16 Birdwood Avenue Brighton - James Home Ratings

James Essence

Rating: 593
Inspected: 20 August 2025

 

Position

This is a Golden Mile address — but it’s worth noting it’s the northern end, closer to Elwood. Families who want to be deep in Brighton’s Church Street action may see this as a little far away. But for Elwood buyers looking to step into Brighton’s prestige strip, this is right in the zone.

 

Land

  • Size: 676sqm
  • Shape: Irregular, tapering strongly at the back
  • Orientation: North-facing rear, which worked beautifully on inspection — full sun in the garden, a clear positive

 

Property

A period-style home, smaller by Golden Mile standards but still offering plenty of accommodation:

  • Five bedrooms, three bathrooms
  • Parking: Tandem at the front (one behind the other) — no garage, which will deter some buyers
  • Upstairs retreat: A genuine plus, providing separation and a second living option
  • Feel: Simple, light, and functional — not cutting-edge or grand, but comfortable and workable

 

 Buyer Fit

This is best suited to buyers who want a simpler offering in a prestige location. It’s not the full Brighton “statement home” package — no big garage, no sprawling backyard, and the block shape is irregular. But for families or couples who value location above all else, and can live with a more modest home, it works.

 

Market & Value

  • Quote: Up to $6.6M
  • Market Lens: For a 676sqm Golden Mile block, the ask is ambitious given the irregular shape and modest dwelling. But the address, land orientation, and accommodation will underpin interest.
  • Summary View: A good entry into the Golden Mile for those who don’t need grandeur but still want the cachet and lifestyle.

 


Period-style 5-bed, 3-bath family home on 676sqm in Brighton’s Golden Mile. North-facing rear, upstairs retreat, tandem parking; simpler entry-level prestige offering.

AskJAMES Rating Sheet

Filled out on inspection of home

Floor plan issues

What is your Market Value ?

      LandAreaImpsqm
56MartinStBRIGHTON06/04/2025$4,300,000619$6,947
42MartinStBRIGHTON01/03/2025$5,050,000640$7,891
8BirdwoodAvBRIGHTON24/03/2024$8,400,000650$12,923
18MartinStBRIGHTON06/03/2024$5,550,000419$13,246