October 29th: Excerpt from October 15th James Marketnews: Want a home with a Tennis Court in Toorak? Got around $6 million dollars? In the last week we visited, assessed and rated: 11 Scotsburn Toorak (Andrew Smith), 10 Montalto Toorak (Mike Gibson) and 25 Scott Glen Iris (Rae Tomlinson). All have tennis courts.

The Question: After Super Saturday would these 3 not sell, sell lower or would the Mexican Wave** (see explanation below) kick in and they all sell once one had gone.
The Answer: The Jungle Drums beat loudly and the Mexican Wave kicked in with all three selling within 24 hours of each other. All three had quotes of $5m to $6m during their campaigns. Scotsburn was bought after a weekend pass-in (believed to be around $5m), Montalto was for most of its campaign a private sale (but finished in a Boardroom Auction at just over $7m) and Scott Grove was an Expressions of Interest closing Wednesday (reportedly 3 interested parties and sold 2 hours after the deadline for well over $6m).

October 29th: 54 Hanby St Brighton (above) (Kevin O’Brien) – The only auction I came out for today. Damian Davis – a bit out of his normal territory started up the engines with a solid opening spiel in front of a crowd of around 50. After he had finished his coverage on the home’s flow, light and feel, he asked for $3,300,000 from the crowd. Nothing was forthcoming, so a vendor bid at $3,300,000. Another vendor bid at $3,350,000 and a half time break did nothing to excite and so the words pass in brought an end to the proceedings on this lovely home that has a vendor at one level and potential buyers seemingly at another.

October 25th: 25 Scott Grove Glen Iris (Rae Tomlinson and James Connell): Bought within 2 hours of close of play for well in excess of the $6m+ price tag. This was a very good home on a very big parcel of land and the result was deserved and expected for a quality A grader – we rated it at almost 3 hats or 791/1000 (see our rating below). And a good night for Marshall White overall with 34 Chatsworth Prahran being sold through Madeleine Kennedy for $3,137,000.

October 24th: The collection of Expressions of Interest campaigns finishing in late October/Early November will be watched by many. There are some great homes, but the results this last weekend indicate they may not sell as strongly as September results suggested they might. We are monitoring a geographically widespread sample – all over $3m and will bring you the results as they come. Lets see if the K&B Mexican Wave** is in play for the Top End buyers or have taken their bat and ball and gone home.

**K&B’s Mexican Wave: It is possible that the above marketing campaigns could in fact produce higher results if we see more marketing campaigns in the style of Kay and Burton’s Mexican Wave effect. It’s just like at the MCG: Kay and Burton brings a group of homes together and push and prod till they get one buyer to perform and then uses that result to get other buyers to put their hands up on other homes. This is planned months beforehand, it’s totally legitimate, it’s brilliant in concept and it’s why people like Ross Savas and Mike Gibson are worth their fees and then some. Other Mexican Wave agents who plan and execute well are Marcus Chiminello, Rae Tomlinson, Heather Elder, Justin Long and Peter Bennison of Marshall White to name a few. However K&B are the absolute masters at the Mexican Wave.

Alastair Craig and Richard Winneke maneuver 3 bidders to a bought price of $2,855,000. This is where some of last spring's $3M plus action is right now at $3M minus.

October 22nd: During 2011 the $3M+ market has been as fickle as we can remember: it disappeared for most of the year, came back with a vengeance in September and has now seemingly run away lost again.
To demonstrate the point, only two homes out of 150+ scheduled $M+ auctions reported a sale price over $3 million today.  Yes two – that’s not many.

They were 34 Stevenson St, Kew with James Tostevin, which sold after auction and 7 Barrington Ave, also in Kew, with Scott Patterson, which sold before auction.

Mid- Week Apartment Auction: 3002/368 St Kilda Road (Marcus Chiminello) – Thursday night auction @ 7.00 pm. A similar property in the same building on the same side, same square metres, same décor, sold for $3.3m a short time ago. Quoting $3.3m plus then $3.5m plus. Surprising to have an auction in St Kilda Road but Marcus Chiminello and Nicole French (the new Batman and Robin) lined up auctioneer Growling Jack Bongiorno and 3 bidders fought it out past the last sale sales, past the first quote and the last quote and all the way up to $3,800,000.

Why did it sell so well? Demand exceeding Supply for North orientation; 315 sqm size with car parking on the 1st floor (no dizziness getting in and getting out) and Shrine views. Well marketed by one of the best in the business at this stuff.

Price: Has been gently improving in some key blocks on some key apartments – but it’s all about the apartment characteristics. There are literally hundreds of apartments above a million that have no buyers at all, because they have nothing unique to offer except a very cheap price.

Biggest Sale: 38 Kerferd St, Malvern East, Glen Coutinho (Hocking Stuart); Under hammer, $2,862,000, 4 bidders
Wow what an auction! This is as intense as it gets. Glen Coutinho has firmed as one of the best auctioneers in Melbourne in my humble opinion. What started out with meek interest from a lively crowd of around 70 people turned into the most hotly contested auction I’ve ever seen. A modest opening bid of $2,350,000 was announced from one party in the crowd and was quickly overtaken by another for $2,355,000.  The two went back and forth in increments of $5,000, then $2,000, then $10,000. Once the price reached $2,501,000 it seemed as though the action had come to a head, and Mr Coutinho retreated to his vendors to discuss the situation. Confident of reaching the price he and his vendors desired, Mr Coutinho continued unabated, knowing full well there were several other parties very interested in the property. As the property was being called down for a fourth time a third party entered the fray, bidding $2,540,000. This guy was ready for a showdown, but the original bidder stuck to it and was relentless in his pursuit of the Glen Iris home. Unable to continue, the young lion who made a worthy challenge correctly backed off, leaving the fight wounded but not insulted. At this point the crowd was able to breathe momentarily, but it wasn’t over! A fourth man entered the mix, and began his challenge. He proceeded to walk across the road towards the original bidder attempting to eye him down, but the original bidder was having none of it. As those who play enough poker know, when someone shows aggression towards you, it is generally a sign of weakness. Fortunately, the original bidder (who probably doesn’t play poker) picked up on the bluff and showed no signs of folding. Once the figure reached $2,862,000, the new combatant gave up announcing: ‘he can have it,’ and the auction ended with a standing ovation from the crowd, although it may have only been an ovation as they were already standing. (Daniel Ehrenreich)

Biggest Pass In: 11 Scotsburn Grove, Toorak, Jeremy Fox (RT Edgar); Passed in, $5,000,000, 1 bidder
A small crowd of around 40 and half are Toorak agents just looking. Jeremy Fox gives us a good solid spiel and we are away. Or are we? Jeremy calls for a $5,000,000 opening bid and gets nothing but silence. He goes inside for his half time break and leaves us all in the rain – actually he was pretty quick to return. I’m typing in Passed in on my Ipad and – whoops no – there was a genuine bid and $5,000,000 is taken up. Then it is passed in to the lone bidder. We await the outcome. (Mal James)

October 15th: Quality Stock Levels have improved for Buyers:
Good levels of good stock came into the market late September and buyers began to take deeper breaths and relax a little.  Angst dissipated somewhat as quality buyer saw more quality homes they could buy, diminishing the spectre of missing out on a home, leading to a drop in buyer urgency and ultimately price.

This Quality Supply Increase is best demonstrated at the Top End.

Want a home with a Tennis Court in Toorak? Got around $6 million dollars?

In the last week we visited, assessed and rated: 11 Scotsburn Toorak (Andrew Smith), 10 Montalto Toorak (Mike Gibson) and 25 Scott Glen Iris (Rae Tomlinson). All have tennis courts. So even if there are 10 buyers for tennis courts at this price level, there’s a fair bit a choice there. If normal market forces prevail and the buyers have good representation, then the prices on all three could be lower than if there was only one of these homes on offer. That’s unless, of course, one home is more strongly favoured than the others by a significant number of those 10 buyers – or if the Mexican Wave effect happens (see below).

Similarly in the last week we have been through some really good new home offerings at over $6 million, including 14 Kilsyth Toorak (Michael Armstrong); 15 Vista Toorak (Nicole Gleeson) and 33 Coppin Grove Hawthorn ( Scott Patterson) – see our ratings over the coming week.

These are just some examples. And in fact, quality stock levels have improved at all price levels. This is good news for Top End buyers and the reason we think October 2011 and hopefully November 2011 will be better months for buyers than were Winter 2011 and September 2011 in terms of:

1. More choice

2. Less chance of the runaway prices.

This price segment is all about either side of the Melbourne Cup – as a number of Expressions of Interest, Private Sale and Auction campaigns are scheduled for some sort of conclusion at that time. We anticipate publicly reporting in  early November as to market movements since September’s price and activity spiking.

25 Campbell Road Balwyn - Peter Mitchell - Under the hammer - $3,000,000 - 5 bidders

Week 4 September 24th: Overall market interest is down this week, best evidenced by the fact we had 30% less Marketnews readers on the Monday of  this week than the past two month average (alternatively we may be just getting boring). While some new AFL coaches bobbed up, so have some interesting homes and it may be worth your while to revisit your contacts to see what new offerings are on the horizon. The internet portals are showing more homes in the Upper End than they have for a while and this is due to the agents planning an extended campaign to manage arrange the Grand Final while still trying to get the home done and dusted prior to the Melbourne Cup. So this week may have been more interesting than you thought but soon it will be back to “quiet and low new stock” as far as listings go until the second week of November post Melbourne Cup (hopefully).

Biggest Sale: 2 Albert St, Brighton, Leigh Hallamore (Buxton); after auction, in excess of $3,100,000, 3 bidders
With a relatively big crowd of 60 lining both sides of Albert St, there was a feeling in the air that this auction would be an exciting one. And, although he had to open on a vendor bid of $2,500,000 to kick-start proceedings, auctioneer Leigh Hallamore soon had a tightly contested battle between three parties on his hands. Bidding was strong and constant with bidder 3 eventually earning the right to negotiate after the property was passed in at $3,120,000. Bought after for an undisclosed amount. (Jen Milligan)

Biggest Pass In: 324 Beaconsfield Pde, St Kilda West, Andrew Stuart (Hocking Stuart); Passed in, $5,000,000, no bidders
Auction Andrew Stuart took great pleasure in explaining to the crowd how the under-ground car lift and turning circle worked – with a  practical demonstration. Demonstrations over, Andrew asked for a bid somewhere near the lower end of the quoted range. No one offered a bid and  a vendor bid of $5,000,000 was made – still no interest and half time was called. Half time was short and sweet. The property was reoffered again and surprise, surprise – no bids and the property was passed in at $5,000,000. It has been a long time since a property on Beaonsfield Parade has sold under the hammer. Sales are being transacted its just taking some time for vendor and buyer to reach that all important middle ground. (Guy Angwin)

Bidderbuzz Auction: 25 Campbell Rd, Balwyn, Antony Woodley (Marhsall White); under the hammer, $3,000,000, 5 bidders
Antony Woodley took the helm and fielded bids from 5 parties before the hammer fell at $3,000,000; after being on the market around $2,700,000. Around 70 people attended this auction. Full report in Market News (Adam Woledge)

Some clean ups from previous auctions and another few off markets and quiet results for the month.

• 34 Tormey St Balwyn North – James Tostevin – after auction for around $3,000,000
• Brighton 12 North Road – Jonathan Dixon – off market – over $5,000,000
• Toorak 67 Lansell Road – Andrew Harlock – after auction – over $3,500,000
• Toorak 1 Sargood – Lachlan and Paul Castran – Expressions of Interest – new home – undisclosed
• Balwyn 49 Metung St – John Bradbury – Expressions of Interest – new home – undisclosed
• Kew 26 Dean St – James and Hamish Tostevin – Expressions of Interest – new home – over $4,000,000

Not everything sells at the top - 111 Walsh South Yarra - Passed-In $3,250,000

Week 3 September 17th: Good quality Top End (around $3m and above) continues to change hands in strong numbers.

• 40 Balwyn Canterbury Peter Dixon over $3,000,000
• 37 Fairview Hawthorn Jeff Gole just under $3,000,000
• 3 Gardiner Hawthorn Hamish and James Tostevin – 5 bidders $3,850,000
• 41 Drummond Carlton James Keenan – $3,160,000
• There were $3m pass-ins at 111 Walsh South Yarra and 2-4 Sandown in Brighton.

During the week these $3M+ were bought

• 48 Hampden Road Armadale Andrew Baines over $6,500,000
• 45 Martin Brighton Ian Jackson just under $4,000,000
• 42 Matlock Canterbury Sam Wilkinson just over $3,000,000
• 198 The Esplanade Stewart Lopez – were quoting in excess of $6,000,000 – undisclosed

This September, to date, we are aware of 26+ sales in the is $3m and above price range – see our $3Million Plus report. If you look at our $3Million Plus market report for last year, September 2010, we got to 46 boughts by months end – http://marketnews.com.au/2010/09/two-9-million-homes-bought-on-monday/ and that was pretty much a solid activity time in the market. The Top End has some ooomph just now.

Michael Gibson and Justin Follett of Kay and Burton were both a bit chipper when I spoke to them this weekend and assured me that while the market may seem a little boring until the end of the school holidays, there are some good homes coming on after that. Hopefully post Melbourne Cup as well. Michael added that vendor moods have improved with the Top End good news of recent times. We hope he is right as that will mean more choice for buyers.

78 Blessington St Kilda - John Bongiorno - 6 bidders - Under the Hammer for $3,400,000

Week Two September 10: With the third week in a row of significant competition on A grade Top End homes there is little doubt we are now firmly in the midst of  an activity spike due to significant stock shortages of “ready to move in family period and new homes” in the $2m to $6m range.

On top of what we saw 2 weeks ago (11 sales at $55m with an average of 2 bidders each) and last week (7 from 8 bought over $3m) we saw solid results this weekend at:

1. Kew 20 Barry – Peter Batrouney 3 bidders, under the hammer, $3,850,000
2. St Kilda 78 Blessington – John Bongiorno $3,400,000, 6 bidders.
3. Armadale 46 Stuart – Andrew Hayne 2 bidders, after auction, over $3,300,000
4. Malvern East 58 Kerferd – John Bongiorno, 1 bidder after auction, $3,075,000
5. Malvern East – Little Como – 50 Finch – Gowan Stubbings – Expressions of Interest – It was a long battle but there is a sold sticker on the board.
6. Toorak 8 Ultimo – Justin Long – After Auction – 3 bidders – $2,900,000

Whilst the market is giving a big tick to those it likes (well priced A graders); it is marking very harshly those that is doesn’t and they are best summarized as B or C graders – homes that have issues. Some examples below

1. Toorak 32 Canberra – its old and tired – big land though.
2. Kew 2 -4 Heather – No backyard, no garage and no real interest.
3. Malvern East 4-6 Finch – 0 bidders – a big reno required and only a few metres from Dandenong Road

And then there is 22 Surrey Road Toorak – Auction was due today – converted to Expressions of Interest at the last minute. What does this mean?

Yes our focus in Marketnews seems to be all at the top of Top End ($3M+). Right now that is where the real action is. There has been an unequivocal mood change that does not seem to have been shared by the market at the lower dollar values.

Buyers are now having to answer some very real questions.

What is the real price? – Eg What is the highest other bidder prepared to pay, if indeed there is one? As a buyer am I trying to buy an A grader or a C grader – am I $300,000 below the other bidder or $300,000 above nobody!

What should my new strategy be in trying to purchase a Top End home? Extract from an MW St Kilda auction report “This market now plays to MW’s great little system and strength – shake the buyers up, show ‘em their competition, work out who is the strongest, then pass it into them and mentally torture them in post auction dealings by referring to those outside. It’s very hard to argue with it’s effectiveness, for if you don’t play the game, on a good home in this market, then there is a high chance somebody else will. This market is now spiking in the direction that will enhance MW’s reputation amongst sellers but …  um how do I say un-enhance their reputation amongst buyers.” This applies to not only Marshall White, but Jellis Craig, Kay and Burton, RT Edgar, Benmac and many of the Bayside agents. The main question for buyers is not it’s legitimacy (the sellers absolutely want this); its how do I best manage it and achieve my main goal within my buyer risk profile.

How will you manage a negotiation situation under extreme pressure – then is not the time to work out a plan. After the event is not a time to say I could have done it a lot better. The market has changed at this level, and may well change again, as a buyer have you moved with the times?

Strong Crowd at South Melbourne 210 Nelson Road - Anthony Grimwade - Under the hammer - 3 bidders

Week One September 3: My week this week. A good week with another $3M+ purchase for a satisfied client – which makes a good string of activity in the last month for our company. Overall a solid start to Spring after a less than exciting Winter (well I enjoyed Scotland with my son anyway). A magic moment for me was the home at 8 Torrington Place in Canterbury (Michael Armstrong of Kay and Burton). We will have a rating up in the next few days – but in a nutshell it’s a very brave new build home. Its Olde English for a start, which already loses most of you; but it is built to such a standard that when its attracts a suitor to its sweet offerings they will be entranced and will move to a mindset of I have to have this. The French Provincial being built next door will attract more; but this home will attract a greater intensity of interest. The price – well its asking $5million and for me the end result will be give or take a million and the sold sticker will be slapped on in an almost impossible to guess timeframe. That will depend on when the specific bee walks into this very specific honey pot. A lovely, well thought out, beautifully crafted home – go and check it out – its open mid week and weekends or google for our rating by weeks end. Please we are happy to be more specific on perhaps how best to buy it; if indeed it’s of interest to you.

My other magic moment was the 29 Rose St Armadale Auction: I really love watching Heather and Rae (Marshall White) at work – they are masters at their craft also – just like the developers of 8 Torrington. The two of them had positioned buyers on this home (last sold for around $2,500,000 in mid 2008) to get involved in the biggest shootout I have personally witnessed at an auction this year. And they lined up one of the best sheriffs to take all-comers on – Growling Jack (John Bongiorno) and boy did he fire up – to use the vernacular he stuck it right up ‘em and corralled 9 bidders into the final $3,030,000 result. It was very powerful to watch and while not reflective of the overall market right now, it did provide a pointer to the current lack of stock at the $3m+ level and a beacon for those that feel the only way forward is without hope. Sure we are all a bit nervous, but things are simply not as bad as The Age daily headlines make you think they are – well not right now in the $3m+ segment anyway.

Again the standout $ segment – granted on very low numbers ( 6 from 8 ) Yes there were some big pass-ins like 67 Lansell Road Toorak ($3,200,000 vb) but it has some challenges. Also passed-in 2 Iona Toorak ($5,000,000 vb) – postscript: was bought over the weekend.  However the ones that were bought this week showed, in the main, multiple interest.

• Toorak 2 Iona – Jeremy Fox – bought after auction $5,080,000
• Armadale 29 Rose  – see report below 9 bidders $3,030,000
• Malvern East 7 Bates – Heather Elder and Rae Tomlinson – 3 bidders – bought after for $3,500,000+
• Hawthorn 34 Coppin Grove Jack Bongiorno – 3 bidders – under the hammer – $4,110,000
• South Melbourne 210 Nelson – Anthony Grimwade – 3 bidders – under the hammer – $4,215,000
• Toorak 19 Sargood – Jeremy Fox – 2 bidders – bought after – $4,700,000.
• Balwyn 12 Creswick – William Chen – Bought Before – Undisclosed – around $3,000,000 . This was after a failed auction earlier in the year.
• Canterbury 52 Mont Albert – Karen Gornalle – Private Sale – over $3,800,000.
• Hawthorn East 5 Constance – John Chartres – After Auction – just under $3,000,000. 2 bidders.

MALVERN EAST, 34 Emo Rd: The crowds were out in force again. Here, nearly 200 people crowded the street to watch Richard James (Jellis Craig) in action. Passed in, $1,925,000, 1 bidder

James Private Client Briefings contain far greater and more client specific detail than what you see below and are available for full service James Search and Negotiate clients throughout Melbourne.

For a private, confidential and no obligation discussion on what is really happening in your street, precinct and suburb from a buyer’s perspective contact Gina on (+613) 9804 3133 or 0457 835 255 from James Buyer Advocates.

These meetings can be phone, skype (overseas clients) and one on one including relevant sales results, off markets, agent negotiation trends, real market values on specific homes and practical strategies that are working for buyers at auction, private sale, off market or expressions of interest.

A sample of testimonials from satisfied clients http://www.jamesbuyeradvocates.com.au/testimonials.php

Just because we’re in a buyers market, with some great opportunities to buy good properties well, don’t think that means you have the upper hand when it comes to bidding at auction.

Many first time buyers think an auction is a matter of turning up and “winging” it. But when you are bidding on a home, you are not just competing against other buyers. You are also bidding against the agent, whose job and expertise is to maximise the selling price for his client. You will often be up against a collective brains trust of three or four and the agents will probably know who you are, what you have already bid on and what you’re likely to do at the auction.

And lately we have been seeing all too many examples where buyers are making it especially easy for skilled agents to do their job.

Take this scenario we witnessed a couple of weekends ago, which highlighted what a skilled agent can do even in a buyers market when presented with an inexperienced and overenthusiastic buyer.

The house was a lovely little single-fronted at 48 Emo Road, Malvern East, in one of my favourite family and investment areas, the Ardrie Park precinct. Middle of the road quality, plenty of space inside and outside and good flow. Good feel.

The agent  was Peter Bennison of Marshall White, is a seasoned operator who showed his stripes and his skills to perfection on this particular day.

The house had been quoted at a very reasonable $890,000 to $950,000, so even Peter was a little shocked when a strong and emotional opening bid came in at $950,000. The rest of the 100-strong crowd seemed stunned into silence as Peter tried, with no avail, to elicit further rises of $10,000.

Repairing inside for a strategic half-time break to consult with the no doubt ecstatic vendor, Peter returned to tell the crowd that the property would be passed in to the highest bidder if there were no further bids. After a pause, a second bidder piped up with an extra $10,000. Back like a shot, eagerness written all over his face, the original bidder responded with a crowd-hushing $1,000,000.

No one else was prepared to go any higher than that one, so the bidder was taken inside to negotiate a final price with the vendor. A few minutes later a final result of $1,150,000 was declared.

How did that happen? Why didn’t the bidder ask outside whether the property was “on the market” (over the vendor’s reserve price)? If he had, the final negotiation would have happened out there on the pavement instead of inside. Would the price have gotten up to $1,150,000 anyway – who knows? At least it would have happened openly and transparently, which is what auctions are good for. But the bidder had made his enthusiasm so completely clear to the agent that the agent was able to play him like a violin.

I don’t want to be critical of the bidder. There are worse “sins” in home-buying than paying more than you need to for a good house. But this scenario does point to some things to keep in mind if you are bidding on a property yourself.

1) As a bidder, by all means look strong to ward off other nervous buyers. But it doesn’t help to look emotional – an experienced agent will pick up on that and it will cost you money

2) In this market you have to test every step of the way. Ask questions. There was nothing wrong with the opening bid but the winning bidder’s second bid should have been presented in a very different way. The post auction problems snowballed from this one decision.

3) In this market, when your bid is well above the quote already, and when there is no proven competition, why rush up the pole? If you have to pay more at least let it take a few hours of testing.

4) Considering getting professional help.

The result may have been no different if a professional was managing the buying side. But I think a number of safety procedures could have been implemented prior to agreeing to that amount.

It’s a great market to buy in but you still need to be careful.

Mal

Printed each week in The Weekly Review – Melbourne’s Million Dollar Plus Magazine

PRAHRAN, 80 Williams Rd: A true sign of a wet auction day - a pile of shoes at the front door! Andrew Macmillan (BenMac), passed in, $2,300,000, no bidders

Key Points:

What little action there is – is for the most part away from auctions (expected and traditional for this time of the year)

• Toorak 252 Walsh – Jeremy Fox – off market around $8,000,000
• Toorak 320A Walsh – Peter Kudelka – quiet sale just under $2,900,000
• Toorak Ross St  – Andrew Sahar also of Kay and Burton (maybe underrated, here is another strong result ) – over $5,000,000
• Armadale 47 Huntingtower  – solid result with Kevin O’Brien of Jellis Craig – see auction report below

A few smiles were found on Saturday and here was one of them. David Hart (Buxton) with friend at 48 Regent St, Brighton East. Passed in $1,275,000, 1 bidder

At 6pm on Saturday, the James Clearance Rate for $M+ properties in Melbourne was 55% on the 29 auctions we attended. We covered around half the $M+ auctions this weekend. May is looking very lean for auctions and today was almost a non event auction wise

The Weekly Review Bidderman, our demand indicator, was 1.2 bidders per auction. Considering the low numbers on offer at auction this was not a good sign for sellers going forward.

The Perils of Emotional Bidding
The big auction issue for me this weekend was how bidders were bidding. I went to three auctions with a total of  nine bidders and saw some very surprising and costly bidding.

One example was the auction at 48 Emo Road, Malvern East. This is a lovely little single fronted in one of my favourite family and investment areas, the Ardrie Park precinct in Malvern East. Middle of the road quality, not bad for those just starting out in the home ownership stakes – plenty of space inside and outside and good flow. Good feel.

Anyway the auction is about to start and a nice healthy crowd of around 100 has gathered to hear the pearls from a not-so-old stager who rarely auctions these days – Peter Bennison.

Peter calls for an opening bid, to which one very enthusiastic bidder responds with a strong and emotional bid of $950,000. With repeated calls for further $10,000 rises unsuccessful, Peter takes a strategic half time break. On returning, he unsurprisingly declares that the property will be passed-in to the lone bidder if no further bidding. After a second bidder pipes in offering that elusive $10,000 rise, the original bidder responds emotionally and strongly with a crowd hushing $1,000,000. Perhaps the bidder should have asked the “Is it on the market?” question – because this was well above the original quote of $890,000 to $950,000.

What it also means is that the auction will now be completed behind closed doors with some argy bargy instead of cleanly in the street and under the hammer, which a good question could have allowed. The final result of $1,150,000 is decided inside a few minutes later. Wow! I know the buyer saved the fee of getting professional help and normally I am against such flexible post auction reserves but really if a  buyer wants to pay then they should be allowed to – it’s a free country. For the very experienced Mr Bennison this bidder was a gift, and he knew exactly how to work this  situation to the benefit of his client, the vendor (low quality agents may not have recognized the opportunity presented).

There are a couple of things that come from this as lessons to first home buyers and DIYers:

1) As a bidder, by all means look strong to ward off other nervous buyers. But it doesn’t help to look emotional – an experienced agent will pick up on that and it will cost you money

2) In this market you have to test every step of the way. Ask questions. There was nothing wrong with the opening bid but the winning bidder’s second bid could and in fact should have been presented in a very different way. Because it wasn’t, the post auction problems snowballed from this one decision.

3) In this market, on a $890,000 to $950,000 quote, and with no proven competition above $960,000 why would you be rushing up the pole to an incredible $1,150,000? If you have to pay it then at least take a few hours of testing to get there.

There’s no doubt that it’s a good home and I certainly would have recommended buying it. And maybe the result would have been no different if a professional was managing the buying side. But I think a number of safety procedures could have been implemented prior to agreeing to that amount.

There were further interesting results along these lines at the auctions at 13 Maskell St Brighton (Peter Kennett) and 7 McClaughlin Sandringham (Mark Earle). Please see today’s auction reports for more details.

Now back to the market – Future Stock:

Auctions – May is going to be very quiet compared to May 2010, when we witnessed well in excess of 1000 $M+ sales across Melbourne. Melbourne’s Inner East and Bayside represent a majority of  Melbourne’s Million Dollar Plus sales, and predicted auction numbers in these areas for the four weeks in May are as follows: this past weekend 45, next week 43, and the last two weeks in May, 105 and 106. Even though there were five Saturdays in May 2010, there would need to be an incredible number of private sales this year to get the final numbers of solds anywhere near last year, and that is not likely to happen with the current market mood.

Off Markets – According to agents there is a strong trend towards private and off-market sales. Nick Johnstone, of JP Dixon (Brighton) says: “We are seeing a definite swing towards private and off market sales which shows a transitional phase in the market.” 

Other agent comments:

David Oster, Jellis Craig (Ivanhoe): “The 28^th May will be a Strong Saturday. It is the last clear Saturday before School holidays.”

Richard Winneke, Jellis Craig (Hawthorn): “May 21, May 28 & June 4 are 3 bigger Saturdays and then many owners will hold off selling until August.”

Melbourne Wide April Wash Up :
Volume -  Has a lot changed in Million Dollar Melbourne between April 2010 and April 2011? Well, yes and no. April 2010 had around the same number of REIV reported $1m+ sales (there may be a 10% variance with the chance of late reported April 2011 sales to bring the April 2010 and April 2011 numbers closer together) but on a count of over 500 buy/sells, not much has changed in terms of volume.

However, even though the last market turned in April 2010, May 2010 was a boom month with well over 1000 REIV reported $m+ sales throughout greater Melbourne. Therefore May 2011 will be watched to see if it can get anywhere near those sorts of numbers, however we don’t think that will happen. We are still seeing a $M+ home bought every ninety (90) minutes somewhere in Melbourne and that was with Easter taking up a fair bit of the month.

Let’s look at a couple of suburbs which we randomly selected to give a spread of Greater Melbourne $M+ reported sales for the month of April 2011 compared to April 2010.

Price – In our opinion, backed up by REIV Median price results, we feel prices are definitely flat or falling and have been for the most part of this year and a lot of last year. When we say flat or falling we don’t mean plummeting – we mean a drop by as much as 10% over the last 12 months. However we are still seeing plenty of instances of the old property truism: If it is well located and has some WOW and the right price to attract multiple bidders then it is still possible for the ultimate buyer to be paying more than you would have expected last year.

Winter is upon us and buyers and sellers alike appear in a less enthusiastic mood than even a few weeks ago. Even so, we have bought more $1M+ homes this year to date than this time last year at the same time.  And why wouldn’t you buy now, unless you know something we don’t? Price and choices have been considerably better than last year.

$3M+ Market Report:
Back from a week or two off, this market now, has a fairly clear run till Christmas, with a only brief breaks for a couple of holiday weekends.

A couple of strong results today:

• Elwood 18 Normanby (Paul Sutherland) – Bought for $3,375,000, 4 bidders – see our video auction
• Camberwell 26 Alma (Alastair Craig) – Bought After – $Over $3,000,000 at asking – no bidders – there is that strange bidding thing again

Over the next four to six weeks we should see more choice and some reasonable activity (although not expected anywhere near the levels of last year), as the May market is a traditional agent preferred selling time. Why? Well there is a good stretch of time until Queens Birthday weekend to run an uninterrupted campaign. Stock Quality is the unknown.

Come July things will be relatively quiet as there is a general sellers’ feeling (rightly or wrongly) that good homes do not look their best at this time of the year and accordingly a number of high end selling agents take winter holidays in Europe and therefore do not program campaigns to be run in their absence.

In the post Easter week or so there have been ten or more high end sales including the representative  half dozen below

• 15 St Ninians in Brighton for between $8m and $9m – perhaps not a lot more than what is was sold for less than 2 years ago (need to look up sale time to be absolutely sure of date) – Justin Follett of Kay and Burton
• 255 New Brighton for between $5.5m and $6m – Regina Schmidt and Brian Devlin of Buxton
• 50 Hotham St East Melbourne which had been on the market for at least 6 months for $7million – Paul Richards of Hocking Stuart – on the market for a fair bit of last year and also a failed auction. Nonetheless a reasonable price – not everything the sellers wanted – but more than had been offered at times in the past by buyers. A good result for both parties.
• 150 Clarendon East Melbourne – the Salta apartments saw Anton Wongtrakun deliver another big sale at $5,200,000 for Unit No 4
• Out to the paddocks of Lower Plenty with a Marketnews favourite Rocco Montanaro of Morrison Kleemand who achieved close to $3m on an Expressions of Interest Campaign for a good home on 7 acres at 75 Cleveland.
• And we round up our selection of high end Easter Sales with a $6M+ sale at Mount Eliza 15 Freemans Road – Michelle Skoglund of Aqua

In summary over Easter the market at this level has not been dead, but definitely subdued – there is increasingly a dampening mood in terms of both buyer and seller confidence. Time will tell if this is a short or longer term phenomenon. Price will play a important part going forward as we seemingly move into more uncertain market conditions – i.e. ones that are not as clear as they have been in the past 2 years since we awoke from the GFC. Overall the market now and in fact all of 2011 has not been strong at the $3m+ level – but there are still enough transactions (especially in Bayside) of sufficient value to avoid holding a wake just yet.

With winter approaching and a fair amount of stock available we think it is a buyers’ market and the future is best described as – “uncertain times”.

Finishing on a positive note our James Investment Division has seen some solid interest with investors coming back into the market (rentals are improving) and one current flavor of the times is blocks of flats. Some examples of what we are talking about.

The Big Issue: Klarity Kris and Architect Adam discuss the big issue of the week – does this market, with prices currently dropping, have elevated risks for buyers ? See what the two have to say by clicking on the live action.

Auction Video: This week Cafe Guy heads to Elwood on what was a big auction day for the Port Phillip area. Watch  the auction video of  18 Normandy Rd (Sutherland Farrelly) by clicking on the live action.

Buyer Masterclass: Double-fronter or two storey, single-fronted cottage? Architect Adam explores this dilemma in this week’s Buyer Masterclass. It’s a great article check it out!

We Only Buy Homes and Happy Mothers Day Mum and in fact to all Mums – we love you all!

Like many auctions this weekend, a lot of standing around, not doing much. MALVERN EAST, 9 Lewes Drive: Passed-in at $2,500,000 with two bidders. Anthony Grimwade (RT Edgar)

At 6pm on Saturday the James Clearance rate for $M+ was 57% on the 30 auctions we attended. That was well down on last week’s cameo of excitement, but understandable giving the quality change between this week and last week at the Top End.

Bidderman, our demand indicator, was 1.5 bidders per auction. However the quality of the offerings was one of the lowest this year.

While there were a few volcanoes (4 or more bidders), what was more interesting was that 1 in 3 homes were ducks meaning they didn’t get a bid a all. We think that was a confirmation of the market reaction to this weekend’s lack of Top End quality.

In fact, only 1 in 5 of $M+ homes monitored this weekend sold under the hammer.  The rest sold before or soon after – or didn’t sell at all. That’s an Under the Hammer Clearance Rate of 20%.

What that means is that in this current market buyers need a lot more than just a ‘hand up in the air and hope’ strategy to buy homes well.

Market Summary:

There were plenty of auctions at the lower levels, e.g. at or around a million dollars, but many lacked any WOW factor.

A number of the key selling agents were off this weekend on holidays and, as with many buyers, they seem to have turned their attention to pursuits other than buying and selling.

It was hard to find a property over $2 million up for auction. The only $3 million plus auction we saw in Toorak was at 68 Hopetoun Road with Steve Abbott of Jellis Craig – an art deco that seems to get sold every 12 months (see report below).

The REIV median prices came out this week and rightly confirmed what the market has been saying for some time: Prices are weaker.

This year to date has been a positive one for buyers with reduced competition, more choice and lower prices. On the flip side the buying opportunities are only such if you take them (a Steve Abbott auction line).

Next week, there are almost no auctions and not too much the week after.

Post Easter, as we said last week, may or may not be a different story. But our feeling is that quality choice will dry up and the big issue will become finding a rose amongst the thorns, the pass-ins and the stales. If those roses are hard to find then prices for them will firm as new quality drops with discretionary vendors adopting a wait and see strategy.

What Sold Well – Volcanoes with 4 or more bidders

• Albert Park, 62 Barrett St – Peter Simmons – Nicely renovated Period Home – $1,575,000
• Hawthorn, 23 Falmouth St – Hamish Tostevin – Nicely renovated Period Home – $1,330,000
• Hawthorn, 11 College St – Richard Earle – Nicely renovated Period Home – $1,409,000
• Kew, 36 Maitland Ave – David Oster – Land site – $1,345,000
• Toorak, 80 Grange Rd – Rodney Morley – Nicely renovated Period Town Residence – $1,500,000

$3M+ market: Overall, the high end at $3 million+ appears as weak as it has been for 12 months. Although  a shortage of new quality stock post Easter has put some zing back into the market as some buyers are forced to act.  Growing kids, divorce, lifestyle, whatever cannot wait for everyone indefinitely. Go to our $3m+ report to see most of the last weeks’ 10+ sales.

Michael Armstrong, Kay & Burton, South Yarra: “I think we can expect a fairly normal market post Easter.  Market conditions are settled and stock levels looking forward to May/June are lighter than what we’ve experienced in the past couple of months.  Vendors have had to adjust their expectations in recent times and buyers with long term views have realised that the past few weeks have presented them with good opportunities. The better quality offerings will continue to attract competition and alternatively  buyers will continue to deal harshly with those vendors (and agents) who price properties incorrectly.”

ST KILDA, 2 Marine Pde: On a bit of a rollercoaster day, it was apt to have the Scenic Railway at Luna Park as the backdrop of this Claudio Perruzza (Biggin Scott) auction. Passed in, $1,850,000, no bidders

Biggest Sale we covered: 68 Hopetoun Rd, Toorak, Steve Abbott (Jellis Craig); after auction, $3,050,000, 3 bidders
“This art deco property with Heritage One (HO1) overlay was looking for a committed buyer to make it a home. A vendor bid of $2,800,000 got the proceedings underway and the first bidder entered the race with a bid of $2,850,000. A second vendor bid of $2,900,000 signalled that the bidding was still some way off from the desired sale price. Auctioneer Steven Abbott wouldn’t entertain an increment of $5,000, demanding at least $10,000 to stay in the race. Despite keen bidding, this property was passed in at $3,020,000 but this was just the start of the negotiations. Bought after for $3,050,000.” (Debbie McTaggart)

Biggest Pass In we covered: 12 Dudley Pde, Canterbury, Doug McLauchlan (Marshall White); passed in $2,000,000, no bidders
“Doug McLauchlan took centre stage in the very big, leafy backyard of this great property and looked ready for action. Assisted by his Marshall White team, Mr McLauchlan explained that the circa 1923 home had been in the same family for a massive 72 years. But even the sentimentalists amongst us in the crowd weren’t ready to put their hands in the air and bid. Mr McLauchlan opened and closed on a vendor bid of $2,000,000.” (Jen Milligan)

Auction Video: Architect Adam heads to sunny Hawthorn this week to witness a ripper auction at 23 Falmouth St, a Marshall White property with auctioneer Hamish Tostevin.  Click on the live action.

Big Issue and Weekend Reflections: Coming back after the Easter holidays.

Two Weeks Off: Marketnews will be on holiday for two weeks with our next Marketnews on the 7th of May. A number of agents are talking up the 21st and 28th of May as possible Super Saturdays (as buyers let’s hope so). For James Buyer Advocates it will be business as usual.

We Only Buy Homes and have a safe Easter break:

Job Advertisement:

MALVERN EAST, 15 Albert St: There was a bit of fence sitting at this Andrew Hayne (Marshall White) auction, and not a lot of action. Passed in $1,600,000, no bidders

With not much on offer this weekend, only one over $3m ( Steve Abbott – 68 Hopetoun Rd, Toorak) and minimum quality at the lower end, my thoughts turned to family, holidays and the Pies. Winter will be a time of continuing opportunity, but as buyers we will have to work hard to find them. And you will still need some bravery if you wish to take those opportunities. Overall, unless you are convinced that the world is going to fall apart, this is the best time to buy since GFC 2008 – providing it is the right home at the right price.

South Yarra, 2/264 Walsh St. A good high $3 million result from Marcus Chiminello. It’s not our job to talk agents up,  but in a slow apartment market Marcus has got a number of solid results in recent times.

Andrew Hayne, Marshall White, Armadale: “There will be a bit more stock post Easter, but May won’t be as busy as years gone by due to Easter being a bit later. The 3 weeks leading up to the June long weekend will be busy after the school holiday period, and then slow down again.”

Daniel Wheeler, Marshall White, Armadale: “What we will see beyond Easter will be fair prices being paid for properties, and a shrinking amount of property becoming available leading into the colder months. June is distracted with a long weekend, and yes, it’s school holidays time again – so we will have some interruptions. In the meantime, enjoy the quieter roads!”

Have a good holiday from all things real estate and see you back bright, refreshed and ready to buy after Easter. Drive safely – Mal.

“Oh Yeah Sure Buddy - you are joking, aren't you?” Sold for an undisclosed amount, $500,000 over reserve. 4 bidders. Ivanhoe East 32 Warncliffe. David Oster.

At 6pm on Saturday the James Clearance rate for $M+ was 71% on the 34 auctions we attended. WOW – 71%, a big change from last month.

Bidderman, our demand indicator of bidders per auction, was at 1.8. So on our biggest $M+ auction weekend so far this year, when you would expect buyers to thin out and Bidderman to drop, it actually went up on the trend of the last few weeks.

It may be just one day but it was strong out there this weekend. For the first time since late February our advocates reported feeling feeling genuine price pressures whilst bidding.

Market Summary: The big question is whether this is a statistical blip or whether we are a seeing the trend return towards a balanced market. If so, why?

1. Buyers feel a little better than they did last month and confidence came back into the market as a result. Our enquiry rates are certainly up.
2. The overall quality of homes on offer was up on previous weeks and they were plentiful in number. We saw lots of 700+ James Home Rating (quality) homes go to auction this weekend.
3. Last week as buyers looked into the future they saw that the cupboard of  post Easter offerings was bare – and so they adjusted their game plan accordingly.

Whether this is a blip or a trend change will largely be determined by what discretionary sellers do in May. If they are encouraged by this weekend’s results to put their properties onto the market, then prices may stay softer than last year. If those sellers stay out and demand continues as is, then the overhang of stales will begin to be mopped up and the good buying conditions of the last months (price and choice) will dissipate.

This weekend, again, we saw the overall power of the Melbourne market and the power of demand and supply. There is an underlying strength in Melbourne homebuying (based in immigration and lack of homes), that has slackened off in recent times as buyers become more circumspect with concerns about overseas events, jobs, and who knows what exactly. As well there has been plenty of choice. BUT as soon as there is a hint of a quality stock shortage the market responds, particularly with regards to well-located quality family homes, on land and of a period flavour. And it responds strongly.

More insights

• It wasn’t just the consistent $1m to $1.5m range holding up its end in isolation, this was also the strongest single week this year for $3m+ buys.
• It was the second strongest clearance rate of the year, despite an almost Super Saturday (140 $M+ Auctions – Inner East and Bayside)
• We saw consistent bidding across the board, with over 75% of monitored auctions having at least one bidder.
• The big question going forward after our Easter market break is whether nervous sellers will re-enter the market on one week’s good showing.
• Prices are generally down on this time last year (there are exceptions), so good homes are attractive right now. And while new choice may become limited,  some existing choice (overhang) still remains.
• Top End rentals are getting considerably more rent than expected as supply in relation to demand is tightening. This observation from two agents needs more examination at a later date. We’re interested in how widespread this may be, why it is happening and what effects it may have on the buying market. (Are borderline investors perhaps re-entering the Top End?).

Wild and Wooly - the weather that is, not Rob Vickers-Willis. Toorak 3 Denham. Passed In $2,010,000. 2 bidders.

The $3m+ Market’s strongest 2011 week so far (some examples):

South Yarra 43 Marne St: Nicole Gleeson of Kay and Burton: Bought well over the $12,000,000 quote range, putting Domain Precinct land values at $8,000 per sqm for the bigger blocks.

Hawthorn 51 Berkeley St with Tim Blackett also of Kay and Burton: Over $7,000,000 on Scotch Hill for a good home with tennis court that needs some floor plan reworking.

While still in Hawthorn, Mr Nice Guy and the Very Effective Tim Picken of Jellis Craig got away the quinella with 25 Mary St (modern home in Grace Park) being bought for a credible $4,300,000 and 1 Hilda (period home in Grace Park) for $2,800,000. Both prices were a little down on ambitious asks but they were nonetheless solid prices for what they were.

Kew – Was it us who cried out the death of the Balwyn formula – i.e. new build, small block and overpriced? Well technically we are still credible, because these were in neighbouring Kew: with 21 Macartney (Walter Dodich of Marshall White) and 5 Mawson (Peter Dixon of Jellis Craig) both selling at auction today for $4 million-ish, the death of this market may be a little exaggerated. It was only two sales, but they were biggies.

Malvern and Canterbury -  50 Wattle Valley, Canterbury (Duane Wolowiec and James Tostevin) sold under the hammer for a strong $3,465,000; 54 Stanhope Malvern with Rae Tomlinson also under the hammer for $3,170,000 and 13 Rubens Grove Canterbury with Fletcher’s Jeremy Desmier bought before for over $3,000,000.

Bayside has recorded a few $3M+ sales as well, with 29 Bay Street, Brighton (Bert Stewart of Buxton) selling post auction over $3,550,000. The final result put north-facing Golden Mile land (no view) at more than $3,200 per sq metre. That is a “steady as she goes price” similar to last year’s Golden mile (no view) buys. Another $3m+ sale with a strange twist (all non bidders asked to leave auction) was at 40 Drake Brighton (Ian Jackson of Kay and Burton).

Toorak While on land sales, 1073 Malvern Road (Justin Long) passed in at $3,225,000 and a reserve was offered which was not taken up by the pass-in bidder. Two new bidders appeared and a second auction took place resulting in a sale well over the pass-in figure.

For full details each week of what is happening in the Top End $M+ market see our regular $3-Million-Plus Market Reports.

Round the Grounds – Price this year v last year and a word on Post Easter stock levels.

Malvern John Bongiorno, Marshall White: “Price is a little softer on certain homes but on high quality homes they are still rocking, granted buyers are more discerning. Stock levels are not as strong as last year. Rentals at the top end are exploding in the middle and top end market. Big news is rents have increased, possibly making investments more attractive at the higher end. There is such a shortage of homes to rent.”

Caulfield Rodney Morley, Woodards: “I think the negativity means less stock is coming on in May and Winter. Everybody wants records that are not coming at the moment. The market is definitely softer than this time last year in price. Buyers (then) were buying anything. Right now, buyers do not feel that urgency. No question that the market is softer.”

Brighton Bert Stewart, Buxton: “I think the market is around 10% down on some top end homes. Stock levels and therefore buyer choice after Easter are not looking good.”

Camberwell Geoff Hall, Noel Jones: ”Prices are down around 10% on this time last year, with some exceptions for quality homes, and stock post Easter is just not coming on like it did last year.”

Hawthorn Richard Winneke, Jellis Craig: “Big drop in new buyer enquiry this week. Probably due to the holiday factor but it was a noticeable drop. Rentals are definitely getting more than I expected price-wise and this may stimulate investment into Top End homes. East of Burke Road (Camberwell and Canterbury) has not performed as well as Hawthorn and Kew this year to date. I think prices are still relatively solid around that early million dollar mark but softer higher up.”

Carlton Tom Roberts, Nelson Alexander:  ”Stock levels Post Easter are tightening with only the sellers that need to sell going to market. Good homes still going exceptionally well but those results are in amongst the not so good going not quiet so well as last year. Prices are down a smidgen.”

Playing for Keeps here. Big 150 plus crowd. 29 McKinnon, Carlton. 3 bidders. Bought for a whopping $1,417,000 (462 sqm). We thought it was justified, but it was still big. Nick Renna, Peter Sinclair and Melissa Ryan of Hocking Stuart

Biggest Sale we covered: 21 Macartney Ave, Kew; Walter Dodich (Marshall White): After auction, undisclosed around $4,000,000
“Being in the coveted Sackville area this auction attracted a large crowd of about 100. The crowd were well spread out and even blocked the road in front of the property as they heard auctioneer Walter Dodich open proceedings. The auction began in Mr Dodich’s own words with a ‘traditional’ vendor bid at $3,700,000 as no one was willing to start things off. However this was the trigger that allowed two bidders to start the battle off for the property. Initially there were meant to be three bidders however the third bidder couldn’t get his bid in as he always cut off by the other two. When he finally got one in there was applause from the crowd and a cry of joy from the bidder. As the auction went on, the climax built and the crowd held their breath as the price rose and rose yet there was still no indication from Mr Dodich about whether the property was on the market or not. At $4,000,000 Mr Dodich passed the property in and after lengthy negotiations the property was bought after for an undisclosed amount.” (Josh Bong)

Biggest Pass in we covered: 72 Kerferd St, Malvern East, John Bongiorno (Marshall White); Passed in, $2,800,000, no bidders
“With 300 people having viewed this property and 100 or so crowded into the garden of this Gascoigne Estate home, auctioneer John Bongiorno was confident of a sale. But it was not to be with a vendor bid of $2,800,000 the only one of the day and the property passed in. However, with one interested party heading inside, it may not be long before this stunning property is sporting a ‘sold’ sign.” (Debbie McTaggart)

The Big Issue: Architect Adam and Klarity Kris discuss whether they believe buying conditions will be as good post-Easter as they are now.

Auction Video: This week Jen Milligan, our Market News Co-ordinator, fills in for our advocates who were busy with other auction commitments. 15 Epping St, Malvern East, a BenMac auction with Iain Carmichael. Click on the live action auction video.

Buyer Masterclass: Conditions are great for homebuyers – so where are they?

We Only Buy Homes

New Subscriber System: Over the next few weeks we will  introduce a free subscription model giving you greater access to our council-specific wraps, which include auction results, news, opinion and analysis on a micro level. This subscription model helps us improve your browsing experience as clients or general subscribers by delivering more relevant content to you on the site and in your email newsletter. Sign up by clicking Subscribe at the top right of the website. If you experience any problems as we are testing and implementing this new improved system please let us know at enquiry@james.net.au

MALVERN EAST, 72 Kerferd St: A large crowd gathered for the auction of this Gascoigne Estate home, but there was no sale. John Bongiorno (Marshall White), passed in, $2,800,000, no bidders

Key Points:

• A lot on offer in Stonnington today with 42 auctions monitored over a $m with 22 homes over a million bought.
• Although there was a lot on offer – it was a mixed bag quality wise.
• If there is such a thing the good home clearance rate index would have shown a better result than the stats.
• It was a case of a lot of the good stuff sold, some of the good stuff didn’t and much of the overpriced and/or rubbish got what it deserved – zilch.

What sold well

• South Yarra 43 Marne St: Nicole Gleeson of Kay and Burton: Well over the $12,000,000 quote range making Domain Precinct land values at $8,000 per sqm for the bigger blocks. Private Sale mid week
• 54 Stanhope Malvern with Rae Tomlinson under the hammer for $3,170,000.
• 1073 Malvern Road Toorak (Justin Long) passed in at $3,225,000 and a reserve was offered – not taken up – two new bidders appeared and a second auction took place resulting in a sale well over the pass in figure.
• Malvern East – 13 Chanak with Maddie Kennedy and John Manton of Marshall White – great “feel” home but tougher location being fringe Gascoine to get the $2m plus number – it got it.
• Toorak – 3 May – Richard Hornidge of RT Edgar – a bit of a dog single fronted needing a reno but was priced sensibly – bought for $1,055,000.
• Toorak – 1a Nareeb Court  – Matthew Wassylko of Marshall White – 0 bidders last year, this year 3 bidders and was bought for $2,940,000.

What didn’t sell well

• Luxury Apartments seem to have ground to a halt – one big exception 2701/368 St Kilda Road Melbourne $3,410,000 – Marcus Chiminello – No real capital growth there, but at least it sold.
• Toorak – 3 Denham – Courageous price expectations?
• Malvern – 225 Tooronga – Difficult location?
• South Yarra -  3 Shipley – Good home and garden but some Punt Road noise and some overlooking?

STOP PRESS: March, while not huge in numbers, did finish the month with 3 solid mid week $3M+ buys – including 4 bidders at $7 million or better at 2 of them.

• Toorak Ottawa Avenue : Jeremy Fox of RT Edgar – quiet sale off market in the mid $8m’s
• Toorak 19 Huntingfield: Justin Long and Peter Bennison of Marshall White – mid week auction, 3 bidders and on the market at $6,700,000. Bought under the hammer for $7,060,000. James Connell said afterwards that this market was not all bad news and Huntingfield supported that.
• Canterbury 13 Rubens: Jeremy Desmier Fletchers and Tom Ryan, Sold before Auction: Over $3,200,000
• South Yarra – The Caroline Coachhouse – they were looking for $3m ish for a very long time (eg in the years) and now Mike Gibson – Kay and Burton has got it away.

South Yarra 17 Acland St: Gerald Delany. Fairly typical of the market for the slightly overpriced or slightly less than perfect. Passed-In with no bidders and now for sale at POA.

New Subscriber System: Over the next few weeks we will  introduce a free subscription model giving you greater access to our council-specific wraps, which include auction results, news, opinion and analysis on a micro level. This subscription model helps us improve your browsing experience as clients or general subscribers by delivering more relevant content to you on the site and in your email newsletter. Sign up by clicking Subscribe at the top right of the website. If you experience any problems as we are testing and implementing this new improved system please let us know at enquiry@james.net.au

Week Ending 26th March: The Market at this level was fairly quiet this week with the good sales, price wise but not too many of them.

• Templestowe, 9 Edwin: On the market since October of last year with Jeremy Tyrell of Fletchers. Has been bought for in excess of $4,700,000
• Richmond 37 Docker: Ken Griffith of Jellis Craig. Bought at auction, $3,300,000 – $3,500,000
• Hawthorn 23 Lisson Grove: Michael Lui of Marshall White. Bought after auction $3,600,000 – $3,800,000
• Toorak 17 Lansell: Lisa Jarrett of Abercrombys. On the market since December of last year and selling for circle mid $3′s

Armadale 1026 Malvern Road: The recipe was there for a good auction - quality period home on big land - however the market is a different beast from some time ago at this price level and a quiet auction took place with Jack Bongiorno in charge. Opened on a bid of $3,400,000, passed in to that bidder and was bought after for an undisclosed amount. Crowd of 40.

Week Ending 19th March:

Off Markets, Forthcoming Auctions and Expressions of Interest are increasing as market stock levels begin to rise dramatically. However some big sales including a $13,000,000+ in Toorak and a $7,000,000+ in Brighton along with a few other $3m+ buys indicate the market hadn’t completely gone to sleep .

James Tostevin: “Overall a good day. The $3m+ market is hard to read and we are not getting huge numbers of bidders at many auctions;  so there is a case to say the results may be looking healthier than the market actually is – but from a purely stats points of view (clearance rates) today was a good day.”

In Boroondara:

• Balwyn 34-36 Linckens:  (Toby Parker of Hocking Stuart) – a $3m+ auction slotted in for auction this weekend has been bought before.The quote was over $3.7m and if, as we believe, it was bought for close to $4 million then it was a strong sale.
• Kew 41 Victor Avenue: (James Tostevin) – Two strong bidders and sold under the hammer for $4,100,000.
• Canterbury 17a Alexander Avenue: Passed In $3,200,000. No bidders
• Kew 22 Stawell: Passed In $3,000,000. 0 bidders.

In Stonnington:

• 19 Kingston St, Malvern East, Iain Carmichael (BenMac); After auction in excess of $4,600,000
  “Auctioneer Iain Carmichael was in charge of proceedings for this picture perfect home.  A large crowd of over 80 packed in to the beautiful mature gardens surrounding the house, as the sun shone to show this property at its very best.  The initial vendor bid of $4,250,000 didn’t seem over the top given the location of this park-adjacent idyll.  Despite the auctioneer being confident of a sale, no further bids were forthcoming and, after referral to the vendor, the property was passed in. (Debbie McTaggart)
  Footnote: Nobody bid at auction at $4,250,000 but 2 bidders emerged post auction and fought it out afterwards to a price well in excess of the reserve and well in excess of $4,600,000. Go figure.
• Armadale 1026 Malvern: James Redfern of Marshall White: Passed in $3,400,000 and bought afterwards. 1 bidder.

In Bayside:

• Brighton 29 St Ninians: As always, auctioneer Jonathan Dixon opened proceedings right on time and the preliminaries were soon completed. This property has a supreme and uninterrupted view of the Bay from the City to Royal Brighton Yacht Club and the potential for future development was clearly explained by Mr Dixon. Nevertheless, no bids were forthcoming and the property was passed in on a vendor bid of $7,300,000.
• Brighton 18A Martin: Passed In for $3,300,000. 1 bidder.

Labour Day Weekend March 12th: As expected minimal activity over the weekend; well no auctions that is – a heap of new stock was listed to go onto an already over supplied market.

Brighton 2 Shandford: Bought Post Auction for over $7 million or in around $10,000 per sq metre - meaning Melbourne absolute waterfront is amongst the most sought after land in the world. Regina Schmidt and Brian Devlin from Buxton.

On a buying note, the Golden Mile in Brighton is still alive and well with Regina Schmidt and Brian Devlin from Buxton getting 2 Shandford away post auction for an undisclosed amount over $7 million and in fact over Shandford’s other $7 million sale of a few weeks ago. This home had some positives and will possibly be retained but with two blocks totaling around 1400 sqm going for nearly $15,000,000 this shows that Melbourne absolute waterfront has some of the most sought after beach front in the world on a dollar per sq metre basis.

Another quieter one in the Golden Mile just before the long weekend – 11 Kent Avenue (Stan Fisher of Biggin and Scott) – was reported as bought again for an undisclosed amount having been sold only last year for a tick over $4 million. The rest of Melbourne may be a little quiet, but Golden Mile Brighton is relatively hot for land sales (compared to previous years).

In the heart of the Bagel Belt at 85 Lumeah Road Caulfield North (Gowan Stubbings of Kay and Burton) a large block of land (around 1800 sqm) with a tired home on it was sold for an undisclosed amount for over $4 million, under the hammer, having been on the market at $3.5 million – 3 bidders. That makes it number two along with Langdon Road at or over $4m in the last fortnight in Caulfield.

In Stonnington 20 St Georges has been bought for an undisclosed amount. The property had been quietly on the market for some time before a more public campaign this year. The asking price estimate was $12,000,000 to $15,000,000 and it is believed to have been sold in the middle. Andrew Tolson of TBM was the selling agent. We went through it a few times on behalf of different clients and found it to be a home of some class with good light and a nice flowing floor plan – slight negatives were a less than full-sized tennis court and some overlooking at the rear (although it was not significant and, if you lost the tennis court, planting could remedy that). Being St Georges it commanded a premium – although to date its “little brother” down the road at No 10 hasn’t sold at an already passed Expressions of Interest deadline. However, considering the home’s characteristics, it would be hats off to the agents if it got near their $10,000,000 ask, even if it is St Georges.

Also went through 14 Bruce St Toorak late last month –  it has been bought for a reasonable margin over $3,000,000. Again showing the power of good architects and in particular Wayne Gillespie. Difficult block and orientation and a market place that has competition for supply, so this was a good result for an Expressions of Interest campaign and the man that sells a number of these very quietly – Marcus Chiminello.

‘Hoping for $3m in a different market but didn’t quite get there’ stories: In Port Phillip, 7 Pilley Street in St Kilda East, which was originally marketed at an ambitious around $3 million, has been bought for around $2.6 million - Jeremy Fox of RT Edgar. All things considered, this was still a very good result for the area. In Malvern, 5 Gaynor Court with Rob Vickers-Willis got to $2.73 million and a three storey terrace home in Carlton with Anthony Gattuso of AG Property got around the same amount. All solid results.

Overall still a lot of properties on the market at this $3m+ price level that have completed normal auction and Expression of Interest with no result.

Malvern 66 Claremont: Iain Carmichael: Bought for $3,700,000: 3 bidders: At this point, someone yelled "is it on the market?" and the BenMac team hastily retreated inside to speak to the vendor. Upon his return, Mr Carmichael said yes indeed it was on the market and it was here that the bidding really took off. After the price hit $3,625,000, one of the bidders went bang - $3,700,000 - and knocked everyone else out of the competition. A great finish to a great auction

Week Ending 5th March: All the bigger deals were basically in one spot, Stonnington.

Actual Boughts in Stonnington:

• Malvern 19 Hamilton – Justin Long – At Auction – $4,357,000
• Malvern 66 Claremont – Iain Carmichael – At Auction – $3,700,000
• Toorak 9 Ross – Justin Long – Auction – over $3,600,000
• Toorak – 3 Teringa – Andrew(s) McCann and Macmillan of Benmac – post last weeks auction – over $3,500,000 – nearly $5000 per sqm for rear south facing land
• Toorak – 611 Toorak Road – Expressions of Interest – Greg Herman of RT Edgar – $3,500,000
• Toorak – 231 Kooyong Road – James Redfern – Post last Saturday’s auction – over $3,500,000
• Malvern East – 127 Finch St – Rob Vickers-Willis – $3,300,000

Bayside: A Key land Indicator

• 11 William St Brighton with Rod Richardson of Hocking Stuart – $3,100,000 for 1383 sqm of land = $2,241 per sqm for land in central Brighton. Solid and expected result. 5 bidders.

Boroondara: Action at the Top End almost non-existent

• Stock Surge – Large amounts of $M+ stock are hitting the market for pre-Easter campaigns
• 61 Bellett Camberwell has been on the market since July of last year and was sold by Sam Wilkinson of Kay and Burton mid week for $3,100,000.
• The Balwyn formula of big block, new home, big price tag seems to have come to a grinding halt – very few high end new sales. Opportunity?
• Off markets are on the increase.

Port Phillip: The overpriced are as cold as ice in Port Phillip right now. No bites, no action – as evidenced by the pass-ins of yesterday and the first two weeks of this market.

• I went to a Beaconsfield auction yesterday – the offering slightly less than perfect but still a great spot – however the start was a $4million vendor bid and then a $4,250,000 vendor bid. I may have to eat humble pie when the result comes in but for me the four sales on this strip over $4m last year seemed different offerings.
• 49 Howe Crescent, which was advertised in an Expressions of Interest campaign for later this month, sold last week well over its $5m+ guideline for more than $6m (we believe). A very rare large land size at 915 sqm with a double fronted Victorian on it shows the pulling power of large land so close to the CBD in the St Vincent Garden precinct (or just off it). Michael Coen of Hocking Stuart was the dealmaker on this one. Good job.

What are you talking about? - course the market's OK! St Kilda East 239 Alma Road: Phillip Kingston: Bought for $1,500,000: 3 bidders (Photo Kate Agnoleto)

At 6pm on Saturday, the James Clearance Rate on the 31 auctions we covered was 58%.

Bidderman, our demand indicator of average bidders per auction, had a small rise to 1.6 bidders per auction, in part due to four volcanoes (strong auctions) including one 7 bidder auction in 28 Barrington St Kew.

These figures indicate that the market has now cooled – not frozen or falling apart, just cooled. That means we have moved into a buyers’ market, perhaps until Easter and possibly until Spring.

Well-priced homes are still selling. And there have been some surprising above-expectation results, such as 28 Barrington Kew (Glen Coutinho) which sold for $2,230,000 and, last week,Victor Road Kew (James Tostevin) at $4.1 million. But if the market doesn’t agree with initial pricing then it’s a slow, torturous journey to get a result. See our special Pass-Ins and Stales Report below.

This week we also look at the returns of serve on The Economist’s article as the ‘Experts’ hit back against the “Overpriced” headlines of last week.

This Weekend’s Market Summary:

This weekend in most places, except Boroondara, there was limited $M+ stock on offer at auction. The individual council clearance rates we report on in our market wraps could be distorted due to a) lack of auctions and b) lack of overall quality in those auctions. But this is not to imply a lack of stock in general – there are high levels of $M+ stock available across the board and Boroondara in particular is almost awash with homes on the market.

Looking specifically for a moment at Boroondara (Kew, Hawthorn, Canterbury and Camberwell), while this market may be a little out of kilter with the rest of Melbourne in terms of auction numbers, in the past few years it is a market that has shown the strongest resilience against negativity. It was affected by the GST for the shortest time, and has had the biggest price increases since. This weekend too it seemed to have a little oomph and we expect the clearance rate for Boorondara $M+ homes to be in the high 50s to low 60s.

But it does have a fight on its hands right now, with the main demand drivers (overseas buyers) reducing greatly in activity and supply to the market continuing to arrive week after week. Which means that buyers who can look beyond the headlines will find opportunities, and with the right strategies you should be in a position to push back a little against the seemingly never ending sellers’ market.

The next few weeks will be better in terms of auction quality in the top of the Top End in Boroondara. As long as those properties sell and the clearance rates stay stable, and if new stock reduces post Easter, we could move back to a balanced market. But if stock continues to come on in big numbers then the market will almost certainly remain cool with a significant change in demand sentiment.

Most of the $M+ homes on offer that sold this weekend were in the early $1 million range.

Bayside, Port Phillip, Stonnington have been quiet, with only a handful of sales in the post auction wash up from March 19th  and likewise at auction this weekend. In Port Phillip this is understandable as the Grand Prix completely extinguishes the market for almost a month. Why auction numbers are down in Brighton, Toorak and Malvern is not completely obvious – well not to us anyway. April 9th is shaping up as a Super Saturday of some sorts with almost 120 auctions in Boroondara and Stonnington combined. $M+ auctions in Bayside are still light on at the top of the Top End with mainly $1 million to $2 million homes on offer for the next few weeks leading into Easter. Most of the top of the Top End in Bayside is not going to auction.

Agent thoughts: Has the market changed since before the Labour Day weekend?
Chris Barrett, Marshall White, Hawthorn:“There have been a lot of people in the media talking about a negative change in the market since Labour day weekend, I however have found this to be unsubstantiated. As long as vendors prices are realistic and the property is presented well vendors can expect solid interest in their home.”
John Clarkson, Hocking Stuart, Brighton:“Good properties near local attractions and amenities, schools, shopping and the beach are still attracting a high level of enquiry.  Since Labour Day weekend the message is clear: If you are realistically priced you have a very good chance of selling . If you are above market perception, enquiry is reduced to a trickle.”  * For John’s full comments please see the Bayside weekly wrap.

James Special Report: Pass-Ins and Stales – The Autumn overhang build up.

We went back and re-examined all the auctions we reported on this year in 2011 and we revisited all the pass-ins, using still advertised on the net to determine their still for sale status. Please note that the table below is only connected with PASS-INS, not the homes we reported as bought before, at or just after auction on the day.

The table does make for interesting reading on the fate of a home that the market does not consider to be priced correctly at auction.

The table below shows Adjusted Clearance Rates comparing”On the Day” Clearance Rates with “On the Day plus Bought since”. Back in February 19 and 26 Pass-ins were taken up fairly quickly. However the most interesting stat is the lack of take up on Passed-in homes over the last two weeks of auctions: only 3 in 26.

• 1 of the 13 unsolds from the March 5th pass-ins and
• 2 of the 13 from the March 19th pass-ins.

This we feel confirms the view that the $M+ market started the year as balanced, but around Labour Day took a cooling direction.

What's happening Nick? Bentleigh 7 Eddys: Bought $1,312,500: 3 bidders. (Photo: David James)

James Big Issue: Agents claiming there are 100% Clearance rates in this market are just as misleading as saying the market is in freefall – both are far from the truth. Klarity Kris and Architect Adam cover it in the James Big Issue Video. Here is a summary of what they say.

• Still some surprising results. Two in particular, both in Boroondara, that stand out are Victor Avenue in Kew with James Tostevin – which sold for a hard to believe $4,100,000. Nic Franzman, Mark Dayman and Nic Ptak also from Marshall White’s result at 22 Stawell St Kew for $3,300,000. That was also a most surprising result
• We are hearing from agents 100% clearance rates – mainly due to agents feeling they need to respond to the Negativity of The Economist’s article and the Earthquakes, which for the moment have contributed to dampening demand.
• An interesting stat is that only 3 of the 26 homes we reported as passed in after auction in the last two weeks of auctions have since sold.
• We could say that 3 from 26 is reflective of the market strength – a far cry from the 100% Clearance Rate stats, BUT 3 from 26 while true, is also misrepresenting the market just as is reporting 100% clearance rates
• The market was in a balanced state pre Labour Day and as expected it is now going into a cooling phase until Easter due to increased stock levels and drop in demand intensity.

The message for buyers

• You have choice in the $3m+ range but there are still a few surprisingly strong results
• You will still have to compete relatively strongly if the home is good and well priced in that $1m to $1.5m range
• And the middle range say circle $2m to $2.5m is a bit of moving beast – the trend is not crystal clear to us at this stage.

Click on the JAMES BIG ISSUE video with Architect Adam and Klarity Kris in the middle of the home page

Media Monitor: Are Melbourne homes overpriced?

The case for being overpriced arose from The Economist’s article – which we reported on last week.  And now this week the case against those seemingly extreme overpriced by 56% headlines.

Rob Brooker head of economics from the NAB

1. Current events such as floods and Japan are affecting Melbourne short term, but long term our fundamentals are very strong.
2. Not suggesting prices are going to increase rapidly as affordability is hard pressed right now but we do have a shortage of housing stock.

His comments can be found in the excellent Kay and Burton report – sure it’s a selling tool but we listen to the expert commentary each time it’s on It’s well produced, they have credible experts and it’s relevant to our high end Melbourne market. Check it out, at least the expert comment stuff. The home fluff afterwards is up to you: http://www.kayburton.com.au/kayburtonreport

Paul Bloxham – HSBC’s chief economist for Australia and New Zealand, and a former RBA economist savages The Economist’s article stating “it’s too naive to be useful”. His main points in the Business Spectator are

1. We have an undersupply in inner city areas (totally agree with this comment)
2. Our stock is very high quality and has improved considerably over the last 20 years contributing to the increases in price paid (totally agree with this comment)
3. Very strong and improving economy (beyond our level of expertise but sounds good)

For the full article http://www.businessspectator.com.au/bs.nsf/Article/Australian-property-prices-housing-bubble-pd20110317-F24WP?OpenDocument&src=sph This was supplied by Al Craig of Jellis Craig – thank you.

‘Round the Grounds Headlines:
Boroondara- Some solid results but the trend is down under weight of stock numbers.
Bayside- Little movement on a lot of the recent Auction pass-ins
Stonnington- Small numbers of $M+ auctions today – although plenty of Top End non auction stock available
Port Phillip-With the Grand Prix – only 4 key $M+ auctions – 3 sold
More detailed analysis on our Weekly Local Council Market Wraps

Biggest Sales we can report:

• Templestowe, 9 Edwin: On the market since October of last year with Jeremy Tyrell of Fletchers. Has been bought for in excess of $4,700,000
• Richmond 37 Docker: Ken Griffith of Jellis Craig. Bought at auction, $3,300,000 – $3,500,000
• Hawthorn 23 Lisson Grove: Michael Lui of Marshall White. Bought after auction $3,600,000 – $3,800,000
• Toorak 17 Lansell, Lisa Jarrett of Abercrombys. On the market since December of last year

Biggest Sale we covered after auction: 44 Mary St Hawthorn, Antony Woodley of Marshall White. Above $2,700,000 (Undisclosed): Bought after auction, 1 bidder

Biggest Sale we covered under the hammer: 28 Barrington Ave, Kew, Glen Coutinho (Hocking Stuart), Under the hammer $2,230,000, 7 bidders (WOW)
“This Kew property did attract a crowd of 80 people, with quite a few potential buyers in the mix. The auctioneer, Glen Countinho, had to field bids from a whopping seven different bidders! Despite the light rain, the flow of the auction was quite amazing and reached the final amount of $2,230,000 before the hammer came down.” (Sonia Matmati)

Biggest Pass In: 68 Studley Park Rd, Kew, Passed in, $3,700,000
“A very pretty setting for an auction. Standing on an elevated embankment, auctioneer Richard Earle literally oversaw proceedings. He began by highlighting the virtues of this property with energy and detail. No bids came forth, however, so it was passed in for $3,700,000.”

Auction Video: This week i’ts down to Brighton with Klarity Kris at 22 Oakwood Ave, a Hocking Stuart auction with Peter Kennett. Click on the live action.

Please Note: we always ask permission to film and we always show respect at each auction. We also never video at an auction we are bidding at. If you are at an auction and don’t wish to be videoed, there are designated no-video zones. See our co-workers or ask the auctioneer.

Buyer Master Class: Klarity Kris discusses what’s necessary when buying a home when there are kids in the picture. Is it double storey single fronted or single storey double fronted!

Copyright: Mouldy Bread Picture from ChemistryWorldBlog.

We Only Buy Homes

SOUTH Yarra, 17 Acland St: The maestro, Gerald Delany (Kay & Burton) in action. Passed in, $3,250,000, no bidders.

Key Points:

• Toorak 17 Lansell with Lisa Jarrett of Abercrombys sold mid week after being on the market since late last year
• Toorak 16 Cole St with Nicole Gleeson of Kay and Burton sold mid week after being on the market since late last year

Agent Q & A: Has the market changed since before Labour Day weekend?
Lachlan Fraser-Smith, BenMac, Armadale:” The main change in the market since Labour Day is that the quality of buyers at open for inspections is very good, however the numbers of people through opens has slowed after a busier than anticipated start to the year. The reasons for this are: as the year settles down after a typical February spike in prices, people have found out at open for inspections and attending the early auctions what they wanted to know about prices and have assessed the market and either go to auction themselves or sit still and stay where they are. Numbers of properties on the market has increased as well but there are still some very active buyers out and about so they quality of buyers is certainly still there. We have been seeing some very strong results between $1 million and $2 million in Armadale and between $3 and $5 million in Malvern and Malvern East.  We will see a reduction in properties coming onto the market going into the traditional Easter, Anzac day and school holiday period. This will, I believe, underpin the market for the homes that come on post Easter in May.”
Iain Carmichael, BenMac, Armadale:“The Stonnington market in recent weeks has performed well given slightly diminished bidding activity at many auctions. Pleasing elements from a vendor’s point of view is that sales are being made and that clearance rates in Stonnington continue to exceed the Melbourne-wide figures by up to 10% each week end. The trend for buyers to hold off bidding is puzzling as the great majority of properties auctioned are still sold for solid prices at or immediately after auction.  Stock levels are reasonably full and the market will test both vendor expectations and buyer depth in the weeks leading up to Easter. It will be interesting to observe whether buyers will continue to run the gauntlet and back themselves into post-auction negotiations and, in some cases, private auctions or whether the true transparency of the auction system will give consumers sufficient comfort to bid with confidence and buy ‘under the hammer’ or become the highest bidder to gain an exclusive seat at the negotiating table.”
Andrew Hayne, Marshall White, Armadale:“No I don’t think things have changed too much. The market has been pretty price sensitive for a while now, so provided vendor’s expectations are in line with the market then there shouldn’t be any problems selling. I am a big believer in each property sets its own market so each one has to be treated on an individual basis rather than generalize about market conditions or sentiments.”

ARMADALE, 2 Avondale Rd: Warwick Anderson (RT Edgar), Passed in, $1,950,000 no bids.

TOORAK, 37 Lansell Rd: Andrew Macmillan (BenMac) passes in for $2,800,000, no bidders, but thanks the crowd for their participation with a wink or two.

Key Points:

• Off Markets, Forthcoming Auctions and Expressions of Interest are increasing as market stock levels begin to rise dramatically.
• Nobody bid at the 19 Kingston St Malvern East auction (Iain Carmichael) at $4,250,000 but 2 bidders emerged post auction and fought it out afterwards to a price well in excess of the reserve and well in excess of $4,600,000. Go figure!
• Armadale 1026 Malvern: James Redfern of Marshall White: Passed in $3,400,000 and bought afterwards. 1 bidder.
• 20 St Georges Toorak which has been on the quietly on the market for some time before a more public campaign this year has been bought for an undisclosed amount. The asking price estimate was $12,000,000 to $15,000,000 and it is believed to have been sold in the middle. Andrew Tolson of TBM was the selling agent.
• “Little brother” down the road at No 10 St Georges hasn’t sold at an already passed Expressions of Interest deadline – however it would be hats off if the agents got near their $10,000,000 ask, even if it is St Georges, considering the homes characteristics.
• 14 Bruce St Toorak late last month – and it has been bought for a reasonable margin over $3,000,000. Good result for an Expressions of Interest campaign and the man that sells a number of these very quietly – Marcus Chiminello.
• Overall a number of properties on the market at the $3m+ price level that have completed Private Sale or Expression of Interest campaigns with no result.

Agent Q & A:“What is your take on the Economist’s article that Australian house prices are overvalued by 56%?”
Justin Long, Marshall White, Armadale:” While I do not have a view on every sector of the Australian market, as for Melbourne I think the observation is complete nonsense and that by and large house prices for Melbourne seem to me to be reflective of people’s excellent earning capacity whilst still allowing, especially in outer suburbs, the opportunity for low income earners to get a foothold.”

More big crowds this week, such as this one at 27 Auburn Pde, Hawthorn East, which stopped traffic! Under the hammer, $1,360,000, Peter Batrouney (Jellis Craig), 4 bidders

At 6pm on Saturday the James $M+ Clearance Rate on the 32 auctions we covered dipped to 59%. For the second week in a row there were around 150 new $M+ listings in our main coverage area of Bayside and the Inner East. Buyers have firmly said to sellers – “if it ain’t priced right we ain’t bidding, because we can see plenty of other homes coming on”. This attitude was particularly evidenced by the ‘duck’ rate (auctions with no bids and no sale afterwards) which was almost 1 in 3 this weekend  – well up on last weekend.

However there were exceptions – such as in Stonnington at the top of the Top End where there was almost no stopping the market and it made its strongest statement of the year so far.

Where is the Market At?

Last week there were indications the early $million+ market could be warming up a bit. But a second strong week of listings has taken some heat out of the market.

The strongest “take notice of me” stat was this weekend’s Bidderman dropping back to 1.5 from a more healthy 2 last week. What that tells us is that buyers are seeing stock choices going forward and the urgency has dimmed on some homes.  If Bidderman continues like this to Easter, prices are unlikely to rise.

This weekend we did see price pressure on quality homes, with quite strong bidding at a number of auctions (including several $3m+ auctions) and five ‘volcanoes’ of 4+ bidders per auction.

What we’re saying is that this first market period, up to Labour Day, has started healthy and balanced. But the second market (up to Easter) is no longer a shoo-in positive for would be sellers.

For buyers, this two week stock surge presents an opportunity for good prices on some good homes that the market may miss – at least until Easter. But things can change quickly – while May last year saw oodles of stock coming onto the market, that may not happen again this year. Given we’ve got such a late Easter in 2011, we may already be seeing the stock surge we saw in May last year, which could mean we don’t get strong stock levels this May.

Crowd Numbers: Again we had big crowds at many auctions, indicating a strong level of interest in results. This weekend we reported one in three auctions with 80 or more people in attendance. All others had good numbers watching.

Our $M+ Supply Indicators:

New Stock: This has been the second huge week in a row for listings with around 150 $M+ homes newly listed for sale in the Inner East and Bayside areas that we cover. There were around 200 $M+ listings across Greater Melbourne.

Actual Numbers Sold: There are solid numbers of $M+ homes changing hands, which is in part why we are not yet buying into any  cries of  a “weak market”.
Agent Market Comments:
Gerald Delaney (Kay & Burton): “I can’t see anything wrong with the market at the moment. We have seen good interest on good properties. I definitely think the market is a healthy one.”
Justin Long (Marshall White): “I feel the market has a bit of upward pressure at the moment. The well priced properties are going beyond expectations and the overpriced or not so good can be very hard work.”

James Marketnews Big Issue:
A few Expressions of Interest and Forthcoming auctions are coming back – a possible sign the pre-Easter auction market is viewed as oversupplied. Watch the discussion on Market News TV.

‘Round the Grounds Snapshots
Boroondara -  Stock Surge in Boroondara – Clearance Rates are definitely not as good as we are used to, but nearly 40 homes at $M+ were bought this week
Bayside – Bayside still shining the brightest – more stock coming on pre Easter will re-test its underlying 2011 strength
Port Phillip – So-so weekend, but stock wasn’t that exciting. Wow on Howe – Big $6m+ sale.
Stonnington – Where the big action was this weekend.
Rest of Melbourne – Just not a lot of $m+ auction action happening so we held over this week’s report
More Detailed Analysis in our Weekly Local Council Market Wraps

$3M+ Markets:
New Homes: Definitely weaker than last year particularly in the Balwyn and North Balwyn heartland.
Period Homes: Solid interest continues
More News and Specific Results can be found in $3-Million-Plus Market articles on the home page

MALVERN, 66 Claremont Ave: Iain Carmichael (BenMac) led a cracker auction - on the market at $3,300,000 and selling under the hammer $3,700,000, 3 bidders

Biggest Sale: 19 Hamilton Rd, Malvern, Justin Long (Marshall White): Under the hammer $4,357,000
The auction opened on a bid of $3,820,000, was on the market at $4,250,000 and bought under the hammer for $4,357,000. There were two bidders and a crowd of around 150. A solid result for this 1930s reproduction home on 668sqm of land.

Biggest Pass-In: 279 Beaconsfield Parade, Middle Park, Gerald Betts (RT Edgar): passed in $4,250,000
“Auctioneer Gerald Betts opened with a vendor bid of $4,000,000 and closed with a vendor bid of $4,250,000 in front of 40 seemingly uninterested observers.” (Mal James)

Bidderbuzz Auction: 11 William St, Brighton, Rod Richardson (Hocking Stuart): Under the hammer $3,100,000, 5 bidders
“The epic 45 minute auction of 11 William Street had a mix of elements to entertain those spectators watching on – intensity, drama and tension with a few awkward silences thrown in.  In the end it was a battle of the property developers for this generous block of land, in the heart of bayside Brighton.  Auctioneer Rod Richardson showed composure in the face of heckling and the patience of a saint during this long auction, working tirelessly to achieve a solid result for the vendor from the opening bid of $2,710,000 to the winning end at $3,100,000.  All in all, it was an entertaining auction to witness!” (Nikki Hills)

Auction Video: This week Architect Adam heads to Hawthorn to witness James Tostevin and the Marshall White team auction 66 Manningtree Road. Click on the live action.

Please Note: we always ask permission to film and we always show respect at each auction. We also never video at an auction we are bidding at. If you are at an auction and don’t wish to be videoed, there are designated no-video zones. See our co-workers or ask the auctioneer.

Buyer Masterclass: A change of pace with Architect Adam telling us why we love Victorian homes – with plenty of facts and figures.

No Marketnews next week with Labour Day Long Weekend.

We Only Buy Homes

Hawthorn 35 Mason: Scott Patterson and Michael Armstrong: Bought for over $3,100,000: 4 bidders

Some interesting results to finish off the month:

• 6 Teringa Place Toorak with Andrew Macmillan and Andrew McCann of Benmac was bought Sunday for an undisclosed amount over $3,500,000. House was quite serviceable but it would have also been considered as a bulldozer job placing land just under $5000 per sq metre
• 

  49 Howe Crescent South Melbourne - bought in excess of $6,000,000. Expressions of Interest - Michael Coen Hocking Stuart

  And a very quick and smart result at 49 Howe Crescent South Melbourne with Michael Coen of Hocking Stuart – due to be sold through an Expressions of Interest Campaign completing 21st March it was snapped up within a few days of advertising on the 25th of February. The result was a strong one and is undisclosed but the  quoting was over $5,000,000 and we believe in sold for in excess of $6,000,000 to give you some perspective. We do a fair bit of work in the is Expression of Interest area and this again proves that those who wait until the stated deadline do not put themselves in the best position to buy.

• 

  290 Beach Beaumaris - Len Sharp Chisholm and Gamon - Full asking price of $2,950,000 after a previously failed selling campaign.

  Private Sale at 290 Beach Road Black Rock with Len Sharp of Chisholm and Gamon for full asking price of $2,950,000. This again supports our comments that 1) Bayside and 2) New and 3) $3m (almost) price tag are a combination that is getting some runs on the board in the late Summer of 2011.

• Caulfield 20 Langdon Road – Rochelle Butt and Rodney Morley of TBM got away 1500 sqm of land plus home in Caulfield North for an amount believed to be in excess of $4,000,000. Showing that Caulfield’s prices can be Canterbury prices when the right package is sought after.

Week Ending February 26th: If last week was the season opener for the $1m+ auction market, then  this  week  was the beginning of the $3m+ auction market and the main  focus for this weekend’s report. We don’t have all this weekend’s numbers in yet, so it’s hard to call, but it seems that this upper  market cleared at 44% of the properties under the hammer. We at  James accept a slightly lower auction clearance rate on the day in this segment as indicating balanced, warm or even hot  markets, because the air is generally thinner at this level due to the lower number of bidders available at this price point, and because the pre and post auction argy-bargy is  generally greater. Today there were quite a few $3m+ homes on offer. We  think this market segment is underwhelming at present – however if it is the right price, the right property and the right position it is still being well  received and taken up.

A few of the biggies that were bought

• Armadale 23 Wattletree Road – Justin Long – 3 bidders – $3,300,000
• Hawthorn 46 Illawarra – Mark Dayman – Bought Before – $4,250,000
• Brighton 33 Middle Crescent – Jason Swift – 3 bidders – $4,300,000
• Malvern East 8 Westgarth – Andrew Macmillan – 2 bidders – Post Auction Buy a smidge under $3,000,000
• Hawthorn 45 Mason – Scott Patterson – 4 bidders – Under  the Hammer over $3,100,000
• Malvern East 118 Finch – Bought for $3,150,000
• Kew 4 Madden – Peter Batrouney – Bought After – 1 bidder – $3,050,000
• East Melbourne – John Bongiorno – 3 bidders – $3,000,000

Some of the biggies that missed the mark

• Balwyn North 15 Stephens  – 2 bidders – Passed In for $3,650,000
• Balwyn North 59 Hosken – Passed In for $4,050,000
• Toorak 44 Verdant – Passed In for $3,750,000
• Hawthorn 23 Lisson – Passed In for $3,600,000
• Toorak 231 Kooyong – Passed In for $3,500,000
• Malvern East 50 Finch  - 1 Bidder – Passed In $4,100,000

St Kilda West 49 Mary: Passed In $4,000,000 - 0 Bidders: Andrew Stuart was not in the mood for mucking around – he had an uphill battle and he knew it. An opening vendor bid of $4,000,000 immediately hushed the vibrant crowd of 120 and that was it. Game over – a half time break for show but the gate was shut. A duck for this auction. Photos by Phoebe James

Week Ending February 19th: This market is either poor or, what is more reasonable to assume, still on holidays. Mike Gibson of Kay and Burton says that most high end sellers, as advised, are waiting. Hence the quality currently on the market is average. He expects good stock at this level to come on post Labour Day and before Easter.

To support our claims that the $3m+ market hasn’t really got going yet, look at this weekend’s Pass–Ins of $3m+ properties  –

St Kilda West – Mary St – $4,000,000 –  0 Bidders
James Auction Report: See Report Above

Camberwell – Canterbury Road – $3,801,000 – 1 Bidder
James Auction Report: An air of expectation at another James Tostevin Boroondara tennis court auction. He has almost singlehandedly made them his own over the last 2 years or thereabouts. His focus has been 20000 sq ft tennis court at $6m plus. A huge crowd, around 200 with kids trampolining, people milling and cars driving by. Everybody seems to know at least one person to give a wink or a nod to. Carnival atmosphere. Then the business started – well this time it didn’t. One auctioneer bid at $3,800,000 and then surprisingly one crowd bid for $1,000 more. Small Argument – settled with pass-in to the bidder on his $1,000 bid. Inside to do battle and last check they were still banging heads. We await the result.

"You are all very naughty schoolkids and I'm going to keep you back here somebody bids." Well no, James Tostevin didn't say that but he may have been thinking this on Saturday. Camberwell 31 Canterbury: Passed In $3,801,000: 1 bidder:

Balwyn – 12 Creswick – $3,425,000 – 3 Bidders
James Auction Report: A genuine bid of $2,000,000 opened proceedings. Auctioneer Maurice Di Marzio politely accepted the bid, suggesting it was closer to land value than a sale price, before offering a vendor bid of $3,200,000. More than 150 people watched Mr Di Marzio field bids from another two bidders before passing the property in at $3,425,000. Both interested parties headed inside after the auction for further discussions.

Albert Park – 139 Beaconsfield – $3,250,000 — 0 Bidders
James Auction Report: Auctioneer David Wood from Hocking Stuart was seriously up against the elements today as he tried to make himself heard against the traffic noise and the wind coming off Port Phillip Bay. The preamble was short and to the point, before he asked for bids. No one was prepared to open the bidding and he immediately entered a vendor bid of $3,250,000. Still no response, so half time was called. After the think music was up, the question was asked again and still no bids. The property was passed in on the vendor bid.

Gowan Stubbings of Kay and Burton successful at 29 Scott Grove Glen Iris

Kooyong – 711 Toorak – $3,190,000

In fact the only auction sale over $3,000,000 we covered was 29 Scott Grove Glen Iris (Gowan Stubbings of Kay and Burton) for $3,032,000 – 3 Bidders.
James Auction Report: A triangular battle developed right from the word go, and auctioneer Gowan Stubbings orchestrated the bidding superbly to maintain momentum throughout. Only when the $3,000,000 mark was eclipsed, did one of the bidders drop out. $32,000 later and the property was secured. Good naturedly, the two bidders shook hands to acknowledge the end of the contest. A riveting event.

However a few strong private and off-market sales show this market is not completely morbid. There is still some pulse. There were three very solid such sales in Bayside this week:

Brighton Golden Mile: Scene of 2 big sales over $10,000 per sq metre in February 2011

Shandford Avenue – Nick Johnstone of JP Dixon – $7.3m for 600sqm approx – which translates to $10,000 sqm for Golden Mile beachfront

Chatsworth Avenue – Stewart Lopez of Kay and Burton – $11m+ for 1100 sqm approx – again, $10,000 sqm for Golden Mile beachfront

Kerferd Road – Andrew Stuart of Hocking Stuart – $4.9m off market – 440 sqm approx

Continuing with February Sales:

While we have seen no sales over $3m reported in Boroondara and only the long suffering and difficult to see what you can do with it 13 Como Sth Yarra finally sold (Jeremy Fox of RT Edgar) we have seen a reasonable amount of mopping up action in Brighton – a sort of summer clean out.

New and old Brightonians like to buy New in Brighton

1 Inner Crescent Brighton with Justin Follett of Kay and Burton for an undisclosed amount – proved difficult to move and while it was an impressive residence it must have been price that proved the sticking point. Having said that line it up against a number of apartments and I thought the final result was fair value.

This type of offering sold well over Summer

2 William St Brighton – cnr St Andrews –scene of the all the helicopter noise in recent weeks saw a similar offering to 1 Inner Crescent also sell –reportedly through Kay and Burton.

2a Mulgoa also with Kay and Burton and a similar offering got a lot of it’s 50% better price basically because of its golden mile location.

Another good result  in the Golden Mile this time for the dynamic duo Regina Schmidt and Brian Devlin saw another of the Glyndon apartments (no 4) bought for $3,200,000 which continues to emphasize the demand for “retiree” offerings and it shows the selling appeal for Friedrich designs.

The Buxton duo again  – 1/188 The Esplanade with waterfront views but unlike the Golden Mile also some traffic noise – bought for $3,500,000.

And finally also Buxton in Brighton – David Hart got away a very popular 62 Dendy when we  went through it (but for us main road, south facing , tight block) for a smidge under $2,950,000. And increase of just over 28% from the depths of the GFC,  2 years ago.