Hawthorn 35 Mason: Scott Patterson and Michael Armstrong: Bought for over $3,100,000: 4 bidders

Week Ending February 26th: If last week was the season opener for the $1m+ auction market, then this week was the beginning of the $3m+ auction market and the main focus for this weekend’s report. We don’t have all this weekend’s numbers in yet, so it’s hard to call, but it seems that this upper market cleared at 44% of the properties under the hammer. We at James accept a slightly lower auction clearance rate on the day in this segment as indicating balanced, warm or even hot markets, because the air is generally thinner at this level due to the lower number of bidders available at this price point, and because the pre and post auction argy-bargy is generally greater. Today there were quite a few $3m+ homes on offer. We think this market segment is underwhelming at present – however if it is the right price, the right property and the right position it is still being well received and taken up.

A few of the biggies that were bought

• Armadale 23 Wattletree Road – Justin Long – 3 bidders – $3,300,000
• Hawthorn 46 Illawarra – Mark Dayman – Bought Before – $4,250,000
• Brighton 33 Middle Crescent – Jason Swift – 3 bidders – $4,300,000
• Malvern East 8 Westgarth – Andrew Macmillan – 2 bidders – Post Auction Buy a smidge under $3,000,000
• Hawthorn 45 Mason – Scott Patterson – 4 bidders – Under  the Hammer over $3,100,000
• Malvern East 118 Finch – Bought for $3,150,000
• Kew 4 Madden – Peter Batrouney – Bought After – 1 bidder – $3,050,000
• East Melbourne – John Bongiorno – 3 bidders – $3,000,000

Some of the biggies that missed the mark

• Balwyn North 15 Stephens  – 2 bidders – Passed In for $3,650,000
• Balwyn North 59 Hosken – Passed In for $4,050,000
• Toorak 44 Verdant – Passed In for $3,750,000
• Hawthorn 23 Lisson – Passed In for $3,600,000
• Toorak 231 Kooyong – Passed In for $3,500,000
• Malvern East 50 Finch  - 1 Bidder – Passed In $4,100,000

St Kilda West 49 Mary: Passed In $4,000,000 - 0 Bidders: Andrew Stuart was not in the mood for mucking around – he had an uphill battle and he knew it. An opening vendor bid of $4,000,000 immediately hushed the vibrant crowd of 120 and that was it. Game over – a half time break for show but the gate was shut. A duck for this auction. Photos by Phoebe James

Week Ending February 19th: This market is either poor or, what is more reasonable to assume, still on holidays. Mike Gibson of Kay and Burton says that most high end sellers, as advised, are waiting. Hence the quality currently on the market is average. He expects good stock at this level to come on post Labour Day and before Easter.

To support our claims that the $3m+ market hasn’t really got going yet, look at this weekend’s Pass–Ins of $3m+ properties  –

St Kilda West – Mary St – $4,000,000 –  0 Bidders
James Auction Report: See Report Above

Camberwell – Canterbury Road – $3,801,000 – 1 Bidder
James Auction Report: An air of expectation at another James Tostevin Boroondara tennis court auction. He has almost singlehandedly made them his own over the last 2 years or thereabouts. His focus has been 20000 sq ft tennis court at $6m plus. A huge crowd, around 200 with kids trampolining, people milling and cars driving by. Everybody seems to know at least one person to give a wink or a nod to. Carnival atmosphere. Then the business started – well this time it didn’t. One auctioneer bid at $3,800,000 and then surprisingly one crowd bid for $1,000 more. Small Argument – settled with pass-in to the bidder on his $1,000 bid. Inside to do battle and last check they were still banging heads. We await the result.

"You are all very naughty schoolkids and I'm going to keep you back here somebody bids." Well no, James Tostevin didn't say that but he may have been thinking this on Saturday. Camberwell 31 Canterbury: Passed In $3,801,000: 1 bidder:

Balwyn – 12 Creswick – $3,425,000 – 3 Bidders
James Auction Report: A genuine bid of $2,000,000 opened proceedings. Auctioneer Maurice Di Marzio politely accepted the bid, suggesting it was closer to land value than a sale price, before offering a vendor bid of $3,200,000. More than 150 people watched Mr Di Marzio field bids from another two bidders before passing the property in at $3,425,000. Both interested parties headed inside after the auction for further discussions.

Albert Park – 139 Beaconsfield – $3,250,000 — 0 Bidders
James Auction Report: Auctioneer David Wood from Hocking Stuart was seriously up against the elements today as he tried to make himself heard against the traffic noise and the wind coming off Port Phillip Bay. The preamble was short and to the point, before he asked for bids. No one was prepared to open the bidding and he immediately entered a vendor bid of $3,250,000. Still no response, so half time was called. After the think music was up, the question was asked again and still no bids. The property was passed in on the vendor bid.

Gowan Stubbings of Kay and Burton successful at 29 Scott Grove Glen Iris

Kooyong – 711 Toorak – $3,190,000

In fact the only auction sale over $3,000,000 we covered was 29 Scott Grove Glen Iris (Gowan Stubbings of Kay and Burton) for $3,032,000 – 3 Bidders.
James Auction Report: A triangular battle developed right from the word go, and auctioneer Gowan Stubbings orchestrated the bidding superbly to maintain momentum throughout. Only when the $3,000,000 mark was eclipsed, did one of the bidders drop out. $32,000 later and the property was secured. Good naturedly, the two bidders shook hands to acknowledge the end of the contest. A riveting event.

However a few strong private and off-market sales show this market is not completely morbid. There is still some pulse. There were three very solid such sales in Bayside this week:

Brighton Golden Mile: Scene of 2 big sales over $10,000 per sq metre in February 2011

Shandford Avenue – Nick Johnstone of JP Dixon – $7.3m for 600sqm approx – which translates to $10,000 sqm for Golden Mile beachfront

Chatsworth Avenue – Stewart Lopez of Kay and Burton – $11m+ for 1100 sqm approx – again, $10,000 sqm for Golden Mile beachfront

Kerferd Road – Andrew Stuart of Hocking Stuart – $4.9m off market – 440 sqm approx

Continuing with February Sales:

While we have seen no sales over $3m reported in Boroondara and only the long suffering and difficult to see what you can do with it 13 Como Sth Yarra finally sold (Jeremy Fox of RT Edgar) we have seen a reasonable amount of mopping up action in Brighton – a sort of summer clean out.

New and old Brightonians like to buy New in Brighton

1 Inner Crescent Brighton with Justin Follett of Kay and Burton for an undisclosed amount – proved difficult to move and while it was an impressive residence it must have been price that proved the sticking point. Having said that line it up against a number of apartments and I thought the final result was fair value.

This type of offering sold well over Summer

2 William St Brighton – cnr St Andrews –scene of the all the helicopter noise in recent weeks saw a similar offering to 1 Inner Crescent also sell –reportedly through Kay and Burton.

2a Mulgoa also with Kay and Burton and a similar offering got a lot of it’s 50% better price basically because of its golden mile location.

Another good result  in the Golden Mile this time for the dynamic duo Regina Schmidt and Brian Devlin saw another of the Glyndon apartments (no 4) bought for $3,200,000 which continues to emphasize the demand for “retiree” offerings and it shows the selling appeal for Friedrich designs.

The Buxton duo again  – 1/188 The Esplanade with waterfront views but unlike the Golden Mile also some traffic noise – bought for $3,500,000.

And finally also Buxton in Brighton – David Hart got away a very popular 62 Dendy when we  went through it (but for us main road, south facing , tight block) for a smidge under $2,950,000. And increase of just over 28% from the depths of the GFC,  2 years ago.

ALBERT PARK, 139 Beaconsfield Pde: David Wood (Hocking Stuart) rubs his hands together in anticipation, but it was a quiet day at on Beaconsfield Pde. Passed in, $3,250,000, no bidders

Key Points:

• The two big ones over $3m didn’t get a bid – Mary St and Beaconsfield Pde, and the $2m Mary St only had one bidder
• Off Market – Andrew Stuart gets a big one away in Kerferd Rd for $4,900,000

Agent Q & A: How have you found non-auction sales so far this year?
Matt Young, Buxton, St Kilda:“Sales in general, be it non-auction or via auction, have been far more difficult than throughout 2010.  In short, the basics don’t change.  You need to closely match the potential buyers requirements with the right home.  In a softening market this is a far more difficult prospect, buyers requirements aren’t as easily flexed as they have the luxury of choice.  In an upswinging market the opposite is in effect, many potential buyers simply don’t have the choice and are restricted to what they can afford to buy rather than meeting their ideal requirements. With regards to non-auction sales specifically, it’s a common misconception that the auction process is less successful in a soft market.  Vendors may be concerned their home may not sell on the day, they hear many negative reports about auction clearance rates falling and fear what may happen to them.  On the contrary though, non-auction sales avoid much of this negativity due to their being no specific reporting measures available of their success rate.  In actual fact, I would suggest to most that the failure to sell ratio would be far higher through non-auction sales than via auction. Understanding your market place, knowing your buyers and having world class buyer management strategies are all now more important than ever before.  Failure to do this is quite literally guaranteeing a negative outcome for your vendors.   It’s been a terrific start to 2011.  So far this year, we have found the market to have returned earlier than usual as the volume of properties available is higher than normal presenting many potential buyers with great opportunities.”

THE LEOPARD: Auctioneer Jason Scillio watching, thinking, testing, watching. 1 Stawell Kew bought afterwards for an undisclosed amount. 2 bidders.

At 6pm on Saturday the final James $M+ Clearance rate for the year on the 35 auctions we covered was 69%. You may be interested to remember that back in our first Marketnews report for 2010 it was 83%. Those figures point to the year that was.

Bidderman, our demand indicator, was a strong 2.1 bidders per auction – which only confirms what those in the market know: we have had a bounce and that while the hot market has continued to cool, it has not lost all its warmth on the good homes. Our first market news in February 2010 had Bidderman at 3.0.

This Weekend’s Market:
This weekend the market continued its bounce which began two weeks ago. Bidders were there to meet those sellers who chose to meet the market. They were even prepared to fight a little harder than they were in October. Maybe it’s the need for buyers to be in a home by Christmas or maybe it’s the need for sellers to have money in the bank at Santa time – or probably a bit of both, which is normal for this time of the year. The market was in a bit of trouble a few weeks ago following Super Saturday and something had to give. And something has: sellers have given. Which is why the market has bounced in the last fortnight and is looking healthier. Sellers are now pricing their homes to meet the market. They are listening to their selling agents and they are getting the job done. In return buyers are responding, especially when a good home is placed on the market at a reasonable price. Yes, that reasonable price is 5% below September’s reasonable price and maybe 10% below April’s. But it’s still about the same as this time last year and that is how the market works. It goes up and it goes down and it does that every week on every type of property in every type of market. It’s just the median price stats and some media commentators which encourage the uninitiated to think property is a slow moving beast. It’s not. Footnote: over the long term the property market goes up more than it goes down.

Meet the market – what does that mean?
While our focus is homes over $1 million, many of our purchases are over $2 and $3 million. We also have an investment division – headed up by Valuer David McMillan. This weekend we witnessed a great example of a product that met the market and one that didn’t. They were a kilometre apart and finished around the same price – circa $850,000. Both had competent agents managing their campaigns, both have 2 bedrooms.

• Home 1: 1/45 Thanet Street Malvern with Tim Bennison, had 7 bidders and sold for $880,750.
• Home 2: 102 Sutherland Road Armadale, had no bidders and passed in on a lone vendor bid at $850,000.

The market embraced one home and completely rejected the other.

What to do now?
With basically one weekend of auctions left and two weeks of private sales and off-markets, you basically have around ten more sleeps to find what you want – or sit back, relax and wait till just after Australia Day 2011 for a burst of new stock (hopefully).

Try and make good decisions not emotional ones. If you have to rent then so be it, it’s better to rent than buy badly. But good decisions also involve reading the market and it has stepped up a bit so we do not recommend being too cute on price. Sure, don’t overpay, but don’t be too cute either.

We have bought eight homes in the past eight days – five of them outside the auction hammer. Highlights include the purchase of Munro St Armadale post auction, Kyarra Street Sandringham off-market, and Avenue Road Camberwell before auction. As well we have had solid new enquiry. So internally and externally we are seeing market indicators that point to a bounce. As we at Marketnews leave you for the year we think the market could well be in a healthier and more sustainable shape than it was when we first reported to you in 2010, just 10 short months ago. Let’s hope that is good news for 2011.

Auction in a Garden: Tim Derham, a rose amongst the thorns, passes in to the third bidder for $2,970,000, 4 Mathoura Toorak.

$3m+ market

While the highlights point to a number of successes in the $3m+ market there have also been a number of pass-ins. Which suggests that this market too is cooling or cooled and now seems balanced and healthy and this week has a bit of pep again.

This Weekend’s Highlights:

• Brighton 4/23 St Ninians, Stewart Lopez  Bought at auction for $4,825,000
• Balwyn 32 Stephens, Maurice Di Marzio, Bought under the hammer for $3,800,000 – 4 bidders
• Armadale 17 Denbigh, Justin Long, Bought under the hammer for $3,890,000 – 4 bidders
• Balwyn 12 Knutsford, Tim Derham, Bought under the hammer for $3,520,000 – 4 bidders
• Kew 1 Stawell, Gowan Stubbings, undisclosed Bought after – 2 bidders
• Kew 3-5 Rimington, Scott Patterson, Bought After above $3,650,000 -  2 bidders
• Malvern 376 Glenferrie, Iain Carmichael of Benmac passed in $4,300,000 and bought after $4,415,000 – 0 bidders

Off Market

• Hawthorn 26 Fordholm, Michael Armstrong, Over $5,000,000

Not so Highlights:

• Canterbury 34 Maling, passed in $4,600,000
• Brighton 29 Sussex (this seems to be for sale each year), passed in for $3,350,000 – 0 bidders
• Middle Park 280 Beaconsfield, passed in $4,400,000 – 0 bidders
• Toorak 83 Clendon, passed in – 0 bidders

*For more $3m+ results please go to our weekly updated $3m+ section

Bidderbuzz Auction: 43 Motherwell St, South Yarra, Joseph Allan (Chisholm & Gamon); Bought under the hammer, $1,860,000, 7 bidders
“As I rocked up you could feel a number of people had come to play – and play they did under Joseph Allan’s direction. On the market at $1,400,000. 7 bidders, all with a variety of techniques and wallet sizes provided some sparkling entertainment until there was only one left at $1,860,000. This home needed some serious work. Sorry – did I hear somebody say the market was gone?” (Mal James)

Biggest Sale: 17 Denbigh Rd, Armadale, Justin Long (Marshall White); Bought under the hammer, $3,890,000, 4 bidders
“On a magnificent day in Melbourne, auctioneer Justin Long left it to the energetic crowd for a starting bid. Within a few seconds an opening bid was made from a gentleman in the crowd for $3,300,000, which was quickly followed by a bid $25,000 higher. With four separate parties vying for the Armadale home, the price flew past $3,500,000, then $3,600,000, then $3,700,000, and finally slowed at $3,850,000. Mr. Long extracted the maximum from the bidding parties, managing to squeeze out a final bid of $3,890,000 from one very interested gentleman, and the property was sold at that price. All in all, a very well conducted auction with 80 or so people in attendance, and all participating parties walking away very satisfied.” (Daniel Ehrenreich)

Biggest Pass In:280 Beaconsfield Pde, Middle Park, Andrew Stuart (Hocking Stuart); $4,400,000; no bidders
“A large crowd of 80 sought refuge from the hot sun under the shade of the trees scattered on the nature strip.  In his preamble, auctioneer Andrew Stuart spoke enthusiastically about the property, the ‘outstanding lifestyle’ and it being in ‘Melbourne’s greatest location’.  Mr Stuart looked to the group for an opening bid, but all remained silent, so he opened with a vendor bid of $4,400,000.  Despite Mr Stuart’s best efforts there was no bidding on the day and the property was passed in at $4,400,000.” (Kate Agnoleto)

Market News TV
This week’s video auctions are at 25 Bateman St, Hampton with James Paynter (Hodges) and 19 Ferrars Place, South Melbourne with David Wood (Hocking Stuart). This week Gina, whom many of you would know as she co-ordinates all our new clients, and Jen, our Market News Co-ordinator, step in for Klarity Kris and Adam the Architect – click on the live action this Sunday.

*Please note: We always ask permission to film and we always show respect at each auction. We also never video at an auction we are bidding at. If you are at an auction and don’t wish to be filmed, there are designated no-video zones. See our co-workers or ask the auctioneer.

June 2010: Our favourite Pic for 2010: Susan McGlashan (right) of Bennison Mackinnon leads some very happy buyers inside for the sign up of 2/9 Shipley South Yarra. Bought under the hammer $2,195,000. 2 bidders. Strong.

Summary of 2010

Early 2010 started where 2009 left off, with sellers successfully getting buyers to accept their courageous asking prices, and buyers only too happy to hop on board the train, no matter the price.

Why was that?  After the 2008 Global Financial Crisis many buyers had feared further falls. Instead, by the end of 2009 the market had recovered what it lost in the GFC – and then some. And it seems buyers who missed out in 2009 were putting their hands up at auction with a sense of urgency and even panic, determined to get on the train this year.

For sellers this meant champagne and truffles, a situation that continued until Anzac Day when the market turned sharply downwards. It seems that both buyers and sellers realised that while the property market was booming, the economy – and especially the world economy – wasn’t. The Greek economy was in collapse, the Dow Jones went into a slide, and here interest rates started rising. Sellers decided it was time to rush their home onto the market to make hay while the sun still shone. But buyers were already taking a more guarded approach and were no longer prepared to pay big prices.

Properties were increasingly being passed in, adding to an already substantial overhang of stale unsolds. Where previously the market had been feeding on buyer panic, now it began to slip down on buyer apathy. The market increases of November 2009 to April 2010 were wiped off within a fortnight or so, cutting prices by around 10%.

April 2010: Strange. Very strange. Yes Glen we can see you, but check out the guy to the right. I'm not sure if he was there for marketing or to revive injured buyers. Maybe he will be mandatory at all auctions soon. Camberwell: 52 Athelstan Road: Glen Coutinho. Passed In.

A chilly winter saw a shortage of good quality homes, with only those selling who had to. And even when a good home arrived on the market, it had to compete with a growing overhang of stales (unsolds) that had been building up since May.  But people still need to buy homes, and the shortage now fueled buyer demand, which led to a bounce in early spring. It was surprising  because there were distractions – the August federal election and subsequent postulations and the footy and Collingwood’s replay victory (got it in) The first days of Spring brought out the instinctual buyers who need to move nests as the sun warms their hearts.  The sun also loosened their wallets, creating a small fillip on quality stock. But it only lasted the month.

And it wasn’t strong enough to absorb the surge of 200+ $ million plus properties going to market on October 23rd’s Super Saturday. In the weeks following, rather than risk passing-in their property to the unsolds list where they might wait weeks for a buyer, vendors initially tried to hold their prices. However, after a few weeks of denial and a Melbourne Cup interest rate jolt they finally began to revise their prices downwards. By end November clearance rates were back at a healthy, if unspectacular 65%.

And so we end 2010 almost where we started in terms of price, but vastly different in terms of what we expect for the start of next season. The heat of last summer is over, but it is still warm in parts. (Inner city quality homes are particularly still in high demand). Overall it’s a more healthy balanced market. For now. Stay tuned for next year.

2010 Awards
Most of our year-end efforts have gone into our 2010 yearbook due out before Christmas (downloadable from this site). Our legend section and their pearls of wisdom are contained within this 2010 marketnews yearbook. The two inductees into the Marketnews Legends Hall of Fame are Alastair Craig and Rodney Morley. However as this is our last 2010 marketnews it is customary to put up our 2010 awards. Consider them like Mike Sheahan’s footy awards – a bit of fun.

Auctioneers: we chose who we chose because we saw these auctioneers consistently quote sensibly (well 6 of 7 anyway), give buyers and sellers a fair go at auction, provide great entertainment and handle the sticky situations well. Other three hat auctioneers were Marshall White’s John Bongiorno, Andrew Hayne and Justin Long, Kay and Burton’s “Hollywoods” Jason Scillio and Gowan Stubbings, RT Edgar’s Jeremy Fox and Abercromby’s Tim Derham, all of whom we really enjoyed watching under pressure, who are brilliant at their job, but had a number of quote malfunctions – a Stonnington malaise for much of the year. Jeremy Desmier and Tim Heavyside are ones to watch and if Fletchers could be less conservative in their high-end auction quotes they would be right up there. Phillip Kingston mainly works the day we like to take off but when we see him we like what we see. We think Mark Earle and Craig Williamson of Buxton, Glen Coutinho, Peter Kennett, Andrew Stuart, Andrew James and Nick Renna of Hocking Stuart, Rodney Morley of TBM, David Oster, Damien Davis, Peter Batrouney and Richard Earle of Jellis Craig, Lachie Fraser-Smith of Benmac and Tom McCarthy of Biggin and Scott all put in two/three hat performances during the year.

Agents: These are the standouts for us – agents who are particularly strong in their market segment. Off market we think Marcus Chiminello from Marshall White is the one to watch.

Young agents: we dropped this segment because they are getting older.

Agency: Jellis Craig was a unanimous choice. Their comparable sales system, their attitude to buyers and general respect for all parties meant for us in 2010 they were our agency of the year.

Each year it’s a different format and each year we offend everybody we leave out – so please try not to take it too seriously.

click on to enlarge

click on to enlarge

click on to enlarge

click on to enlarge

Thank yous
I would like to thank my fellow co-workers Adam the Architect, Klarity Kris, Value Dave, Cafe Guy and earlier in the year Ralph and Stephen and our market news co-ordinators Jen, Julia, Sim and Peter. A big thank you to our editors Karin and Melinda, organizer Gina and Michael our MD. You’re a champ Michael.  Thank you to our behind the scenes people in Peter, Dan, Julie, Jason and Naomi and our Board; Peter, Adam, David and Chrisso. Thank you to Phil for your insights as well.

I also would like to thank all the selling agents who despite being on the “other side” allow access to almost all results and auctions, assist with quotes and smooth over ruffled buyer and seller feathers which occasionally happen. There are a few agents who are extra helpful friends of Marketnews and our advocacy business. In no particular order Mike Gibson of Kay and Burton; Rob Vickers-Willis of Abercrombys; Mark “Lama” Dayman, James Tostevin and John Bongiorno of Marshall White; Iain Carmichael, Kaine Lanyon and Elliot Gill of Benmac; David Oster, the Richard(s) James, Winneke and Earle of Jellis Craig; Tom Roberts of Nelson Alexander; Ladies in Red – Jenny Dwyer and Barb Gregory and Andrew Stuart of Hocking Stuart and Geoff Cayzer – thank you. Thank you to the agents at Marshall White who let us join some of their open training sessions – it is most appreciated. There are others and I apologise for leaving you out. Three agents who have helped us a great deal and whom we would like to single out are G-E-R-A-L-D Delany of Kay and Burton, James Connell of Marshall White and Scott “Pretty Boy” Patterson of Jellis Craig. An extra big thank you.

Thanks to our trusty reporters and photographers who come rain, hail or shine are out there in their jackets – ducking and weaving, listening and recording. Thank you to Amy, Daniel, David, Doug, Sue, Kate, Tom, Linda, Nikki, Dustin and Joshua – see you all for a great lunch in a week or so and well done.

We also wish our competitors at Morrell and Koren seasons greetings – enjoyed the battle.

Thanks to our readers and the people who come up at opens and auctions and say G’day.

Finally a big thank you to all our clients who have supported us during the year.

Have a safe and happy Christmas holidays period.

Until next year then (our office closes on December 17th and re-opens Monday January 17th)

Albert Park, 22 Madden St, Andrew Stuart (Hocking Stuart); Passed in $1,700,000, no bidders

Price Check: 384-386 Barkly St Elwood (Robert Marden of RT Edgar)  555 square metres of land at $3,400 per sqm. No price drop there since May where we had a flurry of $3,000 to $3,300 per sqm land sales. This was main road land and may have multi-development opportunities.

Agent Q & A: Matthew Young, Buxton, St Kilda:
In terms of real estate, what has happened this year and what do you expect to happen next year?
“In general terms, many would suggest that we have seen the property market turn full circle this year.  When we reflect back to the first quarter the market was still brimming with confidence.  There was a shortage of quality properties, an overwhelming volume of eager buyers, numerous record prices being achieved and auction clearance rates sitting above the 80% threshold regularly. Today, just past the half way mark of the last quarter, the volume of properties on the market is  high and the number of buyers remain strong. However, they are now somewhat more hesitant, are aware that the supply of properties is in their favour, and understand that they have the luxury of choice, even enjoying seeing Auction clearance rates fall to around 60%. They are factoring in not simply that latest interest rate rise but also the much expected rise by the RBA in February. As for 2011, we can only speculate.  I’m not personally one to look at life with a half empty approach, for the real estate market has been incredibly generous to us in recent years.  With further interest rate rises on the cards, should the market correct itself further, we need not worry as it has proven time and time again that it will not only bounce back but be stronger when it does. In short, we have moved from a sellers’ market to one that now slightly leans towards a buyers’ market. In saying that, my suggestion remains that there will never be a better time than yesterday to buy property for the simple fact that we can never accurately pick the bottom of the market until it’s on the way back up. By then people often find it’s too late and they have missed the boat.  Property is, has and will continue to be a proven wealth creation strategy, with properties on average doubling every 7 to 10 years!”

Kaine Lanyon, BenMac, Albert Park:”The real estate market started this year much the same as it ended in 2009, absolutely firing on all cylinders. Prices were still moving faster than anyone could fathom. That lasted until circa early April / Easter time when the signs of easing started to appear. The next few months saw prices come off circa 5%, in my view. After this period, the market seemed to find its new level which was one of more normality and back to being, some might say, more of a fair and balanced market across the board. We generally found that the best properties were still selling under competition, with two or three parties vying for the property. Most other properties appeared to be a little hit and miss depending on where the vendors expectations were, in that a sale was transacting if the clients were prepared to listen to the new market level. If not, some properties were left sitting on the market until both parties realigned and accepted that prices had come back from where they had been. This is still the status quo. Next year I believe will deliver a new fresh market after the usual festive break and one that should be fairly well balanced and pretty even across the board with exceptional quality properties still being in high demand.”

Elwood, 45 Dickens, Jason Scillio (Kay & Burton): The biggest auction we attended in Port Phillip on Saturday. Bought under the Hammer, $3,535,000, 3 bidders and a big crowd of 80.

Key Point

• There were three bidders at both hammer auctions and none at the two pass ins.

Biggest Sale: Elwood 45 Dickens St:  Jason Scillio (Kay & Burton) Under the Hammer, $3,535,000, 3 bidders
“A large crowd gathered in the front garden of this magnificent property to hear Jason Scillio provide a well prepared preamble prior to inviting bids from a large crowd on this beautiful afternoon. After the usual hesitation, strong bidding emerged from three buyers and it was on the market at $3,450,000. The house was soon bought with a strong bid $3,535,000.” (David James)

Bidderbuzz Auction: Elwood 69 Ruskin:  Sam Gamon (Chisholm & Gamon) Under the Hammer, $1,600,000, 3 bidders
“An opening bid of $1,000,000 was quickly surpassed by the effervescent Sam Gamon, who offered a vendor bid of $1,350,000. This produced brisk bidding from three buyers with a fourth entering a little later. The property was declared to be on the market at $1,500,000 and, with a strong knockout bid of $1,600,000, was successful in obtaining this well located house.” (David James)

Biggest Pass In: St Kilda 94 Wellington:  Jason Scillio (Kay & Burton) Passed In, $1,700,000, zero bidders
“Following a brief but well prepared preamble, Jason Scillio invited bids for this magnificent two storey period home, a really sumptuous residence just so close to every amenity. Unfortunately his appeals failed to produce a response and the property was passed in on a Vendor Bid of $1,700,000.” (David James)

Agent Q & A: How do you value a home?
Matthew Young, Buxton, St Kilda:“When valuing a property there are two forms: a market appraisal which is what most agents conduct and a valuation that only a sworn valuer is licensed to carry out. As a licensed estate agent, the most important aspect when appraising property is to look at comparable sales. That is, what other properties have sold for in a similar area, the market conditions, the property’s size, features and importantly quality. It is almost impossible to find an exact match so adjustments will need to be made.  This is where experience and local area knowledge play a vital role. We also need to look at a several properties to eliminate any irregularities such as buyer emotion or a freakish result. When buying property don’t hesitate to lean on the experts for professional advice, be it buyer advocates or estate agents.”

Damian O’Sullivan, BenMac, Albert Park:”In order to accurately value a home, comparable sales evidence is of utmost importance. Relying on factual data, rather than guess work is imperative. In particular, our due diligence is based around researching recent sales of a similar / relevant nature in the immediate vicinity of the home being appraised. The research compares homes that are similar in style as well as taking into account the land size, the orientation, the condition they are in, the streetscape and more. We feel that home owners not only deserve a transparent and realistic approach to valuing property but advice they can actually rely on.”

Sam Gamon, Chisholm & Gamon, Elwood:“When we appraise a home, we adhere to certain consistent guidelines in order to ensure we take a scientific approach and provide our clients with a logical estimate, based upon recent sales of like properties. In the event there are no direct comparable sales, we assess properties which might have less features or more features and then add or subtract depending on the perceived value of those attributes. Our first port of call when appraising a home is the “walk-through”. We like to do an internal inspection so we can get a feel for size, light, floor plan, etc. All of these factors weigh into a buyer’s decision making when they’re comparing one home to the next. We then step away from the property and undertake extensive research on comparable sales within the area before we make some judgements on the final appraisal range…and submit our client with their free marketing appraisal report. We take every care to ensure the accuracy of the estimate we’re giving is fair and reasonable.”

Michael Szulc (Cayzer) rejected a low bid of $1m to kick start the auction at 77 Heath St, Port Melbourne. The property later passed in for $1,370,000 on a vendor bid. No bidders

Key Points

• 284 Albert South Melbourne bought at auction for $2,170,000 Nick Yannopoulos of RT Edgar
• Many homes on offer today failed to attract any interest
• Two good $2m+ homes in Park St. St Kilda West  failed to attract a bid

BidderBuzz auction of the day

229 Page St, Middle Park, Andrew Stuart, Hocking Stuart, Under the Hammer $1,620,000, 2 bidders
“I like Andrew Stuart – he is ripper, no nonsense auctioneer and this was another one of his specialties. Bit of humour, bit of pressure, bit of bidding. Opened up around where it sold for less than a year ago at $1,450,000 and two bidders pushed it along under Andrew’s cajoling until it was on the market (officially) and bought at $1,620,000. Sorry the market is faltering – you’ve heard. Not right now on the good stuff – it ain’t. $170,000 above the November 2009 sale figure.”

Agent Q & A:

October 23 is Super Saturday – What can we expect?

Kaine Lanyon, BenMac, Albert Park: “As always Super Saturday is the busiest auction weekend of the year and we expect the clearance rates for that day to be in line with the last number of weekends. The volume so far for spring hasn’t been up at the high levels we have seen from previous years, meaning the market is far from flooded which should keep prices pretty consistent. In summary “Steady as she goes”. Still severely lacking listings in the $2-4m bracket.”

Damian O’Sullivan, BenMac, Albert Park: “A particularly busy weekend for all concerned. We have 27 auctions scheduled and the early signs are promising for our vendors. That said, we’re sure that the buyers will be excited by the volume of property being offered because sadly they have been comparatively starved for some time now. This pent up demand should theoretically see clearance rates in the mid 70% range across Melbourne which would be a reasonable outcome.”

Sam Gamon, Chisholm & Gamon, Elwood:”Super Saturday should be about Super Sales! We have several investors wanting to purchaser for their Super Funds, lots of raving Bayside fans feeling positive now the sun is out & the RBA’s decision has put a smile on everyone’s face.”

Forward Auction Bookings

Some auctions in our forward booking estimates failed to get near $1m – hence discrepancy with results below

Clearance Rates

Results

Some of our buyer prayers have been answered

Market: Even with significantly reduced auction numbers this weekend (owing to a more important event which finally delivered a result that proved there was justice in the world), we still saw a pretty healthy market result for sellers – with a 74% Clearance Rate on the 55 $Million+ auctions we monitored. Of those 55 auctions, 9 results were not reported. But even that is not unreasonable under the circumstances of the GF Replay.

There seems little doubt that the market is on the rise. The big interest now is how the market will absorb the stock surge that will culminate in Spring/Summer’s first Super Saturday on October 23rd.

And it really is Super Saturday - with a massive 81 $M+ auctions booked for Boroondara alone, and around 200 $M+ auctions booked in our key focus $M+ areas – Bayside and Inner East. Check out the size of the Weekly Review this week (it’s as big as a phone book). By comparison this weekend saw only one quarter of that number of auctions. So if you were at an auction this weekend, those four bidders you competed against may well be spread across four homes in a couple of weeks. Well that’s the “buyer-hope” theory anyway.

This Week’s Highlights:

• Two land sales showing vastly differing land values
  a) Land at 101 River Avenue Plenty (39,500 sqm), which can be subdivided, was auctioned  by Rob Stefanovski of LJ Hooker Greensborough and  bought for $3,830,000 or $96 per sq metre
  b) A large land parcel (1,813 sqm) at 3-5 Heath St Sandringham sold after a failed auction by Bill Jowett of Buxton for $2,800,000 or $1,544 per sq metre
• The major stock inflows that took place on Monday, Tuesday and Wednesday when agents began their marketing campaigns for the next Super Saturday – October 23rd.
• The continued improvement of the $3M+ market – two examples below
  a) Off market in Black St Brighton (Peter Bourbaud and Barb Gregory) – bought for around $4 million
  b) 27 Moorhouse Armadale with Gowan Stubbings of Kay and Burton – bought after an Expression of Interest campaign for more than $5 million
• The Pies Forward Line pressure (whoops, sorry – I got distracted)

Auction Snapshot from this weekend: 133 Rathmines Fairfield: Michael Fry and Grant Leonard of Nelson Alexander. Bought under the hammer for $1,116,000. 5 bidders.
There was a buzz about this well located timber period home, which had had its quote lifted to $930,000 during the campaign. It was a surprising development given Grant’s comment that the property failed to attract any interest in the high $800s a few months ago with a quiet sale campaign. It was on the market with the first bid at $900,000. Second bid $950,000. Third bid $970,000. Fourth bid-  bang $1,000,000. Three more bidders joined in before the action stopped at $1,116,000. It was a well run auction campaign. I always enjoy a Michael Fry auction. He has a sophisticated grace about him incongruent with the fact that he is yanking the dollars from buyers’ pockets. Enjoyable to watch unless you’re an underbidder – which unfortunately this time we were.

Bumper Market Insight: We have an information packed Market Insight this week; even though there are no Market Wraps, Bidderman, reports or videos.  The footy replay threw this auction weekend into a bit of chaos, with a few auctions even changing days. But it was a very low stock weekend anyway, so no major damage. All $M results are at the end of this Market Insight. But the big news now is the next three weekends that will lead full bore into the Melbourne Cup Long Weekend.

Stock Levels and Price Assessment:
The big question the market will be asking now is: What will happen to prices on October 23rd? With this big stock influx, how is the price game of snakes and ladders going to pan out? Are we going to see the slippery snake and big price slide of May 2010 or will the market just take this in its stride, as it did this time last year, with prices climbing further up the ladder? Time will tell. Importantly as buyers you need to get yourself organised – and don’t count your chickens before they’ve hatched.

With this apparent largess of choice, perhaps you don’t need brilliant home-seeking skills right at this moment. But you will need first class assessment procedures (e.g. sorting the goodies from the baddies in terms of capital growth prospects, and working out which one is best from a “happy wife = happy life” point of view). You will also need good negotiation strategies – because while you may have more choice, you will also have competition. Remember, our bidders per auction indicator Bidderman was strong on lower numbers in September, especially on good homes. On the flipside, some sellers expectations may be disappointed, so planning good negotiation strategies will improve your chances of grabbing a bargain when it presents.

Have a look at our Forward Auction Booking graphs below to get an idea of what is ahead of you: (click on a graph to enlarge)

There are also some exciting trophy homes on offer through private sale and off market – especially in the $3m+ segment.

Have a look at the New Stock Graph at the top of Market Insight – which compares the last week in September to the last week in June, (private sale and auction weekly new stock numbers are combined).

Special Report on the $3m Market

The $3m+ is back, after the self induced May hiccup that led to a very quiet winter.

There have been over 50 buys in the month of September at this level, with buyers coming from all quarters. Let’s pick one of the segments – around $4million. We have bought 3 homes at this specific level in the last few weeks. All were classic period homes with land of over 1000 square metres. Two were bought post auction (eg after a pass-in) and one was off market (Black St Brighton). However, the interesting thing were the buyer profiles. One buyer was a change of life family, one was a growing family that needed more space, and one was an expat family returning from overseas. This is a fairly accurate representation of the range of people we look for homes for. Of the last case – expats returning from overseas -Brighton high end agent Peter Bourbaud believes “this group will push the market along for the next few years, after a couple of very quiet years from the expat community”. We concur. Last year we conducted very little in business terms last year for expats. However in 2010 there has been a distinct pick up in action from expats returning home.

The James September $3m+ Report with all reported $3m+ boughts and solds can be viewed from the Home Page (next to Market Insight and below Buyer Masterclass) or click here

If you are new to the $3m market you may find the charts below (using 2007 to 2010 Valuer General, REIV and our own James Databases) of some value, as they help to show how the overall $3m+ market works. Note particularly that:

• The two powerhouse $3m+ suburbs are Brighton and Toorak (see 2009 results graphed below). However these two suburbs behave quiet differently from each other (see median graph). More on that another time.
• More $3m+ is bought later in the year than early. (2009 graphed below)
• There are some real name streets around and there are some falsies (where if you pay top dollar you will stand out like a beacon)
• Less than a quarter (25%) of $3m+ homes sell under the hammer at auction (click on September Graph below)
• A lot more activity is off market (not advertised) at this $3m+ level than any other price point, e.g. sub $3m.

Click on any of the graphs below to bring them up to full size

Agent Comments on the current $3m+ market

• “Prior to the school holiday period there was some renewed strength in $3m+ market due to things stabilising after the election and to the shortage of good quality homes. With the spring market in full swing it will be very interesting to see what happens with the increase of volume. But if the enquiry rates are anything to go by, October will be a strong month of sales.” Andrew Hayne of Marshall White Malvern
• “The $3 million plus market is strong, and we are expecting a big finish to spring in this market for good family homes.” Nick Johnstone of JP Dixon Brighton
  
• “There seems to have been a resurgence of buyer enquiry for the upper end properties recently.  It will be interesting to see if this follows through once we see increased stock levels after the school holidays and round 2 of the Grand Final.” Julian Augustini of Hodges Brighton
• Andrew Baynes from Kay and Burton South Yarra “Last Monday was the busiest auction sign up day for me in 10 years.”

Media Monitor: Domain – The Age 2/10/10. Headlined: “Hands up if you don’t have a clue” by Josh Jennings. Basically a solid article – but Josh, how many homes has Dr Damien Eldridge, Economics Lecturer from La Trobe University, bought using his quoted bidding advice this year? Would it have been 5 or 10 or 50? Going by his auction comments we were unclear as to whether you were holding him out as an expert – or simply providing supporting evidence to your headline.

We are not all brickbats here for the mainstream press. Congratulations to Chris Vedelago from The Age who this year has been consistently reporting the market as it really is and who actually seems to get out of the ivory tower (that so many property reporters are stuck in) and goes to auctions and talks to agents. We mightn’t always agree with you Chris, but we respect your work. Keep it up and keep getting out into the market.

Market News TV: On Tuesday of this week we ask the question: Is the ACCC or CAV the right watchdog for the real estate industry? Check out our Agent Opinion Videos.

Buyer Masterclass: We conclude our Negotiation Masterclass series with an article on Backward Bidding. From next week until Christmas we will be looking at “Pricing and Values” in Million Dollar Melbourne

Reported Results:

Big Crowds on Canterbury: 42 Wattle Valley. Bought After: Richard Winneke: Over $3,426,000: Photo courtesy Jellis Craig.

September Executive Summary:

Demand: Solid and increasing

• Reported Boughts: 46
• Bidderman: Substantial improvement in bidders per auction at the higher level. Random cross section of bidders. 1/3/2/1/3/1/3/2/2/3/3/3/2/1/0/0 for a month average of 1.875

Supply: New Stock Low

• Overhang from May however new stock is still light on at end of September and that which comes on at a reasaonble price is mostly being bought.

Price: Firming

• A number of stales (on market over 3 months) were purchased in Bayside reducing overhang – this will have an upwards effect on price if demand remains constant.
• Some new properties coming onto the market but new stock is still limited in Boroondara and Stonnington also encouraging price in an upwards direction.

Quote of the month: Stewart Lopez of Kay and Burton ” In this improving Upper End market, sellers are getting back the control that they lost with the stock splurge in May”

Highlights
Over $9 million
Hawthorn 24 Coppin: Jock Langley: Around $9,000,000 Private Sale. This basic house, on an acre on the river in Hawthorn’s river precinct, has been on the market for well over a year and had quotes at $15m then 12m and then…. A number of agents have worked on this. I went through this home last year and finally Jock Langley has got a sale through under $10m. It is a great block, its only fault until today was its price tag.
Brighton 292 New: Brian Devlin and Regina Schmidt: Around $9,000,000 Private Sale. Up for sale for less than a month, this grand looking home was purchased today for around $9,000,000. A very impressive block just down from Brighton Grammar.
Over $7 million
Toorak 11 Cole: Ross Savas: Private Sale: Quote $8,000,000 plus reported as bought for above that figure
Undisclosed Rating: http://www.james.net.au/rating/11-Cole-Court-TOORAK
Hawthorn East 49 Harcourt: James Tostevin: Bought After: Over $7,200,000: Bidderman 2
James Auction Report: http://www.marketnews.com.au/auction-reviews/8661/49-Harcourt-Street-HAWTHORN_EAST/
Brighton 6 Head: Jeremy Fox: Sold well after auction: Around $7,000,000
Full Rating: http://www.james.net.au/rating/6-Head-Street-BRIGHTON

Bidderbuzz Auction of the Month
24 Somers Malvern: Jeremy Fox: Under the hammer: $6,160,000: Bidderman 3
James Auction Report and Rating: http://www.marketnews.com.au/auction-reviews/8705/24-Somers-Avenue-MALVERN/
The sunfilled courtyard was a perfect setting for the Somers Avenue auction, with the lovely weather attracting a generous crowd of interested parties and onlookers alike. Auctioneer Jeremy Fox asked the crowd for an opening bid, but was disappointed with silence. It wasn’t long before a confident bid of $5,000,000 soon had the ball rolling though. Two parties continued with strong bidding, as the crowd watched on with baited breath. It was at $5,650,000 when another bidder keenly entered the fray, enquiring if the house was in fact yet ‘on the market’. There was clear buzz of anticipation amongst the crowd, as Mr. Fox conferred with the vendors, and finally confirming in the positive. Bidding continued fast and furiously between bidders, whilst the crowd remained captivated. The final knock-out bid brought on a genuine look of relief to the successful bidder. A truly entertaining auction, as you could hear echoed amongst the departing onlookers. (Nikki Hills)

Late Entries (Not Included in Stats)
Brighton Black St: Peter Bourbaud and Barb Gregory: Off Market: James Home Rating 852/1000. Price Undisclosed
Toorak 5 Myrnong: Darren Krongold and Sally Zelman: Private Sale: Price Undisclosed
James Rating: http://www.james.net.au/rating/5-Myrnong-Crescent-TOORAK
Armadale 23 Moorhouse: Gowan Stubbings: Expressions of Interest: Price over $5,000,000
James Rating: http://www.james.net.au/rating/23-Moorhouse-Street-ARMADALE

Apartments:
East Melbourne 144 Jolimont Road: Marcus Chiminello: Penthouse $3,250,000
Melbourne 301/401 St Kilda Road: Marcus Chiminello: Lucient $3,100,000

Albert Park
Albert Park 62 Beaconsfield: Kaine Lanyon: Quote $3,500,000 to $3,750,000: James Home Rating 655/1000: At Auction: Over $3,300,000
James Rating: http://www.james.net.au/rating/62-Beaconsfield-Parade-ALBERT_PARK

Armadale
81 Rose: Tim Derham: Bought Over $3,300,000. A  terrace home that needed a fair bit of work but did have rear access and was north facing to rear. Solid result.
James Undisclosed Rating: http://www.james.net.au/rating/81-Rose-Street-ARMADALE
21 Adelaide: John Bongiorno auctioned this “bulldozer or significant rebuild” home at 4.30pm today. Bought for $3,130,000 or just over $4,000 per sqm. Bidderman 3. Heather Elder and Rae Tomlinson
James Undisclosed Rating: http://www.james.net.au/rating/21-Adelaide-Street-ARMADALE
28 Seymour: Joanna Nairn: Quote $3,500,000 plus: James Rating 682/1000: Bought After Auction: Around $3,500,000: Bidderman 1
James Auction Report: http://www.marketnews.com.au/auction-reviews/9007/28-Seymour-Avenue-ARMADALE/
1 Myamyn: Andrew Macmillan: Under the hammer: $3,215,000: Bidderman 2
James Auction Report: http://www.marketnews.com.au/auction-reviews/8670/1-Myamyn-Street-ARMADALE/
3 Avalon: Ross Savas: Bought: Reportedly over $7,000,000, but not confirmed:
James Rating: http://www.james.net.au/rating/3-Avalon-Road-ARMADALE

Balwyn
Balwyn 23 Bevan: Richard James & William Chen: Quote $3,300,000 to $3,600,000: James Home Rating 742/1000: Bought After Auction: Around $3,500,000: Bidderman 1
James Auction Report: http://www.marketnews.com.au/auction-reviews/8932/23-Bevan-Street-BALWYN/

Brighton
10 Campbell: Peter Kennett. Private Sale after a Pass-In Auction. In excess of pass-in $3,850,000.
James Undisclosed Rating: http://www.james.net.au/rating/10-Campbell-Street-BRIGHTON
20 Bent: Justin Follett. Private Sale . Within asking price range $3,800,000 – $4,000,000.
James Undisclosed Rating: http://www.james.net.au/rating/20-Bent-Street-BRIGHTON
7 St Ninians: Nick Johnstone. Private Sale. In excess of  $3,500,000.
James Undisclosed Rating: http://www.james.net.au/rating/7-St_Ninians-Court-BRIGHTON
292 New: Brian Devlin and Regina Schmidt: Around $9,000,000 Private Sale. Up for sale for less than a month, this grand looking home was purchased today for around $9,000,000. A very impressive block just down from Brighton Grammar.
James Undisclosed Rating: http://www.james.net.au/rating/292-New-Street-BRIGHTON
22 Tennyson: Marcus Gollings. Private Sale. In excess of $5,000,000.
James Undisclosed Rating: http://www.james.net.au/rating/22-Tennyson-Street-BRIGHTON
3/9 Glyndon: Stewart Lopez: Private Sale: Mid $3,000,000’s
James Rating: Click here http://www.james.net.au/rating/3/9-Glyndon-Avenue-BRIGHTON
6 Head: Jeremy Fox: bought well after auction: Around $7,000,000
Full Rating click here: http://www.james.net.au/rating/6-Head-Street-BRIGHTON
19 Wellington: Stewart Lopez and Sturt Hinton. Private Sale after Auction. Over $4,000,000
James Rating: http://www.james.net.au/rating/19-Wellington-Street-BRIGHTON
3 Wellington: Stewart Lopez and Sturt Hinton. Private Sale after Auction. Around $3,900,000
James Rating: http://www.james.net.au/rating/3-Wellington-Street-BRIGHTON
5/23 St Ninians: Stewart Lopez and Sturt Hinton. Private Sale under $5,000,000
James Rating: http://www.james.net.au/rating/5/23-St_Ninians-Road-BRIGHTON
6 Seacombe: Ian Jackson: Private Sale over $4,500,000
James Rating: http://www.james.net.au/rating/6-Seacombe-Grove-BRIGHTON

Camberwell
8 Canterbury: Peter Mitchell: bought after auction: Around $3,000,000: Bidderman 3
James Auction Report: http://www.marketnews.com.au/auction-reviews/7926/8-Canterbury-Road-CAMBERWELL/

Canterbury
42 Wattle Valley: Richard Winneke: bought after, in excess of $3,426,000: Bidderman 1
James Auction Report: http://www.marketnews.com.au/auction-reviews/8807/42-Wattle_Valley-Road-CANTERBURY/
23 Chaucer: James Tostevin: bought after over $3,850,000: Bidderman 3
James Auction Report: http://www.marketnews.com.au/auction-reviews/8221/23-Chaucer-Crescent-CANTERBURY/

Elwood
31 Ormond: Marcus Gollings: Expressions of Interest: Bought over $4,000,000
James Undisclosed Rating: http://www.james.net.au/rating/31-Ormond-Esplanade-ELWOOD

Hawthorn
2 Berkeley: Rob Vickers-Willis: Bought at Auction: Bought over $3,000,000
James Undisclosed Rating: http://www.james.net.au/rating/2-Berkeley-Street-HAWTHORN
24 Coppin: Jock Langley: Around $9,000,000 Private Sale. This basic house, on an acre on the river in Hawthorn’s river precinct, has been on the market for well over a year and had quotes at $15m then 12m and then…. A number of agents have worked on this. I went through this home last year and finally Jock Langley has got a sale through under $10m. It is a great block, its only fault until today was its price tag.
James Undisclosed Rating: http://www.james.net.au/rating/24-Coppin-Grove-HAWTHORN
36 Chrystobel: Lisa Jarrett: Private Sale after auction: In excess of $3,500,000
James Auction Report: http://www.james.net.au/rating/36-Chrystobel-Crescent-HAWTHORN

Hawthorn East
49 Harcourt: James Tostevin: Bought After, over $7,200,000: Bidderman 2
James Auction Report: http://www.marketnews.com.au/auction-reviews/8661/49-Harcourt-Street-HAWTHORN_EAST/

Ivanhoe
59 Studley: David Oster: Under the hammer: $4,300,000: Bidderman 2
James Auction Report: http://www.marketnews.com.au/auction-reviews/8989/59-Studley-Road-IVANHOE/

Kew
63 Walpole: James Tostevin: Bought Before Auction: In excess of $3,000,000.

Malvern
24 Somers: Jeremy Fox: Under the hammer: $6,160,000: Bidderman 3
James Auction Report: http://www.marketnews.com.au/auction-reviews/8705/24-Somers-Avenue-MALVERN/
15 A Sorrett: Andrew Hayne: Week or so after Auction: Over $3,500,000
James Auction Report: http://www.james.net.au/rating/15a-Sorrett-Avenue-MALVERN
Elizabeth: Marcus Chiminello Off the plan $3,300,000
6 Bonview: John Bongiorno: Bought Afterwards in excess of $3,600,000: Bidderman 3
James Video Auction Report: http://www.marketnews.com.au/video/?vid=305
11 Moorakyne: Michael Gibson: Under the Hammer: $4,000,000: Bidderman: 3
James Rating and Auction Report: http://www.james.net.au/rating/11-Moorakyne-Avenue-MALVERN
17 Thanet: Mark Wridgway: Before Auction: Bought over $3,500,000.
James Home Rating: http://www.james.net.au/rating/17-Thanet-Street-MALVERN

Malvern East
31 Finch St: Andrew McCann: Under the Hammer: $3,360,000: Bidderman 2
James Auction Report: http://www.marketnews.com.au/auction-reviews/8376/31-Finch-Street-MALVERN_EAST/

South Yarra
38 Park: Warwick Anderson: Quote $3,500,000 plus: James Rating 725/1000: Bought After Auction: Above $3,000,000: Bidderman 1
James Auction Report: http://www.marketnews.com.au/auction-reviews/8476/38-Park-Place-SOUTH_YARRA/
19 Acland: Greg Herman: 4 bidders: Bought under the hammer: $3,600,000
James Auction Report: http://www.marketnews.com.au/auction-reviews/6886/19-Acland-Street-SOUTH_YARRA/

St Kilda
Two Block of Flats:
4 Church: Claudio Perruzza: Bought at Auction $3,400,000
16 Charnwood: Adam Joske: Bought at Auction $6,060,000

Toorak
11 Cole: Ross Savas: Private Sale: Quote $8,000,000 plus reported as bought for above that figure
Undisclosed Rating: http://www.james.net.au/rating/11-Cole-Court-TOORAK
2/23 Tintern: Ross Savas: Private Sale: Quote $5,000,000 plus reported as bought for above that figure
Undisclosed Rating: http://www.james.net.au/rating/2/23-Tintern-Avenue-TOORAK
8 Macquarie: Jeremy Fox: Private Sale after auction. $6,400,000.
James Rating: http://www.james.net.au/rating/8-Macquarie-Road-TOORAK
4 Forrest Court: Peter Kudelka and James Scarff: Bought after auction $4,050,000: Bidderman 0
James Auction Report: Click here http://www.marketnews.com.au/auction-reviews/8829/4-Forrest-Court-TOORAK
1 Hopetoun: Justin Long: Bought after auction: Over $5,500,000: Bidderman 0
James Auction Report: http://www.marketnews.com.au/auction-reviews/8671/1-Hopetoun-Road-TOORAK/
803 Orrong: Warwick Anderson: Private Sale $4,500,000
Undisclosed Rating: http://www.james.net.au/rating/803-Orrong-Road-TOORAK
1a Como: Greg Herman: Private Sale: Over $6,400,000

Please Note: The $3m+ market can be a very shadowy one at times with regards to what is bought, if indeed it was actually bought and what price (cash and/or otherwise) was paid. At all times the prices we outline are never truly confirmed until they can be viewed six to nine months later at the Government stamp duties office – however we don’t publish without feeling there is a high degree of truth. This is why as buyer agents when pricing homes we never make decisions on one buy alone and why true land and building values plus an overall knowledge of all buys is vital in calculating correct market value.  At this price level it is also a very private world and we respect that when trying to balance market transparency v individual privacy. We accept we don’t get it right every time but we do try. We never discuss buyer/seller personalities; we do not reveal intimate details to the wider press and we do not disclose full details publicly where the source has asked us not to. Our sources are not just the selling agent, but underbidders, our own advocates, REIV, our auction reporters and other agents not connected with the sale/buy. If you aware of an error or omission please email mal@james.net.au and we will adjust – you will be treated confidentially if you wish.

David Hart saying "Ok I give up - for the moment" 42 Clinton Brighton East - Passed In with No bidders. Bought soon afterwards over $1,700,000.

Key Points:

• Two big sales during the week: 282 New St Brighton with Regina Schmidt and Brian Devlin of Buxton around $9,000,000, and 21 Moule Ave Brighton with Stewart Lopez of Kay and Burton (off market) reportedly in the high $6 millions
• 15 sold over $1 million in the last week – including four in Beaumaris
• Clearance rates trending upwards quickly – Saturday was a big improvement on previous weeks
• We covered 8 auctions in Bayside on Saturday and there was a 100% strike rate with three selling before auction, three selling after auction and two selling under the hammer.
• Bayside Bidderman is still low, with only two auctions attracting multiple bidders.

Video Auction this week at 24 Susan St Sandringham – and a cracker it was!

Agent Q & A: Who will win the AFL Premiership and why?

David Hart, Buxton, Brighton: “Geelong will win because when it comes to the crunch they’ve got the class and the players – and I don’t like Collingwood!”

Mark Bury,  Kay & Burton, Brighton: ” St Kilda because we’ve got to support the locals and because Ian (Jackson) will kill me if I don’t say St Kilda!”

Jason Gill,  Hodges, Brighton: “Collingwood because they have had a fantastic year and everyone hates them.”

Gerry Gordon,  Hocking Stuart, Brighton:” Collingwood – because they have to!”

Nick Johnstone of JP Dixon: “Collingwood by a mile”

Rowan Dent,  Hocking Stuart, Sandringham: “Collingwood – based on this year’s performance record.”

Steve Tickell, Hocking Stuart, Sandringham: “The Saints of course! History will repeat itself and the Saints will win by a point, on the siren like they did in ’66.”

Bill Jowett, Buxton, Sandringham: “I’m sorry to say it’s Collingwood”

Stock Comments

Steve Tickell, Hocking Stuart, Sandringham: “Stock is slowly building. There seem to be a lot more inquiries from people, and I would say it has been more positive in the past week – more like 2007 than 2009. In Bayside, villa units and good family homes continue to attract a lot of interest.”

Bill Jowett, Buxton, Sandringham: “End of October is looking strong, top end a little tougher and a bit of strife with development sites due to banks only lending at 60%”

Nick Johnstone of JP Dixon: “Stock levels are OK – compared to last year on par. Shortages in $2m range for family homes that are comfortable.”

Land Sale Price Pointer:
46 Bay Brighton – Vacant Land in precinct between New St and St Kilda St – 800 sqm in size was bought for $2,225,000 or $2781 per sqm Nick Johnstone JP Dixon

Bidderbuzz Auction of the Day: 24 Susan St, Sandringham, Mark Earle, Buxton, Under the Hammer, $1,220,000, 5 bidders.
“Spring was certainly in the air at the ‘Sandy’ auction. The sun shone, birds chirped and 70 people swarmed to the property like bees to a hive. The atmosphere was chatty and cheerful as auctioneer Mark Earle stepped out. A crowd bid of $960,000 got things started and bids soon came in from every angle. One resilient bidder made herself known early with some courageous bidding. She continued to power through despite being “attacked from every side,” past the selling price at $1,110,000, to buy the property under the hammer at $1,220,000 to the delight of her supportive cheer squad.” (Julia Atkinson)

Clearance Rates & Monitor Table:

Forward Auction Stock:

We Only Buy Homes

Marcus Peters (Biggin & Scott) led a brisk, successful auction at 5 Bright St, Brighton East. Bought under the hammer, $1,420,000, four bidders and a crowd of 60.

A sea of umbrellas was all that could be seen at 97 Graham St, Albert Park. Around 90 people watched as Andrew Stuart (Hocking Stuart) brought down the hammer at $2,630,000. Two bidders.

Key Points:

• We focused on Albert Park today and there were reasonable bidder numbers across several auctions. However, Port Phillip has still started Spring very slowly.
• Prices had been falling during Winter and the factors are there for that to continue; especially if any sort of Spring stock level surge is not met by a corresponding increase in bidder numbers – our only proviso is this is a small dynamic market and things change very quickly in Port Phillip.

Biggest Buy:
97 Graham St, Albert Park, Andrew Stuart, Hocking Stuart, Bought $2,630,000.
“Despite threatening skies overhead, and persistent drizzle, Andrew Stuart bravely started proceedings outside with a vendor bid of $2,400,000. After a relatively slow start, a battle between two keen buyers ensued. After Mr Stuart declared the property on the market at $2,617,500, the bidding quickly soared to the selling price of $2,630,000 – a strong result for Mr Stuart and the Hocking Stuart team.”(Jen Milligan)

Agent Comments:
Oliver Bruce, BenMac, Albert Park: “There is a reasonable selection of properties available in Albert Park. A good mix of terraces, small and large, modern and liveable. There are a few unrenovated and three or four land offerings too. There is a shortage of double fronted homes and there are fewer properties on the market in Middle Park. South Melbourne is quiet and there is a shortage in the Howe Crescent/ Lamaro precinct. I am seeing a lot of the same faces around at opens and auctions. Reasonable numbers are attending both for correctly priced opportunities. As always, price is a driving factor for both vendors and buyers. I have seen some absolutely phenomenal prices in every price bracket. These big prices have been driven by competition. One can only assume that the buyers are flocking towards the better homes, or the better priced homes. I am seeing very few offers for properties prior to auction. Buyers are sitting back playing the waiting game thinking that no one will bid, only to see two or three motivated buyers pushing prices well above everyone’s expectations.”

Adrian Wood, Cayzer, Albert Park: “The market is fair at the moment. There is a lack of stock and looking into Spring is like looking into a crystal ball – who knows what will happen. Demand is higher than supply at the moment. Bidder numbers have been down overall, but good quality, well priced homes are still bringing outstanding results.”

Bidderbuzz Auction of the Day:
25 Longmore St, St Kilda West, John Bongiorno, Marshall White, three bidders:
“Having to hold the auction indoors due to wet weather, John Bongiorno asked serious bidders to enter one room and anyone else to stand down the hallway. His invitation to the sitting room was taken up by around a dozen people which looked promising for Mr Bongiorno and the Marshall White team. Out of that group, there were three bidders who fought it out, taking the price to $1,075,000 which, unfortunately, wasn’t enough to buy the property under the hammer. Mr Bongiorno, instead, passed the house in at this amount. Bought after for an undisclosed amount.”(Jen Milligan)

Clearance Rates & Monitor Table: Spring start has been slower than a Mark Webber one.

We Only Buy Homes

Phil DeFegely (for JC Street) brought the action indoors at 347 Dorcas St South Melbourne. Passed in $980,000. Two bidders.

Sam Gamon (Chisholm & Gamon) looks for some bidders at 36 Shelley St, Elwood but to no avail. Passed in for $940,000, no bidders.

Key Points:

Analysis: This was Spring’s first test for Port Melbourne to Elwood. As far as auction homes go it failed badly. The quality was questionable and some newer stock coming on is visible – so there is a high chance buyers are holding off until then. Even so this was a poor start to Spring for Port Phillip. This $M+ market is smaller than the others we cover weekly and has a history of responding dynamically to minor changes in circumstance, so the next few weeks will be viewed with interest.

Agent Comments: In  fairness this election question was asked just prior to this weekends’s results.

Joseph Allan, Chisholm & Gamon, Port Melbourne:“When I heard about the election, I thought it was not going to be ideal for the market. But so far, I have had no indication that it has affected it at all. I guess the big question is: will it affect stock levels coming up? We’ll wait and see.”

Kaine Lanyon, BenMac, Albert Park: “I don’t believe the actual election result itself will affect the market in any real direction. It’s more the waiting around, the ‘holding pattern’ until we see a final result of who will next govern the country, that seems to be affecting the market in a positive sense.  Many vendors will still not yet commit to a selling campaign, so there is  less stock on the market – which in my view is largely why some of our results have been so strong over the last four weeks. That is limited choice for the current bunch of buyers to choose from if they miss out on the only property they like that is currently available”.

Sam Gamon, Chisholm & Gamon, Elwood: “I haven’t seen any impact due to the Election.  Buyers are realising they’re not on a ‘deserted island’ and that other people are making decisions. In essence, I feel buyers are very decisive for the right property. If anything the Election may hold back some sellers from listing as they’d like the assurance of a definite outcome. The warmer weather is bringing renewed positivity to the market place and buyers are keen to move forward when they find something they relate to”

We Only Buy Homes

David Wood (Hocking Stuart) successfully sold 80 Neville St, Middle Park, after auction for an undisclosed amount. One bidder, small crowd of 30.

St Kilda 45 Havelock: Robert Harvey pleading - but to no avail. Passed In bidderless for $880,000

From Port Melbourne to St Kilda things are very much normal for this time of the year. Something – but not much - is happening. These are Bayside suburbs and sales here are very seasonally orientated.

Of the five auctions we covered this week, three passed in, one sold under the hammer and one after auction. Bidderman was just over 1 but that’s not a hugely meaningful figure this week because, as Michael Szulc of Cayzers puts it, one week we are all chocolates and sell everything, the next week it’s all boiled lollies and lots of pass-ins. On such low numbers it all depends on the stock quality.

There were ten reported residential sales over $1 million this week compared to 25 in the corresponding week in May – or about 40% of the activity now compared to May.

Agent Comments – detailed interview with Michael Szulc of Cayzers

• Pre-auction offers are being considered with 25% of Cayzers auctions currently selling beforehand – admittedly on low numbers, as expected for this time of the year
• Overhang is being mopped up – but less than you think Mal.
• 35% of sales are private
• Sub $1 million properties have cost-prohibitive traditional advertising, but those with just internet advertising are selling just as well
• Prices treading water. Plateau
• I got an interesting answer when I asked Michael why we had such huge stock levels early in the year and his response was the most original one I have heard: With the GFC a number of investors took out 12 month leases. All those leases lapsed about the same time, just as we had come into a significantly better market, and were all put up for sale around the same time.
• Significant drop in activity – but this was largely expected

Highlights

34 Derham St Port Melbourne – a nice little single fronter in not the best part of Port Melbourne.

James Auction Report: Torsten Kasper of Chisholm and Gamon politely rejected an opening bid of $800,000 from the crowd and instead offered a vendor bid of $900,000 to get things going. After a slow but steady start, four genuine bidders entered the fray and a battle ensued to the very end. Rapid-fire bidding from all parties saw the property go on the market at $945,500 and subsequently sell for $1,092,500. It was a subdued crowd with a lot of curious bystanders, but a strong result for Mr Kasper and the Chisholm and Gamon team.

We are looking at 8 auctions in Port Phillip in the coming week.

We only buy homes

Port Melbourne 34 Derham: Best auction of the day. 4 bidders and bought under the hammer for $1,092,500

What is it with redheads? They're running the country - and now they're taking over the auctions. We counted six in this photo in amongst auctioneer Phillip Kingston from Gary Peer. 7A Nightingale St Kilda East. Bought After $1,200,000. 1 bidder.

At 6pm Saturday the James Clearance Rate on the 22 $M+ Auctions we covered was 59%.

Our Demand Indicator Bidderman was 2.2.  Hmmm – an interesting increase but it was off a very low turnover.

Today’s Highlights

1)      Bidders were present at 18 of the 22 auctions we covered –  and at three auctions there were 6+bidders

• 23 Sunburst Avenue Balwyn North (Doug McLauchlan of Marshall White)
• 12 Lennox St Hawthorn (Russell Turner of Christopher Russell)
• 7 Monomeath Avenue Toorak (Justin Long of Marshall White)

2)      The Pies are top of the ladder – and the election is on

We couldn’t find many $M+ auctions worth covering and only one of the auctions we covered went over $2m this weekend. So with the small numbers – just coming out of  the winter hiatus – it was like a first back training run before we get into the winter season proper over the next few weeks.

Agent Quotes

Scott Patterson of Jellis Craig: “Sold 12 from 16 today throughout the company. Opens and auctions were well attended…those who wish to sell in next month or two could enjoy quite solid results due to lack of supply, because demand seems reasonable… August 28 is looming as big weekend, particularly as it is now the week after the election…only thing is that Hawthorn vs Collingwood might affect crowd numbers etc…’

Hamish Tostevin of Marshall White: ”Opens were steady without being over-run with buyers. Certainly a lack of property at the moment in terms of supply. Should be a solid spring, particularly when the election is out of the way.”

Now, where were we before we were so rudely interrupted (by the school holidays)?

It has been a month since we last reported, and we have seen more Top End activity at Tullamarine than in any other suburb. Was it sales? No. It was our selling agent brethren jetting off to Europe to recharge their batteries. This poor humble buyer agent can only give you a travelogue on the Dubbo Zoo so I won’t bore you with tales of kids and a 12-hour car drive or the fact it ain’t a patch on the Werribee Zoo.

The world is a different place since our last report: back then Kevin ’07 was in charge, Masterchef was still a competition to find the best amateur chef in Australia, not the luckiest cook as it is now, and our $M+ market had prices cooling quicker than a Melbourne winter, after a blistering start to the year (although there were still an incredibly high number of buys).

A month ago we reported that the early 2010 gains had evaporated in the five auction weeks of May due to the sheer number of listings. May’s record supply finally stopped what had, since March 2009, been a rising market, driven initially by international buyer demand and then solid local demand.

So what is happening in our Winter Market (June to August) right now?

To be frank we don’t know for sure yet. But here are some of our thoughts.

1. Prices Now
2. Stock Quality Now
3. Method of Sale Now
4. Risk v Reward Now

Prices Now
Selling agents love to use the ‘p’ word plateau (rather than the four letter ‘f’ word)  to reflect on, or deflect away, thoughts of a declining price market. Right now, we actually agree with the ‘p’ word – especially if you accept that prices fell significantly in May and June. (By the way, the ‘f’ word that selling agents don’t like to use is fall.)

Some reasons prices may be plateuaing are:

• Seasonally reduced action (winter)
• An election on the horizon –  so some buyers and would-be sellers will pause to wait for the result.
• We had a big price fall in May and  for most of us market watchers the way forward is still unclear. Will we see more price drops or …. who knows? Like many, we are waiting for a sign.

Demand in Relation to Price

• This weekend Bidderman was at 2.2 – but, please note, this is based on very low auction volumes and therefore statistical distortions are possible.
• As a buying company,  we have had commitments from a significant number of new clients over the past few weeks.
• We feel it’s better to reflect overall demand as more cautious rather than dropping – however another month or two may tell us a different story.
• Right now, buyers still do have the rare luxury of having their cake and eating it too – if they choose to. Prices have fallen in May/June, and in July we are in a market of reasonable choice. Hooray for buyers!

Private Sale Clearance Rate – the number of Proven Sales is only 11 from 50 – or 22% – over the past six weeks.

Six weeks ago we randomly selected a basket of 50 higher end Private Sale and Expression of Interest properties, right across our $M+ Melbourne market. We did this with the aim of  checking  what was bought 6 weeks later (roughly the same time as a “go to whoa” auction campaign), and to therefore calculate the clearance rates  to see how Private Sales and Expressions of Interest were really going.

We thought this snapshot would provide the best reflection of private sale market activity and confirm or question comments by some selling agents that: “Oh yes, auctions were not as good as March, but we are selling a heap via private sale”. The results proved that while in May agents were selling a heap, it wasn’t so much the case in late June to early July. However,  it could have just been that many agents were away.

• We have made an effort to contact those that were withdrawn without a sale price, and we may have missed a few sales – but overall the non-auction homes are NOT running out the door any faster than the auctions. In fact you could make a strong argument that, as an effective method of sale, auctions are still outperforming private sales in many cases – despite the declining clearance rates, given that only 1 in 4 private sale properties have been bought in 6 weeks.
• These figures must surely help smart buyers put together an offering strategy. It’s certainly prompted us here at James Buyer Advocates to change how we buy in the last two months.

Today’s final word on price – are you a glass half empty of half full person?

If you feel the double-dip recession is fast approaching and the world as we knew it is about to end, then, by all means, don’t buy – and in fact sell (and please give us a ring if you have a good home to sell).

If you feel Julia (Gillard) won’t be changing the legitimate immigration numbers any time soon (demand) and Justin (Madden) won’t be able to release large numbers of housing blocks in Inner Melbourne because they are not there (supply), you may wish to ignore the doomsayers and take advantage of this current price breather combined with good stock offering. The GFC lasted less than a year  (for us) and in July 2010 Melbourne $M+ home prices are still 20 to 30 per cent above 2008 GFC home prices. Remember the 2008 ‘bulls**t’ rumour of the year, which said the NAB and other banks were about to foreclose on 200 homes in Toorak alone – it never happened. Yes we are biased and make a living by encouraging buyers to buy – but the facts are still very positive for buyers.

Stock Quality Going Forward
Spring quality and auction numbers are the variables we don’t have a clear handle on as yet. Right here and now in July, we have a market with excellent stock numbers for buyers – if you know where to look and you actually act correctly (please see the following paragraph on methods of sale). We also think the quality is good. Going forward, quality stock levels are not clear to us, because traditionally when quality sellers see a declining market they are loathe to put their home on the market on a speculative basis (in that, if they don’t have to sell, they won’t). This obviously leads to less stock on the market, which may affect price but, more importantly, it affects choice. Good buying decisions are more likely when, along with good advice, you, the buyer, have good choice.  You have that now.

Method of Sale
As we said, there is choice now if you know where to look, whom to ask and how to deal. Look at the above private sale table – there are some good homes there. We keep overhang lists (stales and unsolds) and there are also a number of off-markets and quiet pre-releases available. Granted, some of the vendors are still in their price cocoons but  quality sellers who have adjusted their price expectations may have homes worth considering. The off-market (unadvertised properties) may well be the market of choice for a number of buyers and sellers in the next few months.  But, please note buyers, you will have to sharpen your negotiation strategies to take advantage of all that is on offer.

Risk v Reward
To digress – Risk v Reward is where Masterchef’s Adam and Claire had it all over Jono. While Jono was going for the big dish on every occasion – and you have to admire him for that – he wasn’t playing the game to the best of his abilities. Adam is the quiet master at the Masterchef game. He sees a situation and says: “Yeah, I want to try and make a dish that will impress the judges and maybe get me a shot at immunity – the reward – but I don’t want to push the boundaries that far that I risk getting in the elimination round if I fail.” Good Home Buying and Negotiation is absolutely the same as this. Why is that? Because in the first instance the strategy should be to get yourself into a strong position and not risk all for the pot of gold. Once you are in that strong position, then you can make a run for the prize. Another analogy is acclimatising at base camp before you make the assault on the Everest summit. This is Risk v Reward.

A full James Buyer Opinion on Risk v Reward in today’s Market will be published here on Tuesday – so look out for it this week. At the moment you will find our biggest ever ‘clicked on’ James Buyer Opinion article – The Learning Fee - right next to this article.

It’s good to be back

We Only Buy Homes

Mal

Balwyn North 23 Sunburst. Big Crowd for Doug McLauchlan of Marshall White - 125 in fact. Seven bidders. Bought under the hammer for $1,567,000.

Albert Park 77 Page: Mr Stuart sure knows how to pull a crowd. A couple of jokes, four bidders and bang: she's bought - $1,290,000. He's still got it!

Of the 10 auctions we attended, three were bought before auction, three were bought under the hammer and four were passed in (with one bought after).  Our demand indicator Bidderman was at 1.5 bidders per auction. So out of 10, seven were bought. That seems a big improvement on the last few weeks. We have seen 20 homes over $1m purchased in a fortnight in Port Phillip.

This clearance rate boost was not completely unexpected; unlike Boroondara and Stonnington there is not much new stock on the horizon in Port Phillip. And, while there is an overhang of unsold properties, there is an argument that this mostly relates to inferior or overpriced stock.

We think Port Phillip may be a microcosm of what might happen in Melbourne generally – as soon as stock begins to dry up, the clearance rate will subsequently improve. And if that continues, a return to stronger prices will follow. While we are not fortune tellers, it feels as if this market – along with the other main Million-Dollar-Plus markets across Melbourne – may just be taking an enforced breather (caused by supply exceeding demand), and could reignite again once stock levels are significantly pared back. Let’s wait and see.

The big unanswered question is demand strength: Bidderman is still somewhat weak in Port Phillip, evidenced at 0.9 this weekend despite the post auction clearance rate.

20 Gellibrand Road, Port Melbourne went under the hammer with Frank Callaghan of Frank Gordon, advertised at $1,300,000+. After a very confident opening bid of $1,400,000, two bidders pushed the price to just over $1,600,000. Enter bidder number three, who was only interested in bidding in $1,000 rises, and the property was finally bought for $1,681,000 – which I thought was a solid result for the vendors.

Similarly, the auction at 13 -15 Evelyn Street, St Kilda East saw confident bidding and multiple bidders willing to pay considerably more than the reserve. The growing crowd saw Kaine Lanyon of Bennison Mackinnon put on a good performance and produce a solid result for his vendors. Speaking with Mr Lanyon after the auction, he indicated that, whilst the market is generally patchy, quality real estate is still attracting strong interest and multiple bidders and achieving good results.

Last but not least, 77 Page Street, Albert Park with Andrew Stuart of Hocking Stuart (a James Market News favourite), saw four bidders put their hand up for a slice of one of Albert Park’s premier streets. An opening vendor bid of $1,100,000 was followed by frenzied bidding. The property was announced on the market at $1,160,000, with a final result of $1,290,000. It was a strong result, given the current market, for a property with no car parking. However, that is what happens when four people are determined to get into a great pocket of Albert Park.

The properties that were sold before included: 7 Burns Street, Elwood;  76 Armstrong Street, Middle Park; 161 Dow Street, Port Melbourne.

The properties that were passed in included: 5 Kerferd Place, Albert Park; 96 Iffla Street, South Melbourne; 118 Hambleton Street, Middle Park (Sold post auction for $1,760,000)

What was interesting about all the passed-in properties was that  in all instances the vendor was the only bidder. So where is the value level if there are no actual bids?

Opportunity is now here, which makes it important to have more information on hand than the vendor thinks you have and than what the agent  is telling you.

Auction Clearance Rates

19 monitored – 13 bought – 68% clearance rate ( last week 54% / week before 32%)

Know your market

Middle Park 118 Hambleton: Oliver Bruce - He looks good and he is good. No bidders, yet bought immediately afterwards for $1,760,000.

St Kilda 35 Vale St: Today with the rain, it's indoors, up close and personal. Matthew Young of Buxton firing up two bidders on the way to a bought price of $1,192,000.

At 6pm Saturday the James Million-Dollar-Plus Clearance Rate on the 35 auctions we attended was 51%. Our Demand Indicator, Bidderman, was up at 1.7 – still hanging in there.

PRICE CORRECTION
There is no doubt the market has eased, “corrected” – call it what you like. One easy word to understand  is “dropped”. On a few properties it has dropped by 10% since Anzac Day.  Some homes – mostly the higher quality ones – haven’t missed a beat. But for the majority, what seems to have occurred are minor falls – although that’s hard to prove specifically.

The statements from the selling agents seem to be leaning strongly towards a “supply based correction”. At this stage we agree. If we keep seeing large amounts of stock come onto the market in June then it’s logical that prices will continue to fall, until some balance returns.

SUMMARY CLEARANCE RATES
Overall the clearance rate was 50% for 124 auctions we monitored in Port Phillip, Boroondara, Bayside and Stonnington. That’s in line with our James Million-Dollar-Plus Clearance rates – confirming it again as an accurate measure of Million-Dollar-Plus Melbourne.

• Bayside – 35 monitored – 14 bought – 40% clearance rate (last week 46%)
• Boroondara – 46 monitored – 24 bought – 52% clearance rate (last week 70% )
• Glen Eira – 9 monitored – 5 bought –  55% clearance rate (last week 55%)
• Port Phillip – 11 monitored – 6 bought – 54% clearance rate (last week 32%)
• Stonnington – 23 monitored – 15 bought – 65% clearance rate (last week 69%)

Highlights

• While 8% were not reported, indicating a reasonably high degree of accuracy for clearance rates, the numbers of unreporteds are increasing.
• Stonnington sellers seem to have made the price adjustments that some Boroondara owners (“wannabe” sellers) have not.
• Some ripper auctions included 50 Hawthorn Grove Hawthorn (Paul Keane of Jellis Craig), 23 Ferncroft Ave Malvern East and 2 Carmyle Avenue Toorak, both with Jeremy Fox of RT Edgar. These auctions saw four or five genuine bidders (well above the 1.7 Bidderman average)
• Selling in Million-Dollar-Plus Melbourne seemed a coin toss – you had as high a chance of your property passing in, as selling on the day – the first time since 2008.

SUPPLY OVERHANG BUILDS
First some stats. Last Saturday’s (May 29) Auction results showed strong evidence of “auction overhang” in Port Phillip where the clearance rate was 32% clearance rate on the 22 auctions we monitored.

Seven days later the reported clearance rate had lifted from 32% to 45%, with only three of the pass-ins and unreporteds reported as having been bought. On this evidence, it seems a stretch to say that in Port Phillip Million-Dollar-Plus homes are being bought soon after auction. There is overhang elsewhere in $Million Melbourne but not as much as Port Phillip. Which suggests the chance of bargains there.

What Supply Overhang means to you, the buyer
1. More choice, given that new stock has to compete not only with other new stock, but with old stock which hasn’t sold yet.
2.  Better pricing on all homes as there is real competition for the first time in a long while – providing of course you understand the negotiating game and know how to play it.

UNREPORTEDS
Practically all last week’s unreporteds were still for sale on Friday – suggesting that the REIV view that 50% of unreporteds are in fact sold does not seems to apply to the Million-Dollar-Plus  market.

ARE METHODS OF SALE CHANGING?
Perhaps in Bayside but not yet in other areas. Look at the latest 50 homes advertised for sale on the website www.realestateview.com.au

THE SEARCH & NEGOTIATE GAME HAS CHANGED
We feel there are at least four things all buyers should be considering:

1. Most importantly – home buying is still about best meeting your needs and taking a 5-10 year longer term view
2. You need to sharpen your methods on checking all homes – especially pass- ins
3. You need to monitor stales (old unsold homes)
4. You need to reconsider offer techniques

Let’s look at point 4 in more detail:

RECONSIDER OFFER TECHNIQUES
Let’s look at a real life example in detail: one particular property we bought today was 27 Eddys Grove, Bentleigh with Chris Hassall from Buxton. It had a quote range of $975,000 to $1,050,000. We thank our client for his permission to publish these exact figures.

From the top:

1. On pre-auction Friday we were told the property was on the market at $1,150,000 and that it would be sold that day (Friday).
2. We checked the website on Friday and saw that it still had a quote of $975,000 to $1,050,000. We asked: Would we buy it if we paid $1,150,000? We were told that we could if no better bid came in.
3. We hadn’t made a bid – so we were trying to work out how it was on the market at $1,150,000.  

First Offer Technique considerations (pre auction). What would have happened if you had bid then based on that information?

Anyway it didn’t sell, and come auction day the quote on the website and in the paper remained at $975,000 to $1,050,000. At the auction there was an opening bid of $1,000,000. Another bidder joined in and so did we – making a bid for $1,040,000. From $1,100,000 onwards we asked auctioneer Craig Williamson if the property was on the market. We were told “No” – despite the fact that each time we asked we were $50,000, $60,000 and then $70,000 above the top end of the quote. (Please note we make no claim this is out of the ordinary or an illegal practice as the REIV and CAV state this behavior is fair enough).

Second Offer Technique considerations (during auction). What happens if you had not bid, bid differently, or put in a killer bid?

Eventually the property was passed in to us at $1,120,000. We stood there in the sprinkling rain for five minutes before a Buxton salesperson came to us – they were too busy talking to the underbidders and other interested parties. My client, through us, was the last person Buxton spoke to. We are sure there is a perfectly acceptable explanation for this curious behavior. But versions of this happen at many auctions.

(Let’s point out at this point that we have good relations with Buxton Brighton and less than a fortnight ago we bought another $1m+ home through the Bentleigh office and were treated well by Ivan Blow and Craig Williamson.)

This story is not about Buxton or Chris Hassall (whom we think is a solid agent) – after all they got a good price and did nothing that many on the selling side considers untoward.  No – this story is about whether you as buyers have the right offer technique and strategies to best manage your options in this changing market. It shows the importance of good offer technique pre-auction, during the auction and post auction.

Back to 27 Eddys Grove: we were eventually given the reserve of $1,150,000 – with the additional strong advice that if we did not take it, then the underbidders would immediately be given a chance to submit their offers, and that the highest offer would win. While that would have been intimidating to the uninitiated, for us it was no problem. Technically we were being given first right of refusal.

After consulting with our client, we accepted. We felt the reserve was reasonable, we felt we needed to separate ourselves from the other bidders and our client really wanted this beautiful home. It was not a time for bravado but a time for cool heads, was our recommendation.

Third Offer Technique considerations (post auction). What happens if you decline or the stated reserve is a lot higher?

The case of Eddys Grove, like many others, begs the question of why the agent wouldn’t just quote the home at the fair reserve level of $1,150,000? That’s another story and a never ending battle with many agents. But we digress – our focus is Buyer Strategy and Offer Technique.

During any auction campaign you have three very distinct offer times: Pre, During and Post. As the going gets a little tougher for sellers so it will for buyers. So, as the stakes get higher, you will need to sharpen your offer technique before you count your chickens.

OFFER TECHNIQUE – THE CLAYTONS RESERVE  (The false reserve)

1)      What happens if you don’t know how to play the pre and post auction games? Do you join in and just keep bidding against yourself in this market; given you are possibly the only bidder – or do you miss out if there really is another bidder?

2)      What is there to stop the auctioneer at a pass-in telling you the reserve is $400,000 above the quote or their real reserve - and that if you don’t pay it they will offer it to the others? What can you do to defend yourself against a Clayton’s Reserve when you are the highest bidder playing by the stated rules? What strategies do you have?

3)      If, as a buyer you are offered a property with a Clayton’s Reserve and you refuse – does that mean the auctioneer can offer the property at a different reserve to somebody else? Or do the others have to be given the same Clayton’s reserve?  Do they come back to you? How do you as the highest bidder manage this?

For now, in the interests of our clients and to discourage this illegal behavior (The Clayton’s Reserve), in cases where we have won the right to hear the reserve and we consider we have been given a Clayton’s Reserve we will now publish (if we get our client’s permission) the agent’s name and the Clayton’s reserve given to us, We will also send a note of complaint to the REIV and ACCC. If any of our behaviour is as inappropriate as the Clayton’s Reserve, then by all means return our return serve back to any of our advocates.

We have a good many excellent selling agent relationships. They are important to us personally and professionally. We are shown many courtesies and keep many confidences (as we should and will continue to do so). However we are giving fair warning to selling agents, who, by way of example, quote $2 million and then tell us, when we have won the highest bidder right at auction, that the reserve is $2.4 million.

Agents, we would much prefer to deal fairly with you. Why abuse the auction system? If you want to do that why not use Expressions of Interest or some other method of sale?

Our offer technique management, in this instance, is to return the serve right back at you as hard as we can. We will still negotiate, but our relationship on the home in question will continue beyond the buyers and sellers signatures. If you think we are bluffing a Clayton’s Reserve from you will find us both out.

Apologies if this seems a tad emotive or self serving but the Clayton Reserves are continuing and we represent buyers and think these kinds of “Reserves” are legally and morally wrong. Simple as that.

Let’s move on.

Congratulations to Andrew McCann of Bennison Mackinnon on 115 Stanhope Grove Malvern, whose company to our knowledge is still the only publicly declared Melbourne based real estate company with reserves in their quote range. We videoed their auction today – it should be up tomorrow. Their quote was $2,100,000 to $2,300,000. The property passed in at $2,150,000 and with some negotiations was bought post auction for $2,255,000 by the buyer it passed into. That seems solid agent work. Fair buyer quoting; stated reserves.

Now let’s really move on – did you hear the joke about the leprechaun …

Buy Happy

Mal

PS  No Market News next week as its Queens Birthday Weekend and Council Wraps up tomorrow (Sunday)

Toorak 2 Carmyle: Looking like an almost drowned rat - Jeremy Fox from RT Edgar firing 3 bidders up with his banter and a smile. Bought under the hammer for $3,375,000.