16 Birdwood Avenue Brighton - James Home Ratings
James Essence
Rating: 593
Inspected: 20 August 2025
Position
This is a Golden Mile address — but it’s worth noting it’s the northern end, closer to Elwood. Families who want to be deep in Brighton’s Church Street action may see this as a little far away. But for Elwood buyers looking to step into Brighton’s prestige strip, this is right in the zone.
Land
- Size: 676sqm
- Shape: Irregular, tapering strongly at the back
- Orientation: North-facing rear, which worked beautifully on inspection — full sun in the garden, a clear positive
Property
A period-style home, smaller by Golden Mile standards but still offering plenty of accommodation:
- Five bedrooms, three bathrooms
- Parking: Tandem at the front (one behind the other) — no garage, which will deter some buyers
- Upstairs retreat: A genuine plus, providing separation and a second living option
- Feel: Simple, light, and functional — not cutting-edge or grand, but comfortable and workable
Buyer Fit
This is best suited to buyers who want a simpler offering in a prestige location. It’s not the full Brighton “statement home” package — no big garage, no sprawling backyard, and the block shape is irregular. But for families or couples who value location above all else, and can live with a more modest home, it works.
Market & Value
- Quote: Up to $6.6M
- Market Lens: For a 676sqm Golden Mile block, the ask is ambitious given the irregular shape and modest dwelling. But the address, land orientation, and accommodation will underpin interest.
- Summary View: A good entry into the Golden Mile for those who don’t need grandeur but still want the cachet and lifestyle.
Period-style 5-bed, 3-bath family home on 676sqm in Brighton’s Golden Mile. North-facing rear, upstairs retreat, tandem parking; simpler entry-level prestige offering.
askJAMES. Real answers. Only ours.
Deeper Dive: start with a question of askJAMES on this specific home such as what do we think or value or how to negotiate
AskJAMES Rating Sheet
Filled out on inspection of home

Floor plan issues

What is your Market Value ?
LandArea | Impsqm | ||||||
56 | Martin | St | BRIGHTON | 06/04/2025 | $4,300,000 | 619 | $6,947 |
42 | Martin | St | BRIGHTON | 01/03/2025 | $5,050,000 | 640 | $7,891 |
8 | Birdwood | Av | BRIGHTON | 24/03/2024 | $8,400,000 | 650 | $12,923 |
18 | Martin | St | BRIGHTON | 06/03/2024 | $5,550,000 | 419 | $13,246 |