ethical standards which encourage a “dog eat dog” attitude among its sales staff, that can manifest itself in poor interactions between buyers and agents. But rather than reject that and rule out a number of homes because of the agent, you can recognise the culture, understand why it is happening, not take it personally and then use it to your advantage in structuring an offer. In many cases, agents with a chip on their shoulder can be a smart buyer’s friend.

Of course, the reverse is also true and in any one of the above companies you will find the majority (if not all) agents operating in a professional culture where you will be treated in a manner that may lead to a result that made you feel good during the process but …

Understanding culture is very different from understanding buying or selling techniques. For example, if your pre-auction offer is shown to everyone else for 24 hours before it is accepted or rejected, that is a procedure. To be told by an agent that there is another offer even if there isn’t, is a technique or a strategy, not cultural. But to think that all buyers are liars – that is a culture.

There are problems when buyers want to, or become focused on, changing agents’ culture. I would like to see some changes to make private sales a more open process and legislation to make post-auction negotiations a more level playing field. However, while that is a wish, it is not my primary aim when involved in deals day to day. My primary aim is to get the right deal for my client. Any of my cultural change agendas are best served through REIV committee work, agent lunches and other forums. But when the deal light is flashing, I, for one, am not thinking about cultural change.

Besides that, changing cultures in countries, in clubs and within real estate agencies, is not an easy or instantaneous thing.

And, of course, it won’t have slipped past quality selling agents that our company individually, and we as buyer agents collectively, also have cultures – and a number of quality selling agents understand that and deal with us accordingly.

Overall, you may have noticed, in general, that buyer agents’ culture with regards to selling agents is moving from animosity towards understanding, and vice versa.

Selling agents, agencies and auctioneers are all different. There are cultures you may not like, but, in the context of a six-month search and buy, you need to ask yourself whether your priority is to resist or fight to try and change a culture, or whether you should simply ignore homes whose agent culture you don’t care for. You may find that your needs are best served by understanding and finding ways to operate within an agent’s clan culture.

In a previous Buyer Masterclass we talked about the fact that more buyers are asking questions at auctions, especially the “is it on the market?” question. Asking questions can work well when bidder numbers are down.  If you are the only bidder at an auction you are going to get a better hearing from the agent asking that question than if you are one of five bidders and you’re the only one asking the question.

The other thing in buyers’ favour for now is that asking questions at auction is still a novel thing and not all selling agents have worked through the script with their dialogue trainers to work out how to deal with your questions. So all they can do when you ask, is ask the same question of their client, the vendor.

But things will change. The markets will shift, especially if  stock levels stay light and more buyers come out of hibernation. In that case we’ll see an increase in our bidders-per-auction indicator Bidderman and it will become less likely that you’ll be the only one bidding at the auction. As well, the agents will eventually acclimatise to the new buyer attitudes and questions. They will develop new techniques for their auctioneers and sales agents to manage your questions, such as dismissing them or asking questions back or some other strategy.

So asking “the question” at auction is not a cure-all. But asking it and other sensible questions prior to and post negotiations is a key step to become a better negotiator. It just may take you a lot of homes and bidding before you get it right.

Another way to improve your negotiations is through MINDSET.

We’ve learnt a lot of skills through buying homes for wealthy and/or successful people – and one of them is how much more effectively you can negotiate when you are in a certain mindset.

The fact is that if you really want a home, and feel you must get the deal at any price, an experienced selling agent will pick up on that – no matter what techniques, preparation or experience you have.  

The essential ingredient is to have a mindset of “What will be, will be”, otherwise known as the “I Care – But Not that Much” thinking of famous negotiator Herb Cohen, author of “You can Negotiate Anything”.  Con the Fruiterer (from the 1980s show The Comedy Company) was another great negotiator with his “Doesn’t matter” line.  

The point is that you have to be prepared to walk away. You need to have the mindset that there will be another property around the corner and a better one. We adopt this mindset when we discuss our fees. Some people like to negotiate them and we are happy to listen, but at the end of the day you have to be prepared to walk away if the deal isn’t right.

When we go to an auction we have two prices – one for if it’s on the market against proven competition and one for if it’s not. This seems to be one of the hardest concepts to grasp for the “other side” selling agents. They think: “Why would you pay less in a post auction negotiation than if it is ‘on the market’. Why wouldn’t you spend all your client’s money – why would you walk away from a commission as a buyer agent?” We do that when a client wants us to and because we have a mindset that allows us to. And this mindset gets us a lot more work than if we had to cut every deal we came across. Even though as agents we’re paid to cut deals, cutting any deal no matter what is a short term business strategy.

You may be unimpressed with some agents’ quoting strategies of late and we in some cases agree with you. But we do not question Marshall White’s or Kay and Burton’s agents mindsets when it comes to cutting a deal – especially when you go further up the food chain dollar wise and director wise. The best selling agents in other agencies have a similar mindset as well. They can and do recommend saying No to a price if they believe there is a better deal possible for their client. Sure it’s the client’ decision and a good buying or selling agent explains the Risks v Rewards before doing so, but superior agents can and do walk away from a deal when they have to. They do so because they have a mindset that allows that to happen.

By the way it’s not all about walking away. Like the great country singer Kenny Rogers said: “You’ve got to know when to fold ‘em but you’ve also got to know when to hold ‘em.” There is no point having a walk-away mindset if you walked away from your best deal.

You need to learn to find the balance that allows you to buy the right home without being a bridesmaid ten times in a row. If you can negotiate with an attitude that there will always be another, but you’re happy to take it at the right deal, then with the right preparation, process and experience over a period of time you will achieve better financial and emotional outcomes.

This mindset will achieve a lot more than a mindset of “I don’t care at all” or “I must have it at any cost”.

We only buy homes.

"Yeah this is going to turn out OK." And it did - just a casual $800,000 over reserve for David Oster of Jellis Craig of Ivanhoe. Bought for $4,300,000. 2 bidders from the opening bid of $3,300,000.

August has seen a bit more noise in the $3m+ market and deals are seemingly back on the agenda at this price level.

Jon Friedrich-designed apartment 9 Glyndon Brighton with an 812/1000 James Home Rating sold for mid $3millions this week after a long time on the market wanting a bit more. Stewart Lopez of Kay and Burton

In Ivanhoe two bidders fought it out for over a million dollars to get to the $4,300,000 result, as the above picture states  - a full $800,000 over a fair and reasonable reserve. I went through the home prior to auction and I have to say it was a unique offering with an incredible “Gone with the Wind” feel and sweeping views of much of Melbourne.

Moving southwards we get to:

896 Glenferrie Road, Hawthorn which has been on the market for an eternity, but has finally been sold this month for just under $5m through Phillip French of RT Edgar. Still with Phillip French, he reported a private sale of an apartment at 1/42 Grange Road, Toorak for in excess of $5,000,000.

Earlier this month we reported the auctions on two properties  in Moorakyne Ave, Malvern – Number 11 (Michael Gibson of Kay and Burton) and Number 4 (Justin Long of Marshall White), which sold for $4,000,000 and $3,000,000 respectively. Both had multiple bidding.

While we’re in Stonnington let’s look at a couple of sales through Marshall White’s Peter Bennison, Andrew Hayne and Justin Long.

• 6 Cross Street Malvern which was on the market longer than it takes an Independent to extract a deal for  just under $4,000,000.
• Huntingtower Road Armadale over $8,000,000
• An off market in Malvern East Gasgoine around $4,000,000

3 Wellington St Brighton with Kay and Burton - Passed in June 5th see our Auction Report - James Home Rating 702/1000. Sold this week for a bit under $4m.

Nathan Waterston of Bennison Mackinnon sold a lovely terrace home in 12 Jolimont, East Melbourne for just north of $3,000,000. His compatriot Andrew McCann got 31 Finch Malvern East away at auction for $3,360,000. As reported last week it needed a $million reno – so it was a solid price. There were multiple bidders at the auction.

We reported on 23 Chaucer, Canterbury a fortnight ago with James Tostevin of Marshall White – 3 bidders and sold just under $4,000,000. On the same day Steve Burke of Jellis Craig moved at auction 5 Callintina for $3,330,000.

But the news has been in Brighton in the last week or so.

1) John Knox House – 71 North Road. It had been on the market for a long time but it still wasn’t exactly given away – Sturt Hinton of Kay and Burton.

2&3) The Golden Mile was hot this week with two apartments at 3/9 Glyndon selling for over $3m, and 23 St Ninians, which had an initial asking price of near $5m, selling. Both were with Kay and Burton.

23 St Ninians apartment sold by Stewart Lopez of Kay and Burton for an undisclosed amount. They were asking around $5 million at the time I went through. I thought it lacked some floor plan imagination - but it had a view. James Home Rating 649/1000.

4) Also on the Golden Mile and also with Kay and Burton – Ian Jackson sold 6 Seacombe north of $4.5 million.

5&6) 3 Wellington now joins 19 Wellington as having sold recently. Both have been on the market all through the winter doldrums. It was sold by Stewart Lopez and Sturt Hinton of Kay and Burton for close to $4 million.

7&8) Gordon St, Hampton, used the unpopular Expressions of Interest method of sale to achieve a result of around $3.4million through Nick Johnstone of JP Dixon mid week. David Hart of Buxton got another away in the street (23) on Saturday, post auction, after it had been passed in at $2,725,000.

Throw in the reported $7.5million for 3 Avalon, Armadale – Ross Savas of Kay and Burton, Wattletree Road Glen Iris over $3.4million with Marshall White’s Heather Elder and Rae Tomlinson aka “Bonny and Clyde” and a few others – and it’s clear the Top End is not completely dead and buried.

But we do need to keep some perspective – we are a long way off Autumn’s deluge where back in May we saw 50 homes reported as having sold for over $3,000,000.

6 Seacombe Grove Brighton - sold for over $4.5m - Ian Jackson of Kay and Burton. Top 10 Melbourne Street and a James Home Rating of 733/1000.

Why is this happening?

Because buyers are there.

Why now?

The best guess is that buyers never left, but we needed some vendor price adjustments and they are now being made. If this is the case it may simply be a statistical coincidence as opposed to a market change – but it also may bring on some more quality stock, which may or may not give the market a more sustained lift. September is going to be quiet due to Election interference , so October will be the telling month to see if this market is trending back or remaining flat.

We only buy homes

It was game, set and match at 23 Chaucer Crescent today. Holding proceedings from the tennis court in front of a crowd of 100 people, James Tostevin accepted an opening bid of $3,500,000 and the game was on. Three bidders took the price steadily to $3,800,000 before Mr Tostevin referred to his vendor. Not yet on the market, the bidding continued until it reached $3,850,000. The property was passed in, but bought after for an undisclosed amount. Great atmosphere with three bidders over $3,800,000 - a strong result.